A reinvestigation of the analgesic effects induced by stimulation of the periaqueductal gray matter in the rat. I. The production of behavioral side effects together with analgesia

It has been shown that stimulation-produced-analgesia (SPA) in the cat elicited from the periaqueductal gray matter (PAG) is obtained from sites located in the ventral part, particularly the dorsal raphé nucleus (DRN). These data contrast with the numerous studies performed in the rat in which efficient sites seem widely distributed throughout the PAG. These discrepancies led us to reinvestigate SPA from PAG and adjacent structures in the rat. Central stimulation was delivered through bipolar concentric electrodes (one for each animal). Analgesia was evaluated (before and during central stimulation) by measuring the modification in the vocalization threshold induced by electrical tail shocks or by considering the reaction of the animal to pinch. In contrast with the majority of previous studies, these experiments were performed on the totally freely-moving rat. The most striking result was that, in order to obtain analgesia from all regions of the PAG, it was necessary to apply intensities of central stimulation which also triggered other strong behavioral reactions. With intensities of PAG stimulation which did not induce such side effects, very few effective analgesic sites were found (21/129 sites of which 14/83 were strictly located in the PAG). However, it was possible to define two 'pure analgesic regions', both located in the ventral PAG: one centered on the dorsomedial part of the DRN and the other one situated in the ventrolateral PAG. No modification of nociceptive thresholds was observed when stimulating the dorsal and dorsolateral parts of the PAG as well as structures adjacent to these regions; in some rats, an increase in pain reactivity was even noted. When the intensity of central stimulation (applied to the various parts of the PAG) was increased, some stereotyped 'behavioral responses' occurred depending on the location of the stimulation site: motor effects (gnawing, rotation or tremor) in the ventral PAG and aversive effects (flight, jumping and on occasions, distress vocalizations) in the dorsal, dorsolateral PAG and in the ventral region just surrounding the cerebral aqueduct. Under these conditions, analgesia was obtained from practically the entire PAG, the vocalization threshold being increased dramatically on occasions. It must be emphasized that antinociceptive effects associated with other obvious behavioral manifestations (aversive ones) were also obtained from sites located outside the PAG (colliculi and tectum adjacent to the dorsal and dorsolateral PAG).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

A reinvestigation of the analgesic effects induced by stimulation of the periaqueductal gray matter in the rat. II. Differential characteristics of the analgesia induced by ventral and dorsal PAG stimulation

This study consists of a detailed analysis of the analgesic effects induced by stimulation of the various parts of the periaqueductal gray matter (PAG) in the freely moving rat. In order to characterize the analgesia, two criteria are considered: (1) the evaluation of the degree of analgesia and behavioral side effects evoked during central stimulation; and (2) the presence of post-effects. Central stimulation (50 Hz sine waves) was delivered via bipolar concentric electrodes and analgesia was quantified by the change in the vocalization threshold induced by electrical stimulation of the tail. Within the ventral PAG, the vocalization threshold increased gradually with the intensity of the central stimulation, the degree of analgesia generally being powerful. There was no relationship between the strength of the analgesic effects and the motor disturbances also produced by stimulation of this region. Antinociceptive effects generally disappeared when the stimulation ceased. Only when the intensity of the stimulation was strong enough to induce very powerful analgesic effects were post-stimulation analgesic effects noticed. Within the dorsal and dorsolateral PAG as well as in the ventral region just surrounding the aqueduct, analgesia appeared suddenly, was generally less pronounced and was always concomitant with strong aversive reactions. In contrast with the analgesia from the ventral PAG, marked post-effects were observed. These latter characteristics were also obtained from stimulation of regions located outside the PAG (colliculi, intercollicular commissure and tectum adjacent to the dorsolateral PAG) although these zones were not extensively studied. By consideration of various data in the literature, it is concluded from this study, which clearly distinguishes stimulation-produced-analgesia (SPA) from ventral PAG versus dorsal PAG, that analgesia induced from this midbrain area involves at least two different neuronal substrates. Whilst the ventral PAG seems to be more preferentially involved in pain modulation, the authenticity of 'analgesia' triggered by stimulation of aversive regions (which are widely spread over the PAG) is questioned and proposals to explain the simultaneous appearance of analgesic effects and aversion are considered.