Action research methodology in clinical pharmacy: how to involve and change

Introduction The focus in clinical pharmacy practice is and has for the last 30–35 years been on changing the role of pharmacy staff into service orientation and patient counselling. One way of doing this is by involving staff in change process and as a researcher to take part in the change process by establishing partnerships with staff. On the background of the authors’ widespread action research (AR)-based experiences, recommendations and comments for how to conduct an AR-study is described, and one of their AR-based studies illustrate the methodology and the research methods used. Methodology AR is defined as an approach to research which is based on a problem-solving relationship between researchers and clients, which aims at both solving a problem and at collaboratively generating new knowledge. Research questions relevant in AR-studies are: what was the working process in this change oriented study? What learning and/or changes took place? What challenges/pitfalls had to be overcome? What were the influence/consequences for the involved parts? When to use If you want to implement new services and want to involve staff and others in the process, an AR methodology is very suitable. The basic advantages of doing AR-based studies are grounded in their participatory and democratic basis and their starting point in problems experienced in practice. Limitations Some of the limitations in AR-studies are that neither of the participants in a project steering group are the only ones to decide. Furthermore, the collective process makes the decision-making procedures relatively complex.

     

Transplanting the Highly Sensitized Patient: The Emory Algorithm

Renal transplant patients sensitized to HLA antigens comprise nearly one-third of the UNOS wait-list and receive 14% of deceased donor (DD) transplants, a rate half that of unsensitized patients. Between 1999 and 2003, we performed 492 adult renal transplants from DD; 120 patients (approximately 25%) had a panel reactive antibody (PRA) of >30%, with nearly half (n = 58) having a PRA of >80%. Our approach is based upon high-resolution solid-phase HLA antibody analysis to identify class I/II antibodies and a 'virtual crossmatch' to predict compatible donor/recipient combinations. Recipients are excluded from the United Network for Organ Sharing match run if donors possess unacceptable antigens. Thus, when sensitized patients appear on the match run, they have a high probability of a negative final crossmatch. Here, we describe our 5-year experience with this approach. Five-year graft survival ranged from 66% to 70% among unsensitized (n = 272), moderately sensitized (PRA < 30%, n = 100) and highly sensitized (>30% PRA; n = 120) patients, equal to the average national graft survival (65.7%). The application of this approach (the Emory Algorithm) provides a logical and systematic approach to improve the access of sensitized patients to DD organs and promote more equitable allocation to a highly disadvantaged group of patients awaiting renal transplantation.     

Clinical versus ultrasonographic evaluation of scrotal disorders

Clinical and ultrasonographic examinations of scrotal disorders were compared in 166 patients in order to determine their ability to distinguish between those diseases requiring surgery and those requiring clinical follow-up only. Ultrasound examinations were efficient in discriminating between normal and pathological findings. Extra-testicular lesions were readily differentiated from testicular ones. Although both clinical and ultrasonographic examinations had high sensitivity (90%) in detecting testicular cancer, the number of false positive findings was smaller after ultrasound examination. This gave a predictive value of a positive test of 53% after ultrasound examination but only 33% after clinical examination. Ultrasound examination may, therefore, reduce the number of surgical explorations in the scrotum and should be performed in patients with suspected testicular pathology based on history and palpatory findings.     

Altered modulation of prefrontal and subcortical brain activity in newly diagnosed schizophrenia and schizophreniform disorder. A regional cerebral blood flow study.

To measure prefrontal and subcortical activity during a cognitive task, we examined 19 newly diagnosed schizophrenics and patients with schizophreniform psychosis. Seven healthy volunteers served as controls. The patients were drug naive or had received neuroleptics for a few days only. Cerebral blood flow distribution was depicted by single photon emission computed tomography at rest and during activation with the Wisconsin Card Sorting Test. A significant relative activation deficit in the left inferior-prefrontal region was revealed during the Wisconsin Card Sorting Test in the patient group. Furthermore, the patients had impaired striatal suppression on the left side during the cognitive task. The test performance was significantly impaired in the patients. The inability to reduce striatal activity may be due to a lack of corticostriatal feedback during prefrontal activation.     

Recovery of stunned myocardium in acute myocardial infarction quantified by strain rate imaging: a clinical study.

BACKGROUND: Strain rate (SR) imaging (SRI) is a tissue Doppler-based method of regional myocardial deformation imaging. The aim of this study was to see whether SRI could quantify changes in myocardial mechanical function after an acute myocardial infarction, and to follow the time course of these changes. METHODS: In all, 26 consecutive patients with first-time acute myocardial infarctions were examined on days 1, 7, and 90. Segments were analyzed with SRI and wall-motion score. RESULTS: Peak systolic SR in infarcted segments increased significantly in magnitude from day 1 to 7 (-0.45 to -0.68 s -1 , P < .001), but not after day 7. The deformation rate in border zone segments also increased significantly from day 1 to 7 (-0.8 to -0.95 s -1 , P < .05), with no further significant changes at 3 months. In normal segments, peak systolic SR decreased in magnitude during the first week. Systolic strain showed similar results as peak systolic SR. CONCLUSION: SRI can demonstrate small changes in deformation rate from midinfarct through the infarct and border zone to normal myocardium. It can also show changes over time, probably as a result of recovery of stunned myocardium.     

Adenosine instead of supranormal potassium in cardioplegic solution improves cardioprotection.

OBJECTIVE: To determine whether adenosine instead of supranormal potassium in cold crystalloid cardioplegia gives satisfactory cardiac arrest and improved cardioprotection. Cold crystalloid cardioplegia with adenosine, procaine and magnesium (A) was compared with standard cold crystalloid hyperkalemic cardioplegia (K). METHODS: Sixteen pigs were randomized to receive either cold K (n=8) or A (n=8), where hyperkalemia was substituted with 1.2 mM adenosine. The cold (6 degrees C) cardioplegia was given intermittently and antegradely, with an aortic cross-clamp time of 1 h. Hemodynamic data was continuously measured and pressure-volume conductance catheters were used to determine global left ventricular systolic and diastolic function. Coronary flow and O2 content differences allowed determination of left ventricular energetics. Blood samples, and left ventricular microdialysis were used to measure parameters of ischemia. Measurements were done at 1 and 2 h after cross-clamp release. RESULTS: Mean arterial pressure was reduced with 55 mmHg (standard deviation, SD: 19) in the K group versus 30 mmHg (SD: 14) in the A group 2 h after cross-clamp release (p=0.030). Left ventricular contractility expressed as slope of the preload recruitable stroke work index (Mw) was reduced to 53% (SD: 14) in the K group versus 78% (SD: 23) in the A group 2h after cross-clamp release (p=0.046). Reduction of maximum of first derivate of pressure with respect to time (dP/dtmax) was 804 mmHg/s (SD: 189) in the K group versus 538 mmHg/s (SD: 184) in the A group (p=0.033). The slope of the myocardial oxygen consumption-pressure volume area was at 2 h reperfusion increased from 1.37 (SD: 0.64) to 2.86 (SD: 1.27) in the K group, whereas no shift was detected in the A group (p=0.019). Cardiac troponin T measured in the coronary sinus 1 h after cross-clamp release was 1.25 microg/l (SD: 0.64) in the K group versus 0.73 microg/l (SD: 0.31) in the A group (p=0.046). CONCLUSION: Adenosine instead of supranormal potassium in cold crystalloid cardioplegia gives satisfactory cardiac arrest, improves post cardioplegic left ventricular systolic function and efficiency, and attenuates myocardial cell damage.     

Mechanical restitution curves: a possible load independent assessment of contractile function.

OBJECTIVE: The time constant of mechanical restitution (T((MRC))), proposed to reflect changes in calcium release and uptake, has been shown to increase in left ventricular (LV) failure, and might have a potential as an index of contractile function. However, in vivo studies of the effect on T((MRC)) of changing loading conditions in the normal and failing heart have not been reported. Consequently, in this study, we tested the hypothesis that the increase in T((MRC)) in vivo is independent of preload and afterload. METHODS: Left ventricular pressure-volume loops were assessed at baseline in eight open chest pigs using the combined pressure-volume conductance catheter technique during right atrial pacing at 120b/min. Mechanical restitution curves (MRC) were constructed during four different loading conditions in all eight animals: uninfluenced load, reduced preload (balloon catheter in v. cava inferior), increased afterload (balloon catheter in descending aorta), and increased preload combined with reduced afterload (aortocaval shunting). Acute LV failure was then induced by microembolization through the left main coronary artery, and the experimental protocol was repeated. Contractile response was defined as the maximal first derivative of pressure (dP/dt(max)), and T((MRC)) was calculated using a least square approximation algorithm. RESULTS: Hemodynamic data 30min after microembolization showed decreased mean arterial pressure (98+/-14-67+/-10mmHg, (mean+/-SD) P<0.0001) and dP/dt(max) (1482+/-193-1001+/-125mmHg/s, P=0.001). Stroke volume decreased from 30+/-5 to 20+/-5ml (P<0.0001) compared to baseline, and preload recruitable stroke work decreased from 52+/-7 to 31+/-10mmHg (P=0.002). T((MRC)) increased in all eight animals after induction of LV failure at all loading conditions. There was no difference between the different loading conditions at baseline, nor at LV heart failure, but T((MRC)) increased significantly after the induction of heart failure (ANOVA, two ways). CONCLUSIONS: We have shown that the left ventricular T((MRC)) increases after developed heart failure. The increase in T((MRC)) was independent on loading conditions and thus have a potential for a contractility index.