A retrospective review of pharyngeal pouch surgery in 56 patients

We retrospectively reviewed 56 consecutive patients treated surgically for a pharyngeal pouch at our institution between 1989-1999 (10 years). Various surgical procedures were performed including endoscopic stapling (20), external excision (23), Dohlman's procedure (9), pouch inversion (3), cricopharyngeal myotomy only (3), and pouch suspension (1). There were 12 patients (18%) with complications and one mortality (2%). Four patients (7%) had a recurrence with 2 requiring further surgery. Over the latter 3 years, endoscopic stapling has emerged as the primary procedure for pharyngeal pouch surgery in our unit; with the advantages of an earlier commencement of diet and earlier hospital discharge. However, results were not as good as for external excisions. Furthermore, there were difficulties with 3 cases that commenced as endoscopic stapling procedures but had to he converted to external excisions due to inaccessibility in one case and iatrogenic perforations in two cases. As with any new technique, problems may occur and a learning curve has been appreciated in our unit. Surgeons must he prepared, with informed consent, to convert to an external approach should difficulties arise during endoscopic stapling. Elderly and frail patients who are at risk from a general anaesthetic may benefit from endoscopic stapling. External excision of pharyngeal pouches may be more appropriate in the young, the medically fit, and when malignancy is a concern.