Differential diagnosis of salivary acinic cell carcinoma and adenocarcinoma (NOS). A comparison of (immuno-)histochemical markers

A correct histologic differential diagnosis between salivary acinic cell carcinoma (ACC) and adenocarcinoma not otherwise specified (AC-NOS) is highly relevant because of the strikingly different biologic behavior and related therapeutical strategies. The distinction between both tumor types can be difficult because of an enormous variation in histologic appearance, with either type showing partially overlapping morphologic features. Owing to a lack of approved markers, the expression of PAS-staining, -Amylase, -1 Anti-trypsin, cytokeratin (CK)-subtypes 7/18 and Ki-67 was evaluated in 16 cases of ACC and 16 cases of AC-NOS.

CK 7 is identified as the most reliable marker with strong positivity in AC-NOS, and complete or preponderant negativity in ACC. The characteristic membranous staining pattern of CK 18 in ACC, in contrast to a diffuse cytoplasmic pattern in AC-NOS, proved to be an additional valuable criterion. PAS and -Amylase are only of little value when ACC is diagnosed, as many cases are only faintly positive or completely negative. The proliferation index (Ki-67) proved to be significantly higher in AC-NOS; however, the diagnostic usefulness is limited by a relevant overlap. In conclusion, we recommend CK 7 and 18 as the most valuable markers in cases with difficult differential diagnosis between ACC and AC-NOS.