Genome-wide shifts in climate-related variation underpin responses to selective breeding in a widespread conifer

Locally adapted temperate tree populations exhibit genetic trade-offs among climate-related traits that can be exacerbated by selective breeding and are challenging to manage under climate change. To inform climatically adaptive forest management, we investigated the genetic architecture and impacts of selective breeding on four climate-related traits in 105 natural and 20 selectively bred lodgepole pine populations from western Canada. Growth, cold injury, growth initiation, and growth cessation phenotypes were tested for associations with 18,600 single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in natural populations to identify “positive effect alleles” (PEAs). The effects of artificial selection for faster growth on the frequency of PEAs associated with each trait were quantified in breeding populations from different climates. Substantial shifts in PEA proportions and frequencies were observed across many loci after two generations of selective breeding for height, and responses of phenology-associated PEAs differed strongly among climatic regions. Extensive genetic overlap was evident among traits. Alleles most strongly associated with greater height were often associated with greater cold injury and delayed phenology, although it is unclear whether potential trade-offs arose directly from pleiotropy or indirectly via genetic linkage. Modest variation in multilocus PEA frequencies among populations was associated with large phenotypic differences and strong climatic gradients, providing support for assisted gene flow polices. Relationships among genotypes, phenotypes, and climate in natural populations were maintained or strengthened by selective breeding. However, future adaptive phenotypes and assisted gene flow may be compromised if selective breeding further increases the PEA frequencies of SNPs involved in adaptive trade-offs among climate-related traits.

Local adaptation of climate-related traits in widespread temperate conifers has been demonstrated for centuries using extensive long-term common garden experiments (1, 2). As early as the 17th century, foresters were instructed to recognize variation in desirable traits and select seed from trees with favorable phenotypes (3). Modern tree improvement programs systematically select upon genetic variation, primarily to achieve growth gains and meet economic objectives. Estimates of genetic variation and gains from selection made using quantitative genetic models assume many anonymous loci of small effect underlie both variation in continuously distributed phenotypes and their responses to selective breeding. However, the type, quantity, effect size, distribution, and dynamics of genes underlying locally adaptive phenotypic variation and responses to selective breeding in forest trees are still poorly understood (4).Directional selection over hundreds or thousands of generations has led to genomic features of domestication in agricultural crops including simplified genetic architectures underlying many traits, reduced genome-wide diversity, and numerous selective sweeps (5–7). Beyond high-gain, short-rotation clonal forestry [e.g., Eucalyptus spp. (8)], we know little about the effects of artificial selection on adaptive genetic variation in forest trees, yet many tree species undergo some degree of selective breeding. Two or three generations of conifer breeding is not expected to have the same magnitude of genetic effects seen in domesticated crops, but if artificial selection for increased productivity is detectable in conifer genomes, it may expose genetic relationships and potential sources of trade-offs between growth and climatically adaptive phenotypes.Climate-related adaptive traits are often intercorrelated due to pleiotropy, natural selection, or linkage disequilibrium (LD), so that strong directional selection on one trait can cause correlated responses in others. Pleiotropic allelic variants associated with phenotypes do not function in isolation. Antagonistic pleiotropic effects among traits can generate adaptive trade-offs among traits within populations, and limit gains from selection on a focal trait (9). Trait–trait correlations can also arise through strong selection acting in parallel on unlinked loci or from LD mediated by physical linkage of loci on chromosomes. Average genome-wide LD estimates in conifers appear to be low (10, 11) but may be greater (r² of 0.2–0.4) within genes under strong selection (12).Conifer studies have identified putatively adaptive phenotype-associated alleles on a locus-by-locus basis using quantitative trait loci (QTL) mapping or genotype–phenotype associations (GPAs) (also known as genome-wide association studies [GWAS]) (13). Genotype–environment association analyses in conifers have identified putatively adaptive environmentally associated loci (e.g., 14, 15), but loci are usually anonymous relative to adaptive phenotypes. All of these approaches are biased toward detecting loci with large phenotypic effects, but expectations that genome scans will discover individual adaptive loci with large effects or frequency differences among populations may be biologically and statistically unrealistic (16, 17). Conifer GPA studies typically detect relatively few statistically significant loci, and locus-by-locus analyses are insufficient to characterize adaptive genome-wide variation associated with adaptive traits and signatures of selective breeding. Multilocus tests for adaptive polygenic signatures of selection have been developed (e.g., refs. 18 and 19), but significant limitations remain (reviewed in refs. 20 and 21).Uncertainty about the effects of selective breeding on adaptive genetic variation is layered upon expectations that forest trees will become maladapted as climates shift (22). Efforts are being made to estimate maladaptation using genome-wide variation associated with adaptive traits and climate (23, 24), because conserving, managing, and efficiently redeploying genetic variation associated with adaptive phenotypes will be a necessary element of strategies to mitigate the effects of shifting climates on forest resources (25). Assisted gene flow strategies in temperate and subboreal forests generally aim to move trees to cooler climates in anticipation of future warming, but trees must then contend with the increased short- to medium-term risk of maladaptation to damaging frost. This means cold tolerance is, perhaps surprisingly, an important trait when planning for warming climates.Genetic approaches have the potential to efficiently and accurately characterize local adaptation to climate. Understanding whether this potential can be realized in a technically robust and operationally feasible way, and whether selection for faster growth compromises genetic variation associated with phenotypic adaptation to climate, has far-reaching implications for developing effective assisted gene flow strategies that mitigate negative climate change impacts on forest health and timber production (26, 27). In this context, our research objectives are to 1) identify the genetic architecture of climate-related adaptive traits in interior lodgepole pine (Pinus contorta Dougl. ex Loud. var. latifolia Engelm.); 2) identify genome-wide effects of artificial selection for increased productivity on climate-related traits; and 3) assess the implications of genetic responses to selection for assisted gene flow strategies.Our study combines climatic data, genotype data from ∼50,000 lodgepole pine single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), and seedling phenotypic data for height, cold injury, growth initiation, and growth cessation traits. These data were collected from a seedling common garden that sampled reforestation seed lots from 105 natural populations and 20 breeding populations from across the species’ range in Alberta (AB) and British Columbia (BC), Canada (Fig. 1 and SI Appendix, Table S1). For each of the four traits, we identify range-wide GPAs using 929 seedlings from all 105 natural populations. Then for the 1% most strongly phenotype-associated SNPs, we examine how artificial selection within breeding populations has changed allele frequencies at individual SNP loci, within individual seedlings, populations (breeding zones), and three climatic regions (Fig. 1). Using elements from the approach of Turchin et al. (18), we study changes in frequency of the alleles that have a positive effect on adaptive traits (positive effect alleles [PEAs]). At each SNP locus, a PEA is the allele associated with increasing numeric values of the respective phenotype, determined in this case through GPA analyses in the natural seedling populations. PEAs reported here are associated with greater seedling height, greater cold injury, delayed growth initiation, and delayed growth cessation. To parse physical genetic linkage from allelic associations due to other causes, we compare LD estimated from our natural seedlings with estimates of recombination among haploid megagametophytes from a single maternal parent, where physical linkage is the only cause of LD. Integrating genetic, climatic, and phenotypic data gives us a robust basis to detect the effects of artificial selection on climate-related genotypes that are relevant to breeding and assisted gene flow strategies.Open in a separate windowFig. 1.Geographic origins of the natural and selected seedling populations sampled from across the range of lodgepole pine in Alberta (AB) and British Columbia (BC). Natural populations are represented by filled circles; selected seedling breeding zones are represented by filled polygons. The three climatic regions we used were AB, BC-Central, and BC-South. AB breeding zones are formally identified as A, B1, B2, C, J, and K1. BC-Central breeding zone abbreviations are as follows: BV, Bulkley Valley; CP, Central Plateau; and PG, Prince George. BC-South breeding zone abbreviations are as follows: EK, East Kootenay; NE, Nelson; and TO, Thompson–Okanagan. Reprinted from ref. 35, with permission from Elsevier.     

Prevalence of sleep disturbance and the association between poor disease control in people with ankylosing spondylitis within the Australian clinical setting (ASLEEP study): a real-world observational study using the OPAL dataset

Clinical Rheumatology - Sleep disturbance and fatigue are commonly reported in ankylosing spondylitis (AS) but specific prevalence and the relationship to disease control are unknown. This...     

Measuring the ability of school children with a history of otitis media to understand everyday speech

The present study compared the ability of school-aged children with and without a history of otitis media (OM) to understand everyday speech in noise using the University of Queensland Understanding of Everyday Speech Test (UQUEST). Participants were 484 children (246 boys, 238 girls) attending Grade 3 (272, mean age = 8.25 yr., SD = 0.43) and Grade 4 (212, mean age = 9.28 yr., SD = 0.41) at 19 primary schools in Brisbane metropolitan and Sunshine Coast schools. Children selected for inclusion were native speakers of English with normal hearing on the day of testing and had no reported physical or behavioral impairments. The children were divided into three groups according to the number of episodes of OM since birth. The results showed no significant differences in speech scores across the participant groups. However, a significant difference in mean speech scores was found across the grades and the noise conditions. Although children with a history of OM performed equally well at a group level when compared to the controls, they exhibited a large range of abilities in speech comprehension within the same group.