Peer influence on students’ estimates of performance: social comparison in clinical rotations

Context During clinical rotations, students move from one clinical situation to another. Questions exist about students’ strategies for coping with these transitions. These strategies may include a process of social comparison because in this context it offers the student an opportunity to estimate his or her abilities to master a novel rotation. These estimates are relevant for learning and performance because they are related to self‐efficacy. We investigated whether student estimates of their own future performance are influenced by the performance level and gender of the peer with whom the student compares him‐ or herself. Methods We designed an experimental study in which participating students (n = 321) were divided into groups assigned to 12 different conditions. Each condition entailed a written comparison situation in which a peer student had completed the rotation the participant was required to undertake next. Differences between conditions were determined by the performance level (worse, similar or better) and gender of the comparison peer. The overall grade achieved by the comparison peer remained the same in all conditions. We asked participants to estimate their own future performance in that novel rotation. Differences between their estimates were analysed using analysis of variance (anova) . Results Students’ estimates of their future performance were highest when the comparison peer was presented as performing less well and lowest when the comparison peer was presented as performing better (p < 0.001). Estimates of male and female students in same‐gender comparison conditions did not differ. In two of three opposite‐gender conditions, male students’ estimates were higher than those of females (p < 0.001 and p < 0.05, respectively). Conclusions Social comparison influences students’ estimates of their future performance in a novel rotation. The effect depends on the performance level and gender of the comparison peer. This indicates that comparisons against particular peers may strengthen or diminish a student’s self‐efficacy, which, in turn, may ease or hamper the student’s learning during clinical rotations. The study is limited by its experimental design. Future research should focus on students’ comparison behaviour in real transitions.     

Poor Health‐related Quality of Life After Severe Preeclampsia

Abstract: Background: Preeclampsia is a major complication of pregnancy associated with increased maternal morbidity and mortality, and adverse birth outcomes. The objective of this study was to describe changes in all domains of health‐related quality of life between 6 and 12 weeks postpartum after mild and severe preeclampsia; to assess the extent to which it differs after mild and severe preeclampsia; and to assess which factors contribute to such differences. Methods: We conducted a prospective multicenter cohort study of 174 postpartum women who experienced preeclampsia, and who gave birth between February 2007 and June 2009. Health‐related quality of life was measured at 6 and 12 weeks postpartum by the RAND 36‐item Short‐Form Health Survey (SF‐36). The population for analysis comprised women (74%) who obtained scores on the questionnaire at both time points. Results: Women who experienced severe preeclampsia had a lower postpartum health‐related quality of life than those who had mild preeclampsia (all p < 0.05 at 6 wk postpartum). Quality of life improved on almost all SF‐36 scales from 6 to 12 weeks postpartum (p < 0.05). Compared with women who had mild preeclampsia, those who experienced severe preeclampsia had a poorer mental quality of life at 12 weeks postpartum (p < 0.05). Neonatal intensive care unit admission and perinatal death were contributing factors to this poorer mental quality of life. Conclusions: Obstetric caregivers should be aware of poor health‐related quality of life, particularly mental health quality of life in women who have experienced severe preeclampsia (especially those confronted with perinatal death or their child’s admission to a neonatal intensive care unit), and should consider referral for postpartum psychological care. (BIRTH 38:3 September 2011)     

Reliability and validity of health status measurement by the TAPQOL.

BACKGROUND: In addition to clinical measures in the evaluation of paediatric interventions, health related quality of life (HRQoL) is an important outcome. The TAPQOL (TNO-AZL Preschool children Quality of Life) was developed to measure HRQoL in preschool children. It is a generic instrument consisting of 12 scales that cover the domains physical, social, cognitive, and emotional functioning. AIMS: To evaluate the feasibility, score distribution, internal consistency, test-retest reliability, and discriminative and concurrent validity of the TAPQOL multi-item scales in preschool children, aged 2-48 months. Also to evaluate the feasibility, reliability, and validity separately for infants (2-12 months old) and toddlers (12-48 months old). METHODS: Parents of a random general population sample of 500 preschool children were sent a questionnaire by mail. A random subgroup of 159 parents who participated received a retest after two weeks. RESULTS: The response rate was 83% at the test and 75% at the retest. There were few missing answers. Six scales showed ceiling effects. Nine scales had Cronbach's alphas >0.70. In general, score distributions and Cronbach's alphas were comparable for infants and toddlers. Test-retest showed no significant differences in mean scale scores; two scales had intra-class correlations <0.50. Five scales showed significant differences between children with no conditions versus children with two or more parent reported chronic conditions. CONCLUSION: Results showed that the TAPQOL is a feasible instrument to measure HRQoL and support the reliability and discriminative validity of the majority of its scales for infants as well as toddlers.     

Academic and behavioral limitations and health-related quality of life in school-age survivors of bacterial meningitis

The objectives of this study were to describe health-related quality of life of postmeningitic children and to examine the association between academic and/or behavioral limitations and health-related quality of life. One hundred and eighty-two children (mean age 9.7 years; range 5.3–14.2) were selected randomly from a cohort of 674 school-age children who recovered from non-Haemophilus influenzae type B bacterial meningitis. These children had neither meningitis with ‘complex onset’, nor prior cognitive or behavioral problems, nor severe disease sequelae. On average 7.4 years after meningitis, they were evaluated using an ‘Academic Achievement Test’ and their parents filled in the Child Behavior Checklist, the Child Health Questionnaire, and the Health Utilities Index. The long-term incidence of academic and/or behavioral limitations was 32%. Overall health-related quality of life of the postmeningitic children was decreased in comparison with that of a reference population of schoolchildren. The group of postmeningitic children with academic and/or behavioral limitations showed the most marked decrease in quality of life, especially concerning psychosocial health, cognition and family life. The negative effects on quality of life were not significantly influenced by age, gender, causative pathogen, presence of minor neurological impairment, or presence of hearing impairment. In conclusion, health-related quality of life of postmeningitic children is decreased, particularly of those with academic and/or behavioral limitations.     

Effects of recombinant-hemoglobin solutions rHb2.0 and rHb1.1 on blood pressure, intestinal blood flow, and gut oxygenation in a rat model of hemorrhagic shock

The vasoconstriction induced by hemoglobin-based oxygen carriers (HBOCs), mainly a result of nitric oxide (NO) scavenging, until now has limited the application of HBOCs as resuscitation fluids. In this study, we tested the hypothesis that the new modified recombinant-hemoglobin solution rHb2.0, with a 20 to 30 times lesser NO-scavenging rate, would minimize vasoconstriction without adverse effects on microvascular oxygenation. Responses were compared with those to rHb1.1, a recombinant-hemoglobin solution with a wild-type NO-scavenging rate, as well as an oncotically matched albumin solution. In a fixed-pressure (40 mm Hg) rat model of hemorrhagic shock and resuscitation, rHb2.0 and albumin both restored mean arterial pressure (MAP) to baseline values, whereas rHb1.1 increased MAP to 27% above the baseline value. Mesenteric vascular resistance after resuscitation with rHb2.0 was 57% less than that with rHb1.1. rHb2.0 was found to have 55% greater intestinal oxygen delivery (Do2int ) and resulted in a 27% lower oxygen-extraction rate than did rHb1.1 after resuscitation. Intestinal microvascular Po2 , determined on the basis of oxygen-dependent quenching of palladium-porphyrin phosphorescence, revealed no difference between rHb2.0 and rHb1.1. The findings of this study confirm that the well-known pressure effect of HBOCs is caused by their effect on the NO-scavenging rate; recombinant modification of this rate did not increase MAP during resuscitation compared with baseline values. Although systemic vasoconstriction was absent, intestinal vasoconstriction almost negligible, and Do2int greater after resuscitation with rHb2.0, the effect of rHb2.0 on pH, base-excess and microvascular Po2 levels after resuscitation were comparable to those achieved with the use of the albumin solution.     

Targeted disruption of the protein kinase C epsilon gene abolishes the infarct size reduction that follows ischaemic preconditioning of isolated buffer-perfused mouse hearts

OBJECTIVE: Activation of protein kinase C (PKC) isoforms is associated with the cardioprotective effect of early ischaemic preconditioning (IP). PKC consists of at least 10 different isoforms, encoded by separate genes, which mediate distinct physiological functions. Although the PKC-epsilon isoform has been implicated in preconditioning, uncertainty remains. We investigated whether preconditioning still occurs in a mouse line lacking cardiac PKC-epsilon protein due to a targeted disruption within the pkc-epsilon allele. METHODS: The isolated buffer-perfused hearts from knockout mice lacking PKC-epsilon (-/-) and sibling heterozygous mice (+/-), with a normal PKC-epsilon complement, were preconditioned by 4 x 4 min ischaemia/6 min reperfusion. Hearts then underwent 45 min of global ischaemia followed by 1.5 h of reperfusion. RESULTS: In PKC-epsilon (+/-) hearts ischaemic preconditioning reduced infarction volume as a percentage of myocardial volume (24.3+/-4.5 vs. 41.3+/-4.7%, P<0.001). In contrast, in PKC-epsilon (-/-) hearts preconditioning failed to diminish infarction (36.4+/-2.9 vs. 38.8+/-4.5%). Surprisingly however, although preconditioning did not reduce infarct size, it did enhance contractile recovery in PKC-epsilon (-/-) mice (43.1+/-3.9 vs. 24.9+/-5.1%, P<0.05), similar to the level seen in PKC-epsilon (+/-) hearts (35.2+/-3.9 vs. 20.9+/-5.0%, P<0.05). CONCLUSIONS: These data suggest that PKC-epsilon is essential for the reduction in infarction that follows early ischaemic preconditioning, but is not associated with the improvement in functional recovery.