CT- or sonography-guided biopsy of the liver in the presence of ascites: frequency of complications

The presence of ascites has been considered a contraindication to percutaneous biopsy of the liver. To determine the validity of this assumption, we performed percutaneous biopsies of the liver under CT or sonographic guidance in 28 patients who had ascites and in 28 patients who did not have ascites and compared the complication rates in the two groups. Twenty-two patients (79%) in the group with ascites and 19 patients (68%) in the group without ascites had biopsies to determine the cause or extent of chronic liver disease. The remainder were oncologic patients who had biopsies to determine the cause of a focal hepatic mass. The complication rate in the patients who had ascites (32%) was less than that in the patients who did not have ascites (43%) (the difference did not reach statistical significance, p less than .30). In the ascites group, complications included transient hypotension (five patients), a mild-to-moderate fall in hematocrit (three patients), and a small leak of ascites from the biopsy site (one patient). In the control group, minor complications included transient hypotension (three patients), a mild-to-moderate fall in hematocrit (seven patients), and a small subcapsular hematoma (one patient). One major complication occurred in the control group: a patient required a blood transfusion because of the fall in his hematocrit. We conclude that the complication rate in liver biopsies guided by CT or sonography in the presence of ascites is not higher than similar biopsies done in the absence of ascites. Ascites should not be considered a contraindication for performing such biopsies.