A comparison of the apical dye penetration patterns shown by methylene blue and India ink in root-filled teeth

This study compared the linear leakage patterns shown by 5% aqueous solution of methylene blue (MB) and India ink (II). One-hundred and twenty-five roots with single canals from extracted human teeth were used. The canals were cleaned and shaped using the step-back technique under copious irrigation. Three groups were arranged to receive root fillings of gutta-percha and one of three proprietary sealers using standard lateral condensation techniques: Sealapex (40 roots), Tubli-Seal (40 roots) and Ketac-Endo (20 roots). The remaining roots were used as controls: positive with gutta-percha and no sealer and negative with the apices sealed with nail varnish. The roots were randomly selected for 7-day immersion in either MB or II, then sectioned longitudinally; dye penetration was assessed using a Wild Leitz stereomicroscope. In all groups MB showed more penetration than II. The results were statistically significant at the P= 0.01 level, with the exception of the positive control groups. Negative controls showed no penetration. It is concluded that MB, which has a low molecular weight penetrated more deeply along root canal fillings than II, which has a large particle size.