Catastrophic failure of an uncemented acetabular component due to high wear and osteolysisAn analysis of 154 Omnifit prostheses with mean 6-year follow-up

Background?The purposes of this study were (1) to evaluate the wear pattern of the hydroxyapatite-coated “Dual Radius” Omnifit cup, (2) to investigate whether wear is correlated to any demographic or prosthesis-related factors, and (3) to describe micromotion of both the cup and the stem.Patients and methods?154 hips were implanted between 1990 and 1996 and followed for an average of 6 years. Wear was measured according to the “Charnley-duo” method and, in 79 hips, with radiostereometry (RSA). RSA was also used to evaluate micromotion. We analyzed the femoral heads using scanning electron microscopy, energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy and an atomic force microscope.Result?66 cups were revised and had a mean annual wear of 0.32?mm compared to 0.12?mm in hips not revised. Osteolytic processes were observed in 35 hips but at revision osteolysis was present in 51 cases. 43/66 sockets were loose. Micromotion evaluated by RSA, weight, age, side, size of cup, screws, polyethylene thickness or shelf-life of the polyethylene did not correlate to wear, whereas male gender did.Interpretation?It is still unclear why about half of our cases had an abnormal wear rate. Annual wear exceeding 0.2?mm is prognostic of late failure and should be considered a warning sign.     

Cemented tibial component fixation performs better than cementless fixation

Background The question whether the tibial component of a total knee arthroplasty should be fixed to bone with or without bone cement has not yet been definitely answered. We studied movements between the tibial component and bone by radiostereometry (RSA) in total knee replacement (TKR) for 3 different types of fixation: cemented fixation (C-F), uncemented porous fixation (UC-F) and uncemented porous hydroxyapatite fixation (UCHA-F).

Patients 116 patients with osteoarthrosis, who had 146 TKRs, were included in 2 randomized series. The first series included 86 unilateral TKRs stratified into 1 of the 3 types of fixation. The second series included 30 patients who had simultaneous bilateral TKR surgery, and who were stratified into 3 subgroups of pairwise comparisons of the 3 types of fixation.

Results After 5 years 2 knees had been revised, neither of which were due to loosening. 1 UCHA-F knee in the unilateral series showed a large and continuous migration and a poor clinical result, and is a pending failure. The C-F knees rotated and migrated less than UC-F and UCHA-F knees over 5 years. UCHA-F migrated less than UC-F after 1 year.

Interpretation Cementing of the tibial component offers more stable bone-implant contact for 5 years compared to uncemented fixation. When using uncemented components, however, there is evidence that augmenting a porous surface with hydroxyapatite may mean less motion between implant and bone after the initial postoperative year.     

Osteolysis,wear and failure of a migrating acetabular component

The migration of an acetabular component, revised 12 years postoperatively, was clearly detectable within the first year after operation by roentgen stereophotogram analysis. The failure was probably the result of an early initiated prosthetic loosening.     

Periarticular bone mineral content in rheumatoid arthritis and arthrosis of the hip: Dual photon X-ray absorptiometry in 53 cases

The bone mineral content (BMC) was determined by dual photon X-ray absorptiometry prior to hip replacement in 22 patients with rheumatoid arthritis and 31 with arthrosis. Compared with the arthrosis patients, the rheumatoids had approximately 20 percent lower bone mineral content in the proximal femur, the lumbar spine, and in the innominate bone superior to the acetabulum.     

Bone graft fixation in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction evaluated by radiostereometric analysis

For most anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction techniques, the tensile strength of the ligament substitutes and the surgical methods of fixation have been examined. In the present study seven consecutive patients with a chronic anterior cruciate ligament deficiency, who were reconstructed with a bone-patellar tendon-bone graft, were followed. The migration of the bone blocks was examined with radiostereometric analysis immediately postoperatively and after 3 and 12 months. The median migration of the bone blocks in the femur was 0.4 mm and in the tibia 0.4 mm. Clinical examination was undertaken preoperatively and one year postoperatively. We conclude that the use of interference screws seems to be a reliable method for fixation in anterior cruciate reconstruction and that healing of the bone blocks occurs during the first three postoperative months.     

Catastrophic failure of an uncemented acetabular component due to high wear and osteolysis

Background The purposes of this study were (1) to evaluate the wear pattern of the hydroxyapatite-coated “Dual Radius” Omnifit cup, (2) to investigate whether wear is correlated to any demographic or prosthesis-related factors, and (3) to describe micromotion of both the cup and the stem.

Patients and methods 154 hips were implanted between 1990 and 1996 and followed for an average of 6 years. Wear was measured according to the “Charnley-duo” method and, in 79 hips, with radiostereometry (RSA). RSA was also used to evaluate micromotion. We analyzed the femoral heads using scanning electron microscopy, energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy and an atomic force microscope.

Result 66 cups were revised and had a mean annual wear of 0.32 mm compared to 0.12 mm in hips not revised. Osteolytic processes were observed in 35 hips but at revision osteolysis was present in 51 cases. 43/66 sockets were loose. Micromotion evaluated by RSA, weight, age, side, size of cup, screws, polyethylene thickness or shelf-life of the polyethylene did not correlate to wear, whereas male gender did.

Interpretation It is still unclear why about half of our cases had an abnormal wear rate. Annual wear exceeding 0.2 mm is prognostic of late failure and should be considered a warning sign.     

Accuracy of radiographic and radiostereometric wear measurement of different hip prosthesesAn experimental study

Background In vivo measurement of wear in the ball and socket articulation of total hip arthroplasties is of interest in the evaluation of both existing and new implants. Controversy reigns regarding the accuracy of different radiological measurement techniques and in particular how accuracy has been assessed. Material and methods We assessed the accuracy of 2 radiostereometric (RSA) techniques for wear measurement and 3 standard radiographic techniques, namely Imagika (image analyzing software), Imagika corrected for head center displacement, and the Charnley Duo method. 5 custom-made adjustable phantoms with different prosthetic components were used. Results In 20 measurements of all 5 phantoms at 3 levels of simulated wear (0.2 mm, 1.0 mm and 1.5 mm), the mean measurement error of the digital RSA examinations was 0.010 mm (accuracy 0.42). The corresponding error values for the three radiographic techniques were 0.19 (accuracy 1.3) for Charnley Duo, 0.13 (accuracy 1.3) for Imagika corrected, and 1.021 (accuracy 2.99) for Imagika. Measurement error decreased from 0.011 mm with ordinary RSA to 0.004 with RSA digital measurement. Head size, direction of wear in relation to the cup or type of prosthetic component did not influence the measurement error. The results of Charnley Duo and Imagika corrected were similar but the latter had an inexplicable systematic error in measuring one of the phantoms. Imagika had the worst results due to its inability to compensate for the out-of-head center effect. Alumina heads were difficult to analyze with all methods. Interpretation By using the ISO standard for assessing accuracy, RSA can be expected to measure wear with an accuracy of about 0.4 mm irrespective of prosthetic component studied or direction of wear, whereas the best technique, in our study, based on standard radiographs can be accurate to about 1.3 mm.     

Periarticular bone in rheumatoid arthritis versus arthrosis: Histomorphometry in 103 hip biopsies

Histomorphologic differences of the periarticular bone in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and osteoarthrosis (OA) may be of importance for long-term prosthetic fixation. We have evaluated bone specimens, obtained during total hip replacement from an acetabular and a femoral biopsy site, in 42 RA-hips and 61 OA-hips. In both groups the bone turnover was increased in the acetabulum compared to that in the femur. In the acetabulums the total trabecular bone volume was equal, but osteoid volume, osteoid surface, resorptive surface, and the appositional rate were increased in RA. On the femoral side, only the osteoid volume was higher in RA.

The increased bone turnover with a greater amount of unmineralized tissue, as well as resorptive activity in the acetabulum, may be of importance for the higher rate of acetabular component migration and loosening after total hip replacement in RA.     

Loosening of the Lubinus hip: 202 cases followed for 3-6 years

Survivorship methods were applied to a consecutive series of 202 primary Lubinus total hip arthroplasties followed for 3 to 6 years. After 5 years, the revision rate was 3 percent, and the radiographic loosening rate was 13 percent for the socket and 10 percent for the stem.