磁共振成像对类风湿关节炎诊断效率的荟萃分析

目的 系统评价磁共振成像(MRI)对于类风湿关节炎(RA)的诊断效能.方法 计算机检索国内外各主要数据库,辅以手工检索和其他检索方法,收集关于MRI诊断RA的对照试验,检索时间 1996-2009年.按照纳入标准筛选文献并提取资料,采用Meta-disc软件合并敏感性,特异性,阳性似然比,阴性似然比,诊断性试验比值比,进行异质性分析(Q-检验,I2),当P>0.10,且I2≤50%时无异质性.结果 共纳入12项随机对照试验.结果 显示病程≤2年的RA患者,滑膜炎、骨侵蚀和腱鞘炎诊断的敏感度分别为81%～100%、48%、100%~67%~96%,特异度分别为64%～89%、16%~100%~21%~74%.病程>2年的RA患者,滑膜炎、骨侵蚀诊断的敏感度分别为91%、84%,特异度分别为70%、81%.结论 MRI显示滑膜炎对于早期和中晚期RA有诊断意义,骨侵蚀和腱鞘炎对于早期RA的诊断意义有待进一步研究.纳入研究样本量小,对照组病例缺乏代表性,建议设计严谨且更大样本病例的临床研究.

Abstract：

objective To evaluate the diagnostic efficiency of magnetic resonance imaging(MRI)for rheumatoid arthritis(RA).Methods The major international databases was searched by computer and Other methods to collect control studies about MRI for the diagnosis of RA,the searching deadline was December 2009.Data were screened and extracted by inclusion criteria.Meta-disc software Was used for statistics,including sensitivity,specificity,positive likelihood ratio,negative likelihood ratio,diagnostic odds ratio(OR)and heterogeneity analysis.Results Twelve random control tests were included.Meta-analysis indicated that sensitivities of vities of synovitis,bone-erosion and tendenosynovitis were 81%~100%,48%～100%and 67%～96%while specificities of them were 64%～89%,16%~100%and 21%-74%respectively for RA patients(≤2vears).Sensitivities of synovitis and bone-erosion were 91%and 84%while specificities of them were 70%and 81%for RA Datients (>2 years).Conclusion Synovitis shown by MRI is helpful for the diagnosis of earlv and med-to-late RA.Diagnostic values of bone-erosion and tendonosynovitis demonstrated by MRI for earlv RA were not clear.The sample size of the included studies is small and some studies lack of control groupsput the conclusion of this meta-analysis liable for bias.We suggest that better designed and larger sample clinical studies are necessary.

Diagnostic efficiency of magnetic resonance imaging for rheumatoid arthritis: a systemic review and meta analysis

objective To evaluate the diagnostic efficiency of magnetic resonance imaging(MRI)for rheumatoid arthritis(RA).Methods The major international databases was searched by computer and Other methods to collect control studies about MRI for the diagnosis of RA,the searching deadline was December 2009.Data were screened and extracted by inclusion criteria.Meta-disc software Was used for statistics,including sensitivity,specificity,positive likelihood ratio,negative likelihood ratio,diagnostic odds ratio(OR)and heterogeneity analysis.Results Twelve random control tests were included.Meta-analysis indicated that sensitivities of vities of synovitis,bone-erosion and tendenosynovitis were 81%~100%,48%～100%and 67%～96%while specificities of them were 64%～89%,16%~100%and 21%-74%respectively for RA patients(≤2vears).Sensitivities of synovitis and bone-erosion were 91%and 84%while specificities of them were 70%and 81%for RA Datients (>2 years).Conclusion Synovitis shown by MRI is helpful for the diagnosis of earlv and med-to-late RA.Diagnostic values of bone-erosion and tendonosynovitis demonstrated by MRI for earlv RA were not clear.The sample size of the included studies is small and some studies lack of control groupsput the conclusion of this meta-analysis liable for bias.We suggest that better designed and larger sample clinical studies are necessary.