The effect of patient ethnicity on the accuracy of peripheral pulse oximetry in patients with COVID-19 pneumonitis: a single-centre,retrospective analysis

Pulse oximetry is used widely to titrate oxygen therapy and for triage in patients who are critically ill. However, there are concerns regarding the accuracy of pulse oximetry in patients with COVID-19 pneumonitis and in patients who have a greater degree of skin pigmentation. We aimed to determine the impact of patient ethnicity on the accuracy of peripheral pulse oximetry in patients who were critically ill with COVID-19 pneumonitis by conducting a retrospective observational study comparing paired measurements of arterial oxygen saturation measured by co-oximetry on arterial blood gas analysis (SaO₂) and the corresponding peripheral oxygenation saturation measured by pulse oximetry (S_pO₂). Bias was calculated as the mean difference between SaO₂ and S_pO₂ measurements and limits of agreement were calculated as bias ±1.96 SD. Data from 194 patients (135 White ethnic origin, 34 Asian ethnic origin, 19 Black ethnic origin and 6 other ethnic origin) were analysed consisting of 6216 paired SaO₂ and S_pO₂ measurements. Bias (limits of agreement) between SaO₂ and S_pO₂ measurements was 0.05% (−2.21–2.30). Patient ethnicity did not alter this to a clinically significant degree: 0.28% (1.79–2.35), −0.33% (−2.47–2.35) and −0.75% (−3.47–1.97) for patients of White, Asian and Black ethnic origin, respectively. In patients with COVID-19 pneumonitis, S_pO₂ measurements showed a level of agreement with SaO₂ values that was in line with previous work, and this was not affected by patient ethnicity.     

Carbon blacks as EPR sensors for localized measurements of tissue oxygenation.

New electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) oximetry probes were identified in the class of carbon black materials. These compounds exhibit very high oxygen sensitivity and favorable EPR characteristics for biological applications. At low pO(2), the linewidth is particularly sensitive to changes in oxygen tension (sensitivity of 750 mG/mmHg). The application of the probes for oximetry was demonstrated in vivo: the pO(2) was measured in muscle in which the blood flow was temporarily restricted as well as in tumor-bearing mice during a carbogen breathing challenge. The responsiveness to pO(2) was stable in muscle for at least 3 months. No toxicity was observed using these materials in cellular experiments and in histological studies performed 2, 7, and 28 days after implantation. In view of their EPR characteristics (high sensitivity) as well as the well-characterized production procedure that make them available on a large scale, these probes can be considered as very promising tools for future developments in EPR oximetry.     

Continuous measurement of oxygen consumption using the reversed fick method

We developed a continuous oxygen consumption (Vo₂) measurement system employed the reversed Fick method, in which Vo₂ in computed from continuously measured sured arterial and mixed venous oxygen saturation assed by pulse oximetry and mixed venous oximetry, respectively, and cardiac output by the heat deprivation technique. This system was compared with the conventional intermittent reversed fick method in 7 patients during surgery and with indirect calorimetry in 4 intensive care unit (ICU) patients. The Vo₂ measured by the continuous reversed Fick method showed a high correlation with those simultaneously measured by the intermittent Fick method (r=0.97,P<0.01) and by indirect calorimetry (r=0.74,P<0.01). The 95% confidence limits (bias±2 SD) of the continuous reversed Fick method were −0.6±45 ml·min⁻¹ with the intermittent Fick method and −31±56 ml·min⁻¹ with indirect calorimetry. The continuous Fick method is in satisfactory agreement with the conventional methods for the measured of Vo₂ and potentially allows for convenient assessment of Vo₂ in critically ill patients. This study was supported in part by Grants-in-Aid for the Encouragement of Young Scientists 01771185 and 04857171 from the Ministry of Education, Science and Culture of Japan     

Use of epr oximetry with india ink to measure the po2 in the liver in vivo in mice

The partial pressure of oxygen (pO₂) of the liver in vivo in unanesthetized mice was determined using electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) oximetry with India ink. The EPR spectra were obtained using a low-frequency (1.2 GHz) EPR spectrometer with a loop gap cavity resonator. The line width of the India ink used in this experiment was reversibly broadened by oxygen and was particularly sensitive to pO₂ below 30 torr. After the administration of India ink into the tail vein, the India ink particles were taken up mainly by Kupffer cells in the liver and in part by phagocytes in the spleen. The pO₂ measured in the normal liver was about 14 torr and was constant for the 2-week experimental period. The pO₂ decreased when measured at 1, 2, and 6 days after treatment with a hepatotoxin (carbon tetrachloride (CCI₄)); within 2 weeks, it returned almost to the initial level. Measurements by EPR at sacrifice of controls and CCI₄-treated mice indicated that more than 90% of the India ink went to the liver; the spleen contained 4.7% of total amount in control mice and 8.8% in CCI₄-treated mice when measured 2 weeks after the treatment. These data indicate the usefulness of India ink for measuring the pO₂ of the liver in vivo and that the pO₂ in the Kupffer cells is decreased when the liver is damaged by CCI₄.     

Can people hear the pitch change on a variable-pitch pulse oximeter?

The introduction of the variable-pitch feature on pulse oximeters in 1983 by the Nellcor Corporation (Hayward, CA) allowed users to rapidly detect changes in oxygen saturation by listening for changes in the pitch of the tones emitted by the pulse oximeter. A few individuals have reported that they have been unable to detect a change in pitch when oxygen saturation changes. To these individuals, the variable-pitch feature of these pulse oximeters has not been beneficial. Using the pitches from one manufacturer of oximeters, we created a computer program to simulate the pitches that accompanied various oxygen saturations. The pitches were recorded onto a tape player and played for 75 volunteer subjects unfamiliar with the pitches of a variable-pitch pulse oximeter. Of our sample, 67% were able to detect a single change in pitch corresponding to a 1% fall in oxygen saturation, and 11% of the population could not detect a change in pitch until there was a change in pitch with every beat. We suggested four alternative designs that may prove beneficial to this group of individuals.     

Computer analysis system of blood oxygen saturation in an animal hypoxia model

An experimental animal hypoxia model has been developed. It consists of two sensors (an in vitro and in vivo model), an experimental device and a computer signal processing system. This method can easily be applied to determine and analyse blood oxygen saturation at various hypoxia levels. It can also be used to evaluate the accuracy of pulse oximetry over a wide range of oxyhemoglobin desaturation levels. The DC and AC components of recorded red and infra-red signals, the dual-wavelength ratio R₁₂ and the reading of a pulse oximeter (SpO₂) can be automatically calculated and displayed on a computer screen. Preliminary results of the animal hypoxia test indicate that the measurements made by the instrument correlate well with the oxygen saturation readings of the automatic blood gas analyser AVL945. The computer analysis system is suitable for repeated estimations in the animal model.     

Evaluation of a new reflectance pulse oximeter for clinical applications

The design of a noninvasive reflectance pulse oximeter that uses the same principle of transmittance pulse oximeter and analyses the oxygen saturation of arterial blood was described. Four sets of red and infra-red LEDs were used as light sources. The respective reflectance photoelectric outputs were used to make an internal calibration curve of the instrument relative to the arterial oxygen saturation values measured with a Co-Oximeter (OSM-3) in five healthy nonsmoking subjects during steady-state hypoxaemia. The accuracy of the present instrument was studied in six patients with respiratory failure. From 22 samples, a good correlation coefficient (0.98) with a standard deviation of 1.42 was obtained in the range between 73 and 100 per cent between the arterial oxygen saturation measured with the present instrument and that with the Co-Oximeter. The result strongly suggests the usefulness of this oximeter in monitoring patients with hypoxaemia.     

Accuracy of pulse oximetry at various haematocrits and during haemolysis in anin vitro model

In situations in which it may be impossible and/or unethical to evaluate pulse oximetry in humans, an in vitro model with circulating blood may be a necessity. The main objective was to develop such an in vitro model and, in this model, validate the pulse oximetry technique at various haematocrit levels. The pulsating character of arterial blood flow in a tubing system was simulated by using a specially constructed pressure-regulated roller pump. The tubing system was designed to minimise damage to red blood cells. The pulse oximeter readings (SpO₂) were compared with oxygen saturation analyses by a haemoximeter (SaO₂). The pulse oximetry readings were recorded at various haematocrit levels and during haemolysis in the SaO₂ range 60–100 per cent. At a haematocrit level of 41–44 per cent, there was no correlation between SaO₂ and SpO₂ readings. After diluting the blood with normal saline to a haematocrit of 10–11 per cent, a good correlation between SaO₂ and SpO₂ was found. Following haemolysis, the agreement between SaO₂ and SpO₂ was further improved. Using the developed in vitro model, the results indicate that the accuracy of a pulse oximeter may be dependent on the haematocrit level.