Attitudes of Roma toward smoking: qualitative study in Slovenia

Aim

To understand the reasons for widespread smoking behavior among Roma in Slovenia for the purpose of developing successful smoking cessation interventions.

Method

A qualitative focus group approach using a combination of pre-structured and open-ended questions was applied to collect the data from the representative members of the Roma community in southern Slovenia. The discussions were audiotaped and transcribed, and the collected data analyzed according to qualitative content analysis theory.

Results

The content analysis revealed that smoking was a strong part of the cultural, ethnic, and individual identity of the Roma. Even children smoked. Doctor’s advice to quit smoking was usually not followed and the attempts to quit were usually unsuccessful. Difficult financial situation was never mentioned as a possible motive to quit. Roma held a tenacious belief that the harmful effects of smoking were in the hands of destiny and did not associate the smoking-related illness with the habit.

Conclusions

Traditional strategies for smoking cessation are largely ineffective among the Roma because of their different attitudes toward smoking. Therefore, innovative and culturally acceptable methods need to be developed.According to the 2002 Census, 0.2% of inhabitants in Slovenia are Roma. However, on the basis of reports of social centers and schools, their real number could be up to four times higher than this (1). The socio-economic status, education level, and employment rate among Roma are considerably worse than among other Slovenian population, which places many of them into the category of poor people and thereby, at increased health risk.From the cultural point of view, the Roma are a highly specific ethnic minority. These once nomadic people now mostly live in poor accommodation and have difficult housing situation. The health culture of the Roma and their use of health care are low despite the fact that most of them can obtain full state-provided medical insurance irrespective of their employment status (2). Due to low hygienic and microclimatic conditions, low health education, and excessive smoking, diseases of the respiratory system seem to be among their most important health problems (3-5). Although epidemiologic data hardly exist, the Roma are known to be heavy smokers. The Roma trust in traditional folk medicine and do not believe smoking is a health-threatening habit (2). The percentage of smokers among the Roma in Slovenia is unknown. Studies from other countries show that, similar to other cardiovascular risk factors, smoking is by far more frequent in Roma than in other populations (5,6).Countries with a Roma population, whose health status is usually poor and socioeconomic position the lowest in the country (7-10), realized that research into the health status of the Roma people is needed for the planning of health intervention strategies, such as antismoking campaign (11,12). From everyday practice we know that the Roma never stop smoking and that they smoke heavily. We performed a qualitative study to understand the reasons for widespread and heavy smoking among the Roma in Slovenia for the purpose of developing more successful public health actions against smoking in their community.