Malignant colonic polyps: is polypectomy adequate treatment?

The management of patients with endoscopically removed malignant intestinal polyps is controversial. The risk of residual disease should be assessed against the risk of a surgical operation. The authors report 35 cases of malignant polyps (5.5% of 641 colonoscopically removed adenomas). Sixteen patients had carcinoma in situ and received no further treatment and 19 had invasive carcinoma (sessile in 6, pedunculated in 13). Of these 19, 7 did not undergo surgery--because of old age in 2, minimal invasion in 3, a low rectal location in 1 and refusal in 1. Twelve patients (3 with sessile, 9 with pedunculated polyps) underwent a surgical resection, and residual disease was present in 3 (25%), 1 with positive nodes. Reported criteria of increased risk of residual disease--cancer in lymphatics or veins, incomplete excision, tumour at resection margin, sessile and villous tumours--were present in nine. All three patients with residual disease had microscopically involved margins of resection. The authors believe that the increased risk of recurrence justifies the risk associated with subsequent surgical resection unless the patient is otherwise a poor operative risk.