The Impact of Method on Kidney Graft and Patient Survival in Kidney-Pancreas Transplantations for Type I Diabetes Mellitus

Patients who develop end-stage renal disease (ESRD) associated with Type I Diabetes Mellitus may receive kidney alone (KA) transplantation, simultaneous pancreas-kidney (SPK) transplantation, or a pancreas after kidney (PAK) transplantation. The goal of this study is to examine the long-term impact of pancreas transplantation on kidney graft and patient survival rates. A total of 85 transplantation cases, consisting of 30 that received living donor KA, 21 that received SPK, and 34 that received PAK, from 2003–2010 at Akdeniz University Organ Transplantation Institute were retrospectively screened. There was a graft loss in 4 cases from the KA group, and in 1 case from each of the SPK and PAK groups. The five-year kidney graft survival rates were 86.7% in KA, 95.2% in SPK, and 97.1% in PAK. There was a single patient loss in both KA and SPK. The kidney survival percentages were higher in SPK and PAK groups compared to the KA group. Therefore, SPK should be the primary preference in these patients; however, for the cases that have a living donor, pancreas transplantation should be considered after kidney transplantation, or the patients can be followed-up on with close blood sugar control.Key words: Kidney, Pancreas, Transplantation, Kidney survival, Patient survivalThe discovery of insulin in 1921 enabled the transition from diabetic ketoacidosis and diabetic coma to an increasing number of patients with prolonged life expectancies in the clinical course of diabetes mellitus (DM). However, with prolonged lifetime, increases in the neurological, ocular, and renal complications of DM have become evident. With a 40% rate, DM is the leading cause of end-stage renal disease (ESRD) in the United States.¹ In patients with type I DM-related kidney failure, kidney transplant is highly more preferable in terms of the negative effects of long-term dialysis on the patient survival and quality of life compared with the benefits of kidney transplants.² In patients who develop type I DM-related kidney failure, kidney-alone transplantation (KA) from a living donor or a cadaver, simultaneous pancreas-kidney transplantation (SPK), or pancreas-after-kidney transplantation (PAK) are among the transplantation alternatives. The 10-year life expectancy in patients receiving hemodialysis for ESRD, and in those undergoing living donor or a cadaveric renal transplantation, was reported to be 4.4, 32.9, and 59.3% in the United States, respectively.³ Similarly, while the average life expectancy for diabetes patients waiting for kidney transplantation was 8 years, the average life expectancy after kidney transplantation was determined to be 22 years.² When pancreas transplantation is added to kidney transplantation, prolonged kidney and patient survival rates can be attained along with other benefits, such as protection from the secondary effects of diabetes and an increase in patients'' quality of life. While the 4-year mortality rate in the selected dialysis patients on the waitlist for pancreas-kidney was 40%, it was 10% in patients who received SPK transplantation.⁴ The goal of this study is to compare the impact of the KA, SPK, and PAK transplantation methods on kidney graft and patient survival rates in patients with ESRD associated with type I diabetes.