End-tidal Carbon Dioxide Monitoring during Procedural Sedation

OBJECTIVE: To prospectively determine whether end-tidal carbon dioxide (ETCO2) monitors can detect respiratory depression (RD) and the level of sedation in emergency department (ED) patients undergoing procedural sedation (PS). METHODS: This was a prospective observational study conducted in an urban county hospital of adult patients undergoing PS. Patients were monitored for vital signs, depth of sedation per the physician by the Observer's Assessment of Alertness/Sedation scale (OAA/S), pulse oximetry, and nasal-sample ETCO2 during PS. Respiratory depression was defined as an oxygen saturation <90%, an ETCO2 >50 mm Hg, or an absent ETCO2 waveform at any time during the procedure. The physician also determined whether protective airway reflexes were lost during the procedure and assisted ventilation was required, or whether there were any other complications. Rates of RD were compared with the physician assessment of airway loss and between agents using chi-square statistics. Spearman's rho analysis was used to determine whether there was a correlation between ETCO2 and the OAA/S score. RESULTS: Seventy-four patients were enrolled in the study. Forty (54.1%) received methohexital, 21 (28.4%) received propofol, ten (13.5%) received fentanyl and midazolam, and three (4.1%) received etomidate. Respiratory depression was seen in 33 (44.6%) patients, including 47.5% of patients receiving methohexital, 19% receiving propofol (p = 0.008), 80% receiving fentanyl and midazolam, and 66.6% receiving etomidate. No correlation between OAA/S and ETCO2 was detected. Eleven (14.9%) patients required assisted ventilation at some point during the procedure, all of whom met the criteria for RD. Pulse oximetry detected 11 of the 33 patients with RD. Post-hoc analysis revealed that all patients with RD had an ETCO2 >50 mm Hg, an absent waveform, or an absolute change from baseline in ETCO2 >10 mm Hg. CONCLUSIONS: There was no correlation between ETCO2 and the OAA/S score. Using the criteria of an ETCO2 >50 mm Hg, an absolute change >10 mm Hg, or an absent waveform may detect subclinical RD not detected by pulse oximetry alone. The ETCO2 may add to the safety of PS by quickly detecting hypoventilation during PS in the ED.     

Carbon dioxide analysers: accuracy,alarm limits and effects of interfering gases

Six mainstream and twelve sidestream infrared carbon dioxide (CO₂) analysers were tested for accuracy of the CO₂ display value, alarm activation and the effects of nitrous oxide (N₂O), oxygen (O₂) and water vapour according to the ISO Draft International Standard (DIS) #9918. Mainstream analysers (M-type): Novametrix Capnogard 1265; Hewlett Packard HP M1166A (CO₂module HP M1016A); Datascope Passport; Marquette Tramscope 12; Nellcor Ultra Cap N-6000; Heilige Vicom-sm SMU 611/612 ETC. Sidestream analysers: Brüel &; Kjaer Type 1304; Datex Capnomac II; Marquette MGA-AS; Datascope Multinex; Ohmeda 4700 OxiCap (all type S1: respiratory cycles not demanded); Biochem BCI 9000; Bruker BCI 9100; Dräger Capnodig and PM 8020; Criticare Poet II; Heilige Vicom-sm SMU 611/612 A-GAS (all type S2: respiratory cycles demanded). The investigations were performed with premixed test gases (2.5, 5, 10 vol%, error ?1% rel.). Humidification (37° C) of gases were generated by a Dräger Aquapor. Respiratory cycles were simulated by manually activated valves. All monitors complied with the tolerated accuracy bias in CO₂ reading (≤ 12% or 4 mmHg of actual test gas value) for wet and dry test gases at all concentrations, except that the Marquette MGA-AS exceeded this accuracy limit with wet gases at 5 and 10 vol% CO₂. Water condensed in the metal airway adapter of the HP M1166A at 37° C gas temperature but not at 3(P C. The Servomex 2500 (nonclinical reference monitor), Passport (M-type), Multinex (S1-type) and Poet II (S2-type) showed the least bias for dry and wet gases. Nitrous oxide and O₂ had practically no effect on the Capnodig and the errors in the others were max. 3.4 mmHg, still within the tolerated bias in the DIS (same as above). The difference between the display reading at alarm activation and the set point was in all monitors (except in the Capnodig: bias 1.75 mmHg at 5 vol% CO₂) below the tolerated limit of the DIS (difference ≤ 0.2 vol%). The authors conclude that the tested monitors are safe for clinical use (except those failing the DIS limits). The accuracy of the CO₂-reading (average of mean absolute bias) is better in the M-type than in the S1- or S2- type analysers although no statistical (nor clinical) significant differences could be detected. Most manufacturers work with stricter limits than those proposed by the DIS.     

Stability of the intra-operative arterial to end-tidal carbon dioxide partial pressure difference in children with congenital heart disease

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the stability of the arterial PCO2 (PaCO2) to end-tidal PCO2 (PETCO2) partial pressure difference (Pa-ETCO2) during surgery using PETCO2 monitoring, in children with congenital heart disease (CHD). Forty children with CHD were studied: ten children with no interchamber communication and normal pulmonary blood flow (PBF) (normal group); ten acyanotic children with increased PBF (acyanotic-shunting group); ten cyanotic children with mixing type lesions and normal or increased PBF (mixing group), and ten cyanotic children with right-to-left intracardiac shunts demonstrating decreased and variable PBF (cyanotic-shunting group). Simultaneous PaCO2 recordings and PETCO2 measurements were obtained for each patient during five intraoperative events: (1) control time, arterial line placement under anaesthesia; (2) time 1, patient preparation; (3) time 2, immediately after sternotomy; (4) time 3, after heparin administration; and (5) time 4, immediately after aortic cannulation. Initially, cyanotic children demonstrated a greater Pa-ETCO2 compared with acyanotic children (P less than 0.05). There was no difference in the Pa-ETCO2 over time in the control, acyanotic-shunting, or mixing groups. The Pa-ETCO2 in the children with cyanotic-shunting lesions at times 2 and 3 was greater (P less than 0.05) than at their control times. We conclude that the Pa-ETCO2 of children with acyanotic-shunting and mixing congenital heart lesions is stable intraoperatively, although patients with mixing congenital heart lesions may demonstrate large individual variations. In children with cyanotic-shunting congenital heart lesions, the Pa-ETCO2 is not stable. The PETCO2 cannot be used during surgery to estimate reliably the PaCO2 in children with cyanotic CHD.     

Should we monitor alveolar and inspiratory concentrations of anesthetic and respiratory gases?

One essayist suggests that continuous monitoring of alveolar and inspiratory concentrations of anesthetic and respiratory gases has little or no positive effect on patient outcome and may even be detrimental to patients. Such monitoring, he says, tends to remove anesthesiologists from personal contact with their patients. He recommends careful monitoring of fresh gas concentrations leaving the anesthetic machine, careful monitoring of inspired gas in a circle absorption breathing system, and improved training of anesthesiologists to prevent human error. Another essayist suggests that continuous monitoring of alveolar and inspiratory concentrations of anesthetic and respiratory gases is cost-effective and relatively simple. He says that such monitoring, without being a source of legal problems for its users, improves the quality of patient care.     

Capnography does not reliably detect double-lumen endotracheal tube malplacement

Two patients are described in whom double-lumen endotracheal tube malplacement and its ventilatory consequences were not detected by infrared capnography. Problems were suspected on auscultation, and the malplacement was diagnosed by means of bronchospirometry. We conclude that bronchospirometry helps detect problems with endotracheal intubation.     

Sublingual capnometry tracks microcirculatory changes in septic patients

Objective To test the hypothesis that microcirculatory blood flow is the main determinant of sublingual carbon dioxide pressure in patients with septic shock. Design Prospective, open-label study Setting A 31-bed medico-surgical department of intensive care. Patients Eighteen consecutive mechanically ventilated patients with septic shock. Interventions A 5 μg/kg · min dobutamine infusion was used to increase blood flow. Methods Sublingual carbon dioxide pressure was monitored using a microelectrode sensor, and sublingual microcirculation was assessed using orthogonal polarization spectral imaging. The sublingual carbon dioxide pressure gap was calculated as the difference between sublingual and arterial carbon dioxide pressures. In each patient, a nasogastric tonometry catheter was inserted for gastric mucosal carbon dioxide pressure measurement. The gastric carbon dioxide pressure gap was calculated as the difference between gastric mucosal and arterial carbon dioxide pressures. Measurements and results Dobutamine infusion was associated with increases cardiac index and mixed venous blood oxygen saturation. Dobutamine infusion resulted in decreases in sublingual carbon dioxide pressure gap from 40 ± 15 to 17 ± 8 mmHg (p < 0.01). There was a significant correlation between sublingual and gastric mucosal carbon dioxide pressures (r ² = 0.61, p < 0.05). At baseline, sublingual carbon dioxide pressure gap correlated with the proportion of well-perfused capillaries (r ² = 0.80). The decrease in sublingual carbon dioxide pressure gap paralleled the increase in the proportion of well-perfused capillaries in each patient. Conclusions Regional microcirculatory blood flow is the main determinant of sublingual carbon dioxide pressure. Sublingual capnometry could represent a simple, non-invasive method to monitor these microcirculatory alterations in septic patients. This article is discussed in the editorial     

Capnographic Monitoring in Respiratory Emergencies

Capnography provides a noninvasive, real-time means for assessing ventilatory status, just as pulse oximetry reflects a patient's oxygenation. The widespread availability of portable and bedside end-tidal monitors has allowed for increased use in EDs. Although capnography is best known as a rapid and accurate means for confirming endotracheal intubation, recent studies have supported its utility in managing nonintubated pediatric patients with respiratory illnesses. In particular, waveform analysis in patients with obstructive lung disease may offer valuable information regarding disease severity and disposition. In addition, the introduction of computerized analysis programs has paved the way for the development of increased systematic and automated interpretation of capnographic data. In the future, we are likely to see growing clinical application of this technology as an integral component in the evaluation of patients presenting to the ED with significant respiratory illness.     

Advantage of buffered solutions or automated capnometry in air-filled balloons for use in gastric tonometry

Objective: To test accuracy, reproducibility and time constants of pCO₂ measurement with the tonometric technique, using different media for filling the silastic balloon (saline, phosphate buffer, citrate buffer, air) and employing different analyzer devices (ABL3, ABL330, Nova Stat 5, automated capnometry). Design: Comparative laboratory study of different tonometric techniques, measuring test solutions with known pCO₂ values due to pre-equilibration with three different pCO₂ concentrations. Setting: Clinical laboratory of a university hospital intensive care unit. Measurements and results: The use of saline, as suggested for routine tonometry, led to negative bias values throughout, i. e. underestimation of pCO₂ values, the extent of which depended on the blood gas analyzer device employed. Registration of the equilibration kinetics showed that full equilibration demanded 90 min regardless of the environmental pCO₂ level. Replacing saline by buffered electrolyte solutions resulted in a significant improvement of bias, but did not change the kinetics of pCO₂ equilibration. The employment of air-filled balloons, combined with automated capnometry, led to very low bias values, approaching zero, for all pCO₂ levels, along with excellent precision. Time constants of equilibration were dramatically reduced, with full equilibration being achieved within 12.5 min. Conclusions: Buffered electrolyte solutions are preferable to saline for achieving reliable pCO₂ measurements in gastric tonometry. Air-filled balloons, combined with automated capnometry, present excellent accuracy and reproducibility together with short equilibration times, thus offering “on-line” monitoring of even rapid changes in environmental pCO₂. Reveived: 12 August 1996 Accepted: 13 January 1997