Differential effect of aneuploidy on the X chromosome and genes with sex-biased expression in Drosophila

Global analysis of gene expression via RNA sequencing was conducted for trisomics for the left arm of chromosome 2 (2L) and compared with the normal genotype. The predominant response of genes on 2L was dosage compensation in that similar expression occurred in the trisomic compared with the diploid control. However, the male and female trisomic/normal expression ratio distributions for 2L genes differed in that females also showed a strong peak of genes with increased expression and males showed a peak of reduced expression relative to the opposite sex. For genes in other autosomal regions, the predominant response to trisomy was reduced expression to the inverse of the altered chromosomal dosage (2/3), but a minor peak of increased expression in females and further reduced expression in males were also found, illustrating a sexual dimorphism for the response to aneuploidy. Moreover, genes with sex-biased expression as revealed by comparing amounts in normal males and females showed responses of greater magnitude to trisomy 2L, suggesting that the genes involved in dosage-sensitive aneuploid effects also influence sex-biased expression. Each autosomal chromosome arm responded to 2L trisomy similarly, but the ratio distributions for X-linked genes were distinct in both sexes, illustrating an X chromosome-specific response to aneuploidy.Changes in chromosomal dosage have long been known to affect the phenotype or viability of an organism (1–4). Altering the dosage of individual chromosomes typically has a greater impact than varying the whole genome (5–7). This general rule led to the concept of “genomic balance” in that dosage changes of part of the genome produce a nonoptimal relationship of gene products. The interpretation afforded these observations was that genes on the aneuploid chromosome produce a dosage effect for the amount of gene product present in the cell (8).However, when gene expression studies were conducted on aneuploids, it became known that transacting modulations of gene product amounts were also more prevalent with aneuploidy than with whole-genome changes (9–14). Assays of enzyme activities, protein, and RNA levels revealed that any one chromosomal segment could modulate in trans the expression of genes throughout the genome (9–15). These modulations could be positively or negatively correlated with the changed chromosomal segment dosage, but inverse correlations were the most common (10–13). For genes on the varied segment, not only were dosage effects observed, but dosage compensation was also observed, which results from a cancelation of gene dosage effects by inverse effects operating simultaneously on the varied genes (9, 10, 14–18). This circumstance results in “autosomal” dosage compensation (14, 16–18). Studies of trisomic X chromosomes examining selected endogenous genes or global RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) studies illustrate that the inverse effect can also account for sex chromosome dosage compensation in Drosophila (15, 19–21). In concert, autosomal genes are largely inversely affected by trisomy of the X chromosome (15, 19, 21).The dosage effects of aneuploidy can be reduced to the action of single genes whose functions tend to be involved in heterogeneous aspects of gene regulation but which have in common membership in macromolecular complexes (8, 22–24). This fact led to the hypothesis that genomic imbalance effects result from the altered stoichiometry of subunits that affects the function of the whole and that occurs from partial but not whole-genome dosage change (8, 22–25). Genomic balance also affects the evolutionary trajectory of duplicate genes differently based on whether the mode of duplication is partial or whole-genome (22, 23).Here we used RNA-seq to examine global patterns of gene expression in male and female larvae trisomic for the left arm of chromosome 2 (2L). The results demonstrate the strong prevalence of aneuploidy dosage compensation and of transacting inverse effects. Furthermore, because both trisomic males and females could be examined, a sexual dimorphism of the aneuploid response was discovered. Also, the response of the X chromosome to trisomy 2L was found to be distinct from that of the autosomes, illustrating an X chromosome-specific effect. Genes with sex-biased expression, as determined by comparing normal males and females, responded more strongly to trisomy 2L. Collectively, the results illustrate the prevalence of the inverse dosage effect in trisomic Drosophila and suggest that the X chromosome has evolved a distinct response to genomic imbalance as would be expected under the hypothesis that X chromosome dosage compensation uses the inverse dosage effect as part of its mechanism (15).