Análisis coste-efectividad de samario-153 (Quadramet®) en el tratamiento del dolor en pacientes con cáncer de próstata y metástasis óseas

Objective. To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of samarium [¹⁵³Sm-EDTMP] (Quadramet®) compared to conventional therapy in the treatment of pain in patients with prostate cancer and bone metastases. Method. A decision tree model for the treatment of bone pain due to metastases was adapted to the Spanish context. The model represents the standard treatment patterns in Spain for the study population. The time-course of the model is 4 months and it computes an estimate for the cost of pain control per patient. The effectiveness data for the model derive from a randomised trial. The current treatment patterns have been established according to the consensus opinions of a group of medical experts. Results. The cost of pain control per patient is ? 12,515.39 for conventional therapy and ? 5,595.52 for samarium-153 (Quadramet®) therapy. The incremental cost-effectiveness analysis shows that samarium-153 (Quadramet®) is a dominant therapy. It presents lower costs and higher efficacy than the conventional strategy. The sensitivity analyses showed these results to be robust. Conclusion. Samarium-153 (Quadramet®) is costeffective in treating pain in patients with prostate cancer and bone metastases.     

Diversity of patient preparation activities before initiation of antiretroviral therapy in Cape Town,South Africa

Objective  To investigate patient education and counseling activities prior to the initiation of antiretroviral therapy (ART) at public sector services across Cape Town, South Africa. Methods  Key informant interviews and programme reviews were conducted with government bodies and non‐governmental organisations involved in patient preparation activities. Results  All 11 organisations in Cape Town involved in training and managing personnel to prepare patients for ART during 2010 participated. Each organisation reported a different approach to patient preparation within public sector clinics and in each aspect of patient preparation activities. The number of patient education sessions ranged from 3 to 7, and the delays to ART initiation introduced by patient preparation ranged from 3 to 6 weeks. Different patient education materials (pamphlets, posters and flipcharts) were used by various programmes, and all programmes reported that shortages in materials meant that patient preparation often took place without any educational materials. Each programme also reported attention to mental illness and alcohol/substance use disorders, but none employed formal screening tools consistently, and the handling of patients with potential mental health‐ or substance‐related problems varied. Conclusion  Approaches to prepare patients before ART initiation are wide ranging in one part of South Africa. Their relative value requires investigation, as there is little evidence for the impact of varying approaches. Moreover, the risks associated with delayed ART initiation may outweigh any benefits of patient education before the start of treatment.     

Análisis de supervivencia en investigación cardiovascular (II): metodología estadística en situaciones complejas

This article is the second of a series of 2 educational articles. In the first article, we described the basic concepts of survival analysis, summarizing the common statistical methods and providing a set of recommendations to guide the strategy of survival analyses in randomized clinical trials and observational studies. Here, we introduce stratified Cox models and frailty models, as well as the immortal time bias arising from a poor assessment of time-dependent variables. To address the issue of multiplicity of outcomes, we provide several modelling strategies to deal with other types of time-to-event data analyses, such as competing risks, multistate models, and recurrent-event methods. This review is illustrated with examples from previous cardiovascular research publications, and each statistical method is discussed alongside its main strengths and limitations. Finally, we provide some general observations about alternative statistical methods with less restrictive assumptions, such as the win ratio method, the restrictive mean survival time, and accelerated failure time model.     

Assessing the impact of a school-based water treatment, hygiene and sanitation programme on pupil absence in Nyanza Province, Kenya: a cluster-randomized trial

Objectives There has been increased attention to access to water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH) at schools in developing countries, but a dearth of empirical studies on the impact. We conducted a cluster‐randomized trial of school‐based WASH on pupil absence in Nyanza Province, Kenya, from 2007 to 2008. Methods Public primary schools nested in three geographical strata were randomly assigned and allocated to one of three study arms [water treatment and hygiene promotion (WT & HP), additional sanitation improvement, or control] to assess the effects on pupil absence at 2‐year follow‐up. Results We found no overall effect of the intervention on absence. However, among schools in two of the geographical areas not affected by post‐election violence, those that received WT and HP showed a 58% reduction in the odds of absence for girls (OR 0.42, CI 0.21–0.85). In the same strata, sanitation improvement in combination with WT and HP resulted in a comparable drop in absence, although results were marginally significant (OR 0.47, 0.21–1.05). Boys were not impacted by the intervention. Conclusion School WASH improvements can improve school attendance for girls, and mechanisms for gendered impacts should be explored. Incomplete intervention compliance highlights the challenges of achieving consistent results across all settings.     

Methodology matters: what type of research is suitable for evaluating community treatment supporters for HIV and tuberculosis treatment?

The choice of research method relevant to the evaluation of delivery of a health intervention is not always straightforward. We use the evaluation of HIV and tuberculosis community treatment supporters in promoting adherence to treatment in Africa as a case study to illustrate the pros and cons of operational research and randomised controlled trials. The choice of this intervention for the case study reflects the importance of maximising the benefits of unprecedented efforts to scale-up treatments of these two epidemics. International policy supporting the role of community treatment supporters in tuberculosis is largely based on the findings of operational research studies. This reflects the advantages that operational research is less costly than randomised controlled trials, provides more rapid answers to policy questions, enables standard evaluation of the intervention in 'real life' conditions in several diverse settings and has in-built potential to influence policy and practice, because the research is conducted within health programmes. Recent evidence on the role of community treatment supporters in HIV is largely based on randomised trials. This reflects the advantages that randomised trials compared to operational research are more rigorous and generate a more convincing result. Operational research and randomised trials may be viewed as providing complementary findings to inform new policies and practice aimed at improving programme performance and patient outcomes. However, in practice, insufficient funds are likely to be made available for randomised trials to answer all the current research questions on delivery of programme interventions. In deciding on the type of research to evaluate a particular health intervention, dialogue is necessary with policy-makers to weigh up explicitly the trade-offs between research rigour and other factors such as cost, speed of implementation of research and speed of policy uptake and of change in programme practice.     

Socioeconomic differences in diabetes prevalence, awareness, and treatment in rural southwest China

Objective To examine how socioeconomic differences are related to the prevalence, awareness and treatment of diabetes in rural Yunnan province, a relatively undeveloped province in southwest China. Methods A cross‐sectional survey was conducted from 2008 to 2010; 10 007 consenting individuals aged ≥18 years were selected to participate in the study using a stratified, multistage sampling technique. Information about participants’ demographic characteristics, smoking habits, drinking habits, awareness and treatment of diabetes, and family history of diabetes were obtained using a standard questionnaire. Height, weight, waist circumference, hip circumference, fasting blood sugar level and blood pressure were also measured for each individual. Data were analysed using multivariate logistic regression. Results The age‐standardised presence of diabetes was 6.8% in the study population. In diabetic subjects, 28.7% were aware that they had diabetes, and 22.6% had received treatment. After controlling for age, sex, smoking behaviour, drinking behaviour, hypertension, being overweight, central obesity and family history of diabetes, individual educational level was negatively associated with the prevalence of diabetes and positively associated with the awareness and treatment of diabetes. The awareness and treatment of diabetes showed a negative relationship with ethnic minority status and a positive relationship with individual household income. Conclusions There are low levels of awareness and treatment among individuals living with diabetes in rural southwest China. Strategies that can enhance public awareness of diabetes and increase access to affordable medications are urgently needed, especially for poor, less educated individuals who belong to ethnic minorities.     

Encuesta SEGO. Tratamiento de la amenaza de parto pretérmino en los hospitales españoles

Objective

To determine how threatened preterm labor is treated in Spanish hospitals.

Material and method

Under the aegis of the Spanish Society of Obstetrics and Gynecology, an Internet questionnaire on basic aspects of the treatment of threatened preterm labor was sent to 41 Spanish hospitals (37 public and four private hospitals).

Results

All hospitals use tocolysis in threatened preterm labor before 34th weeks. The most widely used tocolytic agent is atosiban (73,7%), followed by betamimetics (21.9%) and nifedipine (4.9%). Only 7.3% of the hospitals use tocolytics in threatened preterm labor after 34 weeks. All the hospitals use corticosteroids to accelerate lung maturation: 92.7% use betamethasone and 7.3% prefer dexamethasone. In 90% of the hospitals, steroid therapy is not repeated. In multiple pregnancies, the same steroid dose as that used in single pregnancies is administrated in all centers.

Conclusions

The most widely used tocolytic agent in Spanish hospitals is atosiban and the preferred corticosteroid is betamethasone.