小肠肿瘤诊断:双气囊小肠镜与其他检查手段的对比研究

目的比较双气囊小肠镜与小肠稀钡灌注和胶囊内镜检查在小肠肿瘤诊断中的诊断率和准确率。方法对59例临床怀疑小肠肿瘤患者行双气囊小肠镜检查。其中有34例和17例患者分别同期行插管法小肠稀钡灌注或胶囊内镜检查。检查分别由专职医师独立操作并诊断，最后进行汇总比较。结果34例小肠稀钡灌注检查者中，19例诊断为小肠肿瘤或怀疑小肠肿瘤，诊断率为55．9％，最终经双气囊小肠镜确诊为12例，诊断准确率为63．2％（12／19例）；在15例小肠稀钡灌注阴性者中，双气囊小肠镜发现肿瘤3例。17例胶囊内镜检查者中，8例检查结果为小肠肿瘤或怀疑小肠肿瘤，诊断率为47．1％，最终经双气囊小肠镜确诊为4例，诊断准确率为4／8例；在9例胶囊内镜阴性者中，双气囊小肠镜发现小肠肿瘤2例。59例患者中，经一侧进镜检查后（经口或经肛）发现小肠肿瘤36例，完成双侧检查后发现肿瘤16例。7例患者在双侧检查后未发现任何病变。双气囊小肠镜对小肠肿瘤的检出率为88．1％，并经病理和临床随访确诊。上述三项检查中未见明显的与操作相关的并发症。结论双气囊小肠镜在小肠肿瘤诊断率及准确率方面明显优于小肠稀钡灌注和胶囊内镜检查。

Comparative study on diagnostic yield and accuracy of double balloon enteroscopy with barium enteroclysis and capsule endoscopy in patients suspected with small bowel tumors

Objective To investigate the diagnostic yield and accuracy of double balloon enteroscopy, barium enteroclysis and capsule endoscopy in patients with suspicion of small bowel tumors. Methods Double balloon enteroscopy were performed in fifty nine patients with suspicion of small bowel tumors.The route of enteroscopy could be either via mouth or via anus.At the same time,34 and 17 out of 59 subjects received either barium enteroclysis or capsule endoscopy.The results of exams were analyzed independently and final diagnosis of each case was compared thereafter.Results Nineteen of 34 patients undergone the enteroclysis were diagnosed as small bowel tumor.The diagnostic yield was 55.9%.The diagnosis was finally confirmed by the enteroscopy in 12 cases,which indicated the accurate rate of enteroclysis was 63.2%(12/19).Double balloon enteroscopy detected tumors in 3 of 15 subjects with negative enteroclysis finding.The diagnostic yield of capsule endosocpy was 47.1%(8/17),and among the 8 cases diagnosis was comfirmed by the enteroscopy in 4 cases.Small bowel tumors were detected in 2 of 9 cases with negative capsule endoscopy findings.Thirty-six cases of small bowel tumor were detected by double balloon enteroscopy via a route(mouth or anus),and 16 patients were diagnosed after both route procedure.No small bowel tumor was found in 7 paitents.The overall diagnostic yield of enteroscopy was 88.1%.The diagnosis were all finally confirmed by pathological examination.No procedure-related complication were observed.Conclusion Double balloon enteroscopy is superior to enteroclysis and capsule endoscopy in diagnostic yield and accuracy for small bowel tumors.