Maximized combined modality treatment of an unselected population of oral and oropharyngeal cancer patients. Final results of a pilot study compared with a treatment-dependent prognosis index.

BACKGROUND: In an attempt to raise the survival of an unselected and representative population of oral and oropharyngeal squamous cell cancer patients, a pilot study of an integrated four-modality treatment was conceived. Final endpoints were compliance, loco-regional control, survival (after complete 5-year follow-up), and a concept of trial assessment using the treatment-dependent prognostic index TPI. PATIENTS: Eighty-seven consecutive patients with histologically proven untreated stages I-IV disease presented in the period between 1997 and 1999 of whom 14 had to be considered uncurable and 73 were fit to be treated with the intention of achieving a cure. METHODS: All patients received one cycle of neoadjuvant intraarterial chemotherapy with 150 mg/m(2) cisplatin (systemically neutralized with sodium thiosulphate), and, if possible, by consecutive treatment applying both surgery of the primary tumour and the neck lymphatics, as well as by adjuvant radiation over 5 weeks (51.3 Gy) plus concurrent chemotherapy (weekly systemic docetaxel 25 mg/m(2)). RESULTS: Ninety per cent of all cases and 96% of the patients treated with curative intention received more than one modality due to study design. Patient non-compliance in the group treated with curative intention has been 18/73 (=25%), and protocol compliance has been 32/73 (=44%). The locoregional control rate for all cases was 71% (62/87 patients) and for the patients treated with curative intention 83.5% (61/73 patients). Thirteen/fourteen non-curable patients died after a mean period of 4 months. After a median observation time of 5 years, the final absolute survival of the unselected population was 53%, and of the patients treated with curative intention 62% (especially, 70% and 50% for patients with operable stages III and IV, respectively). CONCLUSION: The multimodality regimen as presented proved feasible and showed high objective and relative survival rates in comparison with known data from tumour registries of unselected populations. Intra-arterial chemotherapy should be considered a valuable addition to treatment. The potential of survival benefit from this multimodality regimen in comparison with the prognosis index TPI should be investigated in further studies.