Inhalation carcinogenesis from various forms of asbestos

Rats, rabbits, guinea pigs, gerbils, and mice were exposed to the inhalation of chrysotile, crocidolite, or amosite for 2 years. Mean atmospheric concentrations were 47.9–50.2 mg/m³, but only 0.08–1.82% of the dusts retained fibrous morphology during the dissemination procedure which involved hammer milling. Trace contamination especially by chromium and nickel was also increased. Light microscopic fiber counts per ml chamber air were 54 (chrysotile), 1105 (crocidolite), and 864 (amosite). A fibrogenic response to these dusts was observed in all five animal species, the severity corresponding to the extent of exposure (with reaction to chrysotile frequently very slight). Gerbils developed frequent alveolar proteinosis. Mice developed spontaneous papillary carcinomas in the lungs. Disregarding the latter species, carcinogenic response to asbestos inhalation was restricted to rats and occurred in all three exposure groups. There were 2 lung cancers and 1 pleural mesothelioma after chrysotile inhalation; 4 lung cancers after crocidolite inhalation; and 1 lung cancer and 2 pleural mesotheliomas after amosite inhalation. These cases constituted 7–9% incidence of malignancy among rats with adequate survival record. Hypotheses of asbestos carcinogenesis are reviewed and it is suggested that different etiologic principles may be involved in the causation of lung cancer and of pleural mesothelioma.