三种口腔铸造合金耐蚀性及表面氧化膜的比较

目的 探讨3种常用口腔铸造合金模拟烤瓷前后的耐蚀性差异及氧化膜成分,以期为临床合理选择非贵金属合金提供依据.方法 用电感耦合等离子体原子发射光谱法(inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectroscopy,ICP-AES)检测模拟烤瓷前后3种常用烤瓷非贵金属合金(镍铬合金、钴铬合金、镍钛合金)在达尔伯克改良伊格尔培养液中浸泡30 d后离子析出的种类和含量.同时用X射线光电子能谱(X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy,XPS)对模拟烤瓷后合金表面生成的氧化膜进行分析,扫描电镜(SEM)对合金表面腐蚀形态进行观察.结果 模拟烤瓷前3种合金离子总质量浓度由大到小依次为镍铬合金(2.829±0.694)mg/L]、钴铬合金(2.120±0.418)mg/L]、镍钛合金(1.211±0.101)mg/L];镍铬合金组镍的质量浓度(1.531±0.392)mg/L]＞镍钛合金组(0.830±0.052)mg/L],钴和钼离子质量浓度由大到小为钴铬合金组钴:(0.048±0.011)mg/L;钼:(1.562±0.333)mg/L]、镍铬合金组钴:(0.034±0.002)mg/L;钼:(1.264±0.302)mg/L]、镍钛合金组钴:(0.013±0.006)mg/L;钼:(0.151±0.026)mg/L],差异有统计学意义(P＜0.05).模拟烤瓷后3种合金离子析出总量镍铬合金:(0.861±0.054)mg/L;钴铬合金:(0.695±0.327)mg/L;镍钛合金:(0.892±0.115)mg/L]均比未模拟烤瓷处理的合金离子析出总量少,差异有统计学意义(P＜0.05).XPS分析显示,模拟烤瓷后3种合金表面Cr2O3和钼、镍氧化物的含量增加.结论 3种常用烤瓷铸造合金中镍铬合金的离子析出量最大,耐蚀性最差;烤瓷加热处理可促进这3种合金生成连续的Cr2O3氧化膜,使合金的耐蚀性增强.

Abstract：

Objective To evaluate the types and compositions of oxide films formed during porcelain-fused-to-metal( PFM ) firing on three kinds of dental casting alloys, and to investigate the corrosion property of these alloys in Dulbecco's modification of Eagle's medium( DMEM ) cell culture fluid, before and after PFM firing. Methods Specimens of three dental casting alloys( Ni-Cr, Co-Cr and Ni-Ti) before and after PFM firing were prepared, and were immersed in DMEM cell culture fluid. After 30 days, the type and concentration of released metal ions were measured using inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectroscopy(ICP-AES). X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy(XPS) and scanning electron microscope( SEM )were used for analysis of oxide film on the alloys. One way-ANOVA was adopted in data analysis. Results The total amount of metal ions released from the three dental alloys was found to be highest in Ni-Cr alloy (2.829±0.694) mg/L], followed by Co-Cr(2. 120 ±0.418) mg/L]and Ni-Ti alloy(1.211 ±0. 101 ) mg/L]. The amount of Ni ions released from Ni-Cr alloys( 1. 531 ± 0. 392) mg/L]was higher than that from Ni-Ti alloys(0. 830 ±0. 052) mg/L]. The amount of Cr, Mo ions released from Co-Cr alloy Cr: (0. 048 ± 0. 011 ) mg/L, Mo: ( 1. 562 ± 0. 333 ) mg/L]was higher than that from Ni-Cr alloyCr:(0. 034 ±0. 002) mg/L, Mo: ( 1. 264 ±0. 302) mg/L]and Ni-Ti alloyCr: (0. 013 ±0. 006) mg/L, Mo:(0. 151 ±0. 026) mg/L](P ＜0. 05). After PFM firing, the total amount of metal irons released from the three dental alloys decreasedN i-Cr: (0. 861 ± 0. 054 ) mg/L, Co-Cr: (0. 695 ± 0. 327 ) mg/L, Ni-Ti:(0. 892 ±0. 115) mg/L](P ＜ 0. 05). In addition, XPS showed increase of Cr2O3 and Mo-Ni oxide on the surface of all the alloys after PFM firing. Conclusions The amount of ions released from Ni-Cr alloy was the highest among the three dental casting alloys, this means Ni-Cr alloy is prone to corrode. The PFM firing process changed the alloys' surface composition. Increased Ni, Cr and Mo were found in oxide film, and the increase in Cr2O3 can improve the corrosion-resistance of alloys.

Corrosion property and oxide film of dental casting alloys before and after porcelain firing

Objective To evaluate the types and compositions of oxide films formed during porcelain-fused-to-metal( PFM ) firing on three kinds of dental casting alloys, and to investigate the corrosion property of these alloys in Dulbecco's modification of Eagle's medium( DMEM ) cell culture fluid, before and after PFM firing. Methods Specimens of three dental casting alloys( Ni-Cr, Co-Cr and Ni-Ti) before and after PFM firing were prepared, and were immersed in DMEM cell culture fluid. After 30 days, the type and concentration of released metal ions were measured using inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectroscopy(ICP-AES). X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy(XPS) and scanning electron microscope( SEM )were used for analysis of oxide film on the alloys. One way-ANOVA was adopted in data analysis. Results The total amount of metal ions released from the three dental alloys was found to be highest in Ni-Cr alloy (2.829±0.694) mg/L], followed by Co-Cr(2. 120 ±0.418) mg/L]and Ni-Ti alloy(1.211 ±0. 101 ) mg/L]. The amount of Ni ions released from Ni-Cr alloys( 1. 531 ± 0. 392) mg/L]was higher than that from Ni-Ti alloys(0. 830 ±0. 052) mg/L]. The amount of Cr, Mo ions released from Co-Cr alloy Cr: (0. 048 ± 0. 011 ) mg/L, Mo: ( 1. 562 ± 0. 333 ) mg/L]was higher than that from Ni-Cr alloyCr:(0. 034 ±0. 002) mg/L, Mo: ( 1. 264 ±0. 302) mg/L]and Ni-Ti alloyCr: (0. 013 ±0. 006) mg/L, Mo:(0. 151 ±0. 026) mg/L](P ＜0. 05). After PFM firing, the total amount of metal irons released from the three dental alloys decreasedN i-Cr: (0. 861 ± 0. 054 ) mg/L, Co-Cr: (0. 695 ± 0. 327 ) mg/L, Ni-Ti:(0. 892 ±0. 115) mg/L](P ＜ 0. 05). In addition, XPS showed increase of Cr2O3 and Mo-Ni oxide on the surface of all the alloys after PFM firing. Conclusions The amount of ions released from Ni-Cr alloy was the highest among the three dental casting alloys, this means Ni-Cr alloy is prone to corrode. The PFM firing process changed the alloys' surface composition. Increased Ni, Cr and Mo were found in oxide film, and the increase in Cr2O3 can improve the corrosion-resistance of alloys.