Controlled clinical trials in cystic fibrosis--are we doing better?

We have previously reported the time trends, design and interventions in randomised controlled trials (RCTs) in cystic fibrosis (CF) from 1961 through 1997 [Cheng K, Smyth RL, Motley J, O'Hea U, Ashby D, Randomised controlled trials in cystic fibrosis (1966-1997) categorized by time, design, and intervention. Pediatr Pulmonol 2000, 29:1-7.]. We maintain an ongoing register of all RCTs and controlled clinical trials (CCTs) in CF and have noted that in the five years since 1997 there has been a 48% increase in published trials. We aimed to assess whether this increase has been associated with an improvement in design quality. All RCTs and CCTs from 1961-2002 were assessed. Two epochs were then compared, 1961-1997 and 1998-2002. For each trial we recorded the design, participant numbers and the intervention studied. 261 trials in 1998-2002 were compared with 544 trials in 1961-1997. Comparing the two epochs a similar proportion of trials were parallel, double-blind and placebo controlled; also the median number of participants was similar. In the later epoch 25% of trials were multicentre, compared with 11% previously. Whilst this recent increase in clinical trials in CF is welcome, this has not been associated with improvements in quality. The trend for an increasing proportion of trials to be multicentre is encouraging. There are however, still deficiencies in the design of clinical trials in CF.     

Predictive value and limitations of animal models for human transplantation: do we need more models for facial transplantation?

Animal models have traditionally provided the basis for preliminary investigation of new techniques prior to trials taking place in human subjects. The timing of when to proceed with human trials is difficult, as the accuracy of preclinical models can only be determined with hindsight. This review outlines the progression from transplantation in animal models to man. Now that many transplant procedures are well established, it is possible to assess the predictive value and limitations of animal models. These results are of great importance in the current debate about composite tissue allotransplantation (CTA) and in particular facial transplantation. This progression of CTA from animal models to man is outlined and compared with early renal, cardiac, and liver transplants. There is some evidence to suggest that animal models may have been misleading in CTA and that this has effectively delayed the transition to humans. The role for animal models in facial transplantation, which is currently making the step to clinical trials, is discussed.     

Cesarean delivery during second-stage labor: characteristics and diagnostic accuracy.

OBJECTIVE: To characterize dysfunctional labors that lead to cesarean delivery in the second stage and to assess the accuracy of diagnoses of abnormal fetal descent. METHODS: Thirty-one patients delivered by cesarean during the second stage because of abnormal labor or presumed cephalopelvic disproportion were studied and compared to 62 control cesarean cases delivered for the same indications in the first stage. The clinical diagnosis of dysfunctional labor that led to the cesarean was compared to the diagnosis made by retrospective analysis of the labor curves. RESULTS: Cases did not differ from controls delivered in the first stage in maternal age, race, parity, gestational age, weight gain, or the frequency of associated medical complications. The newborns were not significantly different in birth weight,ponderal index, sex, or the incidence of low Apgar scores. Among study patients, 94% had a second stage labor dysfunction determined by graphic labor analysis, predominantly arrest of descent (69%) and failure of descent (28%). In 79% of cases a dysfunctional first stage preceded the abnormal second stage. Among these first stage labor abnormalities, 68% were not recognized during the labor. CONCLUSION: Characteristics of patients delivered by cesarean during the second stage were similar to those delivered before full cervical dilatation. Second stage labor abnormalities were usually preceded by an abnormal first stage. There was considerable inaccuracy in the diagnosis of second stage labor dysfunction.     

Apparent inactivation of alpha 1-antiproteinase by sulphur-containing radicals derived from penicillamine

alpha 1-Antiproteinase is the major inhibitor of proteolytic enzymes, such as elastase, in human plasma. Its elastase-inhibitory capacity can be inactivated by exposure to hydroxyl radicals (.OH) generated either by pulse radiolysis or by an Fe3+-EDTA/H2O2/ascorbic acid system. Inactivation of alpha 1-antiproteinase by radiolytically-generated .OH under anoxic conditions was decreased by adding a range of anti-inflammatory drugs to the reaction mixtures, including the thiol compound penicillamine. However, under conditions favouring formation of oxysulphur radicals, protection by thiols such as penicillamine was much decreased. It is proposed that sulphur-containing radicals resulting from attack of biologically-produced oxidants upon penicillamine in the presence of O2 can themselves inactivate alpha 1-antiproteinase, and that such radicals might contribute to the side-effects produced by penicillamine or gold thiol therapy in rheumatoid arthritis.     

Multiple pilocytic astrocytomas of the cerebellum in a 17-year-old patient with neurofibromatosis type I

Objective Approximately 10% of patients with neurofibromatosis I (NFI) patients will have central nervous system (CNS) tumors. The most common of these are hypothalamic–optic gliomas, followed by brainstem and cerebellar pilocytic astrocytomas. While isolated pilocytic astrocytomas in NFI are well described, the appearance of multiple pilocytic astrocytomas in an individual patient is less common. The most frequent combination in NFI patients with more than one pilocytic astrocytoma is optic tract/hypothalamic and brainstem. Other combinations are exceedingly rare; multiple pilocytic astrocytomas have only been reported once in the cerebral hemispheres in a patient with NFI. This report presents the first documented case, to our knowledge, of multiple pilocytic astrocytomas in the cerebellum of a patient with NF1. Methods Case report. Conclusion The finding of multiple cerebellar pilocytic astrocytomas in a patient with NF1 is important because it expands the spectrum of presentations for patients with NF1 and also highlights specific diagnostic and therapeutic challenges faced by the treating physicians. The genetic and molecular basis of NF1 is reviewed. Strategies of diagnosis and treatment outlined here are relevant to both patients with NF1 and all patients with multiple posterior fossa tumors.     

A tax reform strategy to deal with the uninsured

The high level of ininsurance in the United States is due in large measure to the tax treatment of health care, which is based on the tax exclusion for company-provided plans. Correcting the perverse incentives for providers and patients resulting from this tax treatment is the crucial step to creating a national health care system that is affordable and efficient. The Heritage Foundation proposal calls for the elimination of the current tax exclusion and its replacement with a system of refundable tax credits for the purchase of health insurance and medical services.