Breast-sparing therapy of breast cancer: on the combination of radiation therapy with adjuvant chemotherapy

From January, 1975 through June, 1986, 426 patients with mammary carcinomas were submitted to primary, breast-preserving therapy at the Gynecological Hospital of the University of Heidelberg. 212 women with a minimum observation time of twelve months fulfilled the criteria of a "typical" treatment: tumor size up to 3 cm, segment/quadrant resection and axillary lymphonodectomy with at least eight lymph nodes removed, radiotherapy of the residual breast with greater than or equal to 45 Gy, in case of histological lymph node manifestation adjuvant hormonal and/or chemotherapy. The average observation time was 38 months, the medium age 48 years. Patients with histological lymph node manifestations were compared with a matched control group of women treated treated by modified radical therapy. According to the error estimation of Kaplan and Meier (1958), no differences were found for local recurrence rate, disease-free survival, and overall survival. Patients treated by organ-preserving therapy with adjuvant chemotherapy were opposed to a matched control group of women treated only by surgical/radiological, organ-preserving therapy. In patients with chemotherapy, the incidence of cutaneous erythema (29% versus 24%), telangiectasia (34% versus 24%), hyperpigmentation (41% versus 34%) showed an upward tendency, but was not significantly increased. There was no difference in the incidence of clinically palpable fibroses (37% versus 42%) and fibroses shown by mammography (54% versus 51%). The frequency of pneumonitis/fibrosis of the retromammary lung area (22% versus 10%) after chemotherapy was two times higher than in the matched control group not treated by chemotherapy.