Bearing surfaces for total disc arthroplasty: metal-on-metal versus metal-on-polyethylene and other biomaterials

Background contextConcerns about the effect of metallic wear debris from metal-on-metal bearing surfaces in total hip arthroplasty have increased. Some spinal arthroplasty devices include metal-on-metal bearing surfaces.PurposeTo review the literature for clinical reports of complications because of wear debris from metal-on-metal spinal arthroplasty devices. To review the biology of wear debris from metal-on-metal bearing surfaces drawn from the hip arthroplasty literature and place it in the context of global regulatory actions and clinical and laboratory studies.Study designLiterature review.MethodsTo identify clinical reports, the PubMed database from the United States National Library of Medicine was queried using Medical Subject Headings terms and additional keyword terms. In addition, experts from academia and regulatory agencies were questioned regarding their knowledge of reports, including experts who attended the US Food and Drug Administration roundtable in September 2010.ResultsThree case reports and one case series including seven total cases were identified in which abnormal inflammatory reactions and soft-tissue masses after metal-on-metal disc replacements were consistent with pseudotumor and metal hypersensitivity. Spinal cases are present as pain and neurologic symptoms. On plain radiography, there is no clear periprosthetic osteolysis or loosening. On magnetic resonance imaging, there is increased magnetic susceptibility artifact because of metallic debris that renders images inadequate. Computed tomography myelography demonstrates a soft-tissue mass, which exhibits epidural extension surgically. Histologically, large areas of necrotic debris and exudates are interspersed with chronic inflammatory cells. Lymphocyte or macrophage predominance is determined by the rate of wear and the presence of gross, microscopic, or submicron metallic wear debris. The metallurgy of the involved devices is cobalt-chromium-molybdenum (CoCrMo) alloy, and the bearing surface is CoCrMo-on-CoCrMo.ConclusionsMetal-on-metal spinal arthroplasty devices are subject to postoperative complications because of metallic wear debris with similar clinical, radiographic, histologic, gross anatomic, and device-related features to those found in metal-on-metal bearing surfaces in total hip arthroplasty.