Compliance and effects of nutritional treatment on progression and metabolic disorders of chronic renal failure

Low-protein, low-phosphorus diets (LPD) are prescribed to patientswith chronic renal failure (CRF) to slow down the rate of progressionof CRF and to control uraemic symptoms. A satisfactory adherenceof patients to the prescribed diet is needed to meet these twogoals. We studied the compliance of CRF patients to a LPD providingdaily (per kg body weight) 0.3 g protein, 3–5 mg phosphorus,35 kcal, and supplemented with essential amino-acids and ketoanalogues.Forty CRF patients were studied for 23.3±10.8 months(range 12–45). Compliance to LPD was evaluated by dietaryinquiry and protein intake estimated from urinary urea excretion.According to compliance to LPD, patients were retrospectivelyassigned to the compliant (n=27) or the non-compliant (n=13)group. GFR measured by the urinary clearance of ⁵¹Cr]-EDTAwas identical in the two groups at the start of the study: compliantpatients 15.7±5.3 ml/mn, non-compliant patients 15.4±5.9ml/mn. The decrease of GFR was – 0.08±0.22 ml/minper month in compliant patients versus –0.31±0.37ml/min per month in non-compliant patients (P<0.02). Theseresults were not demonstrated if the progression of CRF wasassessed by the linear regressions over time of creatinine clearanceor the reciprocal of creatinine. Serum bicarbonate, serum phosphorusand PTH levels were corrected by LPD in compliant patients (P<0.005 for all parameters) but not in non-compliant patients.These results suggest that evaluation of compliance is necessaryto assess the response of CRF patients to LPD, whether the aimis to slow the progression of CRF or to control its metabolicconsequences. A beneficial effect of compliance to LPD was demonstratedupon these two goals.