Evidence for white matter disruption in traumatic brain injury without macroscopic lesions

Background

Non‐missile traumatic brain injury (nmTBI) without macroscopically detectable lesions often results in cognitive impairments that negatively affect daily life.

Aim

To identify abnormal white matter projections in patients with nmTBI with cognitive impairments using diffusion tensor magnetic resonance imaging (DTI).

Methods

DTI scans of healthy controls were compared with those of 23 patients with nmTBI who manifested cognitive impairments but no obvious neuroradiological lesions. DTI was comprised of fractional anisotropy analysis, which included voxel‐based analysis and confirmatory study using regions of interest (ROI) techniques, and magnetic resonance tractography of the corpus callosum and fornix.

Results

A decline in fractional anisotropy around the genu, stem and splenium of the corpus callosum was shown by voxel‐based analysis. Fractional anisotropy values of the genu (0.47), stem (0.48), and splenium of the corpus callosum (0.52), and the column of the fornix (0.51) were lower in patients with nmTBI than in healthy controls (0.58, 0.61, 0.62 and 0.61, respectively) according to the confirmatory study of ROIs. The white matter architecture in the corpus callosum and fornix of patients with nmTBI were seen to be coarser than in the controls in the individual magnetic resonance tractography.

Conclusions

Disruption of the corpus callosum and fornix in patients with nmTBI without macroscopically detectable lesions is shown. DTI is sensitive enough to detect abnormal neural fibres related to cognitive dysfunction after nmTBI.Cognitive and vocational sequelae are common complications after non‐missile traumatic brain injury (nmTBI) without obvious neuroradiological lesions.^1,2 They may present as memory disturbance, impairments in multitask execution and loss of self‐awareness.³ These symptoms have been attributed to diffuse brain injury and the diffuse loss of white matter or neural networks in the brain.^4,5,6 Currently no accurate method is available for diagnosing and assessing the distribution and severity of diffuse axonal injury. As computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings underestimate the extent of diffuse axonal injury and correlate poorly with the final neuropsychological outcome,^7,8 this dysfunction tends to be clinically underdiagnosed or overlooked. Indirect evidence for loss of functional connectivity after nmTBI has been provided by both morphometric and functional neuroimaging studies. Morphometric analysis of nmTBI has shown the relationship between atrophy of the corpus callosum and fornix and the neuropsychological outcome.⁹ Most functional neuroimaging studies conducted after nmTBI have shown that cognitive and behavioural disorders are correlated, with some degree of secondary hypometabolism or hypoperfusion in regions of the cortex.⁵ To date, however, there has been no direct in vivo demonstration of structural disconnections without macroscopically detectable lesions in patients with nmTBI.Diffusion tensor magnetic resonance imaging (DTI), which measures diffusion anisotropy in vivo, is a promising method for the non‐invasive detection of the degree of fibre damage in various disease processes affecting the white matter.^10,11 In biological systems, the diffusional motion of water is impeded by tissue structures, such as cell membranes, myelin sheaths, intracellular microtubules and associated proteins. Motion parallel to axons or myelin sheaths is inhibited to a lesser degree than perpendicular motion, a phenomenon known as diffusion anisotropy.¹² Fractional anisotropy was applied to evaluation of post‐traumatic diffuse axonal injury¹³ and its clinical usefulness described. In a previous study,¹⁴ fractional anisotropy score in the acute stage as an index of injury to white matter showed promise in predicting outcome in patients with traumatic brain injury, by using the regions of interest (ROIs) techniques. MRI voxel‐based analysis, a statistical normalising method, has been developed to reduce interindividual variability and to evaluate the whole brain objectively.^15,16,17 We investigated the regions in the whole brain that are commonly injured in patients having nmTBI with cognitive impairments but no macroscopic lesions, using voxel‐based analysis of fractional anisotropy, referred to as diffusion anisotropy. The advent of DTI has allowed inter‐regional fibre tracking, called magnetic resonance tractography, which reconstructs the three‐dimensional trajectories of white matter tracts.^11,18,19 We also investigated whether magnetic resonance tractography sensitively recognises degeneration of the corpus callosum and fornix in individual patients with nmTBI.