Stage T3a renal cell carcinoma: staging accuracy of CT for sinus fat,perinephric fat or renal vein invasion

Objective:

To study the accuracy of CT for staging T3a (TNM 2009) renal cell carcinoma (RCC).

Methods:

Unenhanced and nephrographic phase CT studies of 117 patients (male:female = 82:35; age range, 21–86 years) with T1–T3a RCC were independently reviewed by 2 readers. The presence of sinus or perinephric fat, or renal vein invasion and tumour characteristics were noted.

Results:

Median (range) tumour size was 5.5 (0.9–19.0) cm; and 46 (39%), 16 (14%) and 55 (47%) tumours were pT1, pT2 and pT3a RCC, respectively. The sensitivity/specificity for sinus fat, perinephric fat and renal vein invasion were 71/79%, 83/76% and 59/93% (Reader 1) and 88/71%, 68/72% and 69/91% (Reader 2) with κ = 0.41, 0.43 and 0.61, respectively. Sinus fat invasion was seen in 47/55 (85%) cases with T3a RCC vs 16/55 (29%) and 33/55 (60%) for perinephric fat and renal vein invasion. Tumour necrosis, irregularity of tumour edge and direct tumour contact with perirenal fascia or sinus fat increased the odds of local invasion odds ratio (OR), 2.5–3.7; p < 0.05; κ = 0.42–0.61]. Stage T3a tumours were centrally located (OR, 3.9; p = 0.0009).

Conclusion:

Stage T3a RCC was identified with a sensitivity of 59–88% and specificity of 71–93% (κ = 0.41–0.61). Sinus fat invasion was the most common invasive feature.

Advances in knowledge:

Centrally situated renal tumours with an irregular tumour edge, inseparable from sinus structures or the perirenal fascia and CT features of tumour necrosis should alert the reader to the possibility of Stage T3a RCC (OR, 2.5–3.9).Current guidelines¹ recommend nephron-sparing procedures (either partial nephrectomy or ablation) for Stage T1a (<4 cm) renal cell carcinomas (RCCs), but the indications for nephron-sparing procedures are widening.² Successful surgical series have been reported with Stage T1b (<4–7 cm) tumours and even Stage T2 RCCs.³ Central location is not necessarily a barrier to good clinical outcome after partial nephrectomy,³ but nephron-sparing procedures are contraindicated for stage ≥T3a renal cancers.¹ Thus, prior accurate recognition of T3a stage is important, especially with central renal masses, as any pre-operative suspicion of local invasion should contraindicate nephron-sparing surgery or ablation.In the most recent TNM iteration, Stage T1 and T2 tumours are defined by tumour diameter (T1a, ≤4 cm; T1b, 4–7 cm; T2a, 7–10 cm; and T2b, ≥10 cm) and the absence of any local invasion. Stage T3a RCC was redefined to include invasion of either renal sinus or perinephric fat.⁴ Renal vein invasion main renal vein and/or segmental (muscle-containing) branch invasion], without caval involvement, was downgraded from Stage T3b to Stage T3a, whilst adrenal invasion was upgraded from Stage T3a to Stage T4. Size is not a governing factor with ≥T3a tumours, and some renal masses <7 cm in diameter will be locally advanced. Nearly half of all pT3a RCCs (n = 309/623) in one study were <7 cm in diameter.⁵ Other studies have confirmed the poor prognostic significance of sinus fat or venous invasion in masses <7 cm, with a 4–6 times increased risk of cancer-related death.^6,7 Centrally located masses are more likely to demonstrate local invasion with positive surgical resection margins after partial nephrectomy,^8,9 and unrecognized sinus invasion may explain the recurrence of cancer, and subsequent death from metastatic disease, in some cases of presumed T1 RCCs.⁸However, in previous studies, CT staging has been variably accurate^10–18 for RCCs, and staging inaccuracies, usually understaging, are said to be most common with Stage T3a disease.^12,17 For venous invasion, the specificity and sensitivity have ranged between 58–97% and 32–96%,^10,14–16 and for perinephric infiltration, the figures have been 32–96% and 85–93%,^14–16 respectively. The CT accuracy for sinus fat invasion has not been previously investigated. The primary aim of this study was to define the accuracy of contrast-enhanced CT for identifying any of the three defining features of Stage T3a RCC, that is, sinus or perinephric fat invasion, or renal vein invasion. Secondary study objectives were to identify any tumour characteristics that increase the odds of T3a disease and may be used as accessory CT signs to alert the reader to an increased likelihood of local invasion by RCC.