The effect of propofol vs desflurane on recovery from anesthesia with remifentanil in outpatient surgery]

OBJECTIVES: To compare the effect on parameters of postanesthetic recovery of propofol and desflurane administered with high doses of remifentanil for major outpatient surgery. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Seventy patients were randomly assigned to receive propofol (target concentration 1.5-2 microg/ml) or desflurane in perfusion (end expiratory concentration 0.5 MAC) during maintenance of anesthesia with remifentanil (0.25-1 microg/kg/min). The anesthetic agents were withdrawn after surgery. We recorded the times until eye opening, respiration, tracheal extubation, ability to cough, response to verbal orders and orientation. We also recorded the time until a score of 10 on the Aldrete recovery scale was attained, pain on a visual analog scale, sedation on the Ramsay scale, and instances of nausea or vomiting during the first 24 h after surgery. RESULTS: No statistically significant differences in patient characteristics, type of surgery or anesthesia were found. Times until early signs of postanesthetic recovery (eye opening, spontaneous breathing, tracheal extubation) were significantly less (p < 0.05) in the desflurane group. The groups were similar for all other parameters compared (times until ability to cough, respond to verbal orders, orientation and a score of 10 on the Aldrete scale). Duration of stay in the postanesthetic recovery unit, time in the day surgery ward and intensity of postoperative pain were also similar. The rate of postoperative nausea or vomiting was significantly lower in the propofol group. CONCLUSION: During anesthesia with remifentanil, the administration of desflurane is associated with better psychomotor recovery parameters than is propofol, but the rate of nausea and vomiting is higher with desflurane.