Argyrophilic nucleolar organizer regions in colorectal malignancy: application of typing by their density

Colorectal neoplasms obtained at colonoscopy were examined by argyrophilic nucleolar organizer region (AgNOR) staining to evaluate the usefulness of AgNOR as a discriminant for malignancy. AgNOR dots were divided into two kinds: 'structures' (larger and less-densely stained) corresponding to the nucleolus, and 'units' (smaller and densely stained) presumed to be true AgNOR within the structure. The number of structures per nucleus did not differ between the adenoma and carcinoma groups, whereas the number of units per nucleus showed a significant difference. However there were several cases showing an overlap between the adenoma and carcinoma groups, leading to a difficulty in deciding whether any given case was benign or malignant. Three types of AgNOR patterns were categorized based on the ratio of units to structure. Type I was defined as the unit being indistinguishable from the structure, Type II as each structure having one to five units, and Type III as at least one structure having six or more units, irrespective of total number of units per nucleus. The colorectal lesions in which more than half of the neoplastic cells showed Type III coincided well with carcinomas histologically diagnosed, with the exception of adenomas with severe atypia. Labeling index of proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA LI) differed between the adenoma and carcinoma groups with a considerable extent of overlap, and correlated to some extent with the AgNOR values. These results showed that the AgNOR staining was useful for determining malignancy and its usefulness appeared superior to PCNA LI.