Is the learning curve for laparoscopic fundoplication determined by the teacher or the pupil?

BACKGROUND: For all surgical procedures, a surgeons' learning curve can be anticipated during which complication rates are increased. The aims of this study were to evaluate individual learning curves for a group of surgeons performing laparoscopic fundoplication and to evaluate if the Procedicus MIST-simulator (Mentice Inc., G?teborg, Sweden) accurately predicts surgical performance. METHODS: Twelve Nordic centers participated, each contributing with a "master" and a "pupil" surgeon. The pupils were tested in the simulator and thereafter performed their first 20 supervised operations. All procedures were videotaped and evaluated by 3 independent reviewers. RESULTS: A significant decrease in operative time (P <0.001) and a trend (P = 0.12) toward improved score were seen during the series. The master significantly affected the pupil's score (P =0.0137). The simulator-test showed no correlation with the operative score. CONCLUSIONS: Individual learning curves varied, and the teacher was shown to be the most important factor influencing the pupil's performance score. The correlation between assessed performance and patient outcome will be further investigated.     

Biomechanical simulations of scoliotic spine correction due to prone position and anaesthesia prior to surgical instrumentation

BACKGROUND: The positioning of patients during scoliosis surgery has been shown to affect the scoliosis curve, yet positioning has not been exploited to help improve surgical outcome from a biomechanics point of view. Biomechanical models have been used to study other aspects of scoliosis. The goal of this study is to simulate the specific influence of the prone operative position and anaesthesia using a finite element model with patient personalized material properties. METHODS: A finite element model of the spine, ribcage and pelvis was created from the 3D standing geometry of two patients. To this model various positions were simulated. Initially the left and right supine pre-operative bending were simulated. Using a Box-Benkin experimental design the material properties of the intervertebral disks were personalized so that the bending simulations best matched the bending X-rays. The prone position was then simulated by applying the appropriate boundary conditions and gravity loads and the 3D geometry was compared to the X-rays taken intra-operatively. Finally an anaesthesia factor was added to the model to relax all the soft tissues. FINDINGS: The behaviour of the model improved for all three positions once the material properties were personalized. By incorporating an anaesthesia factor the results of the prone intra-operative simulation better matched the prone intra-operative X-ray. However, the anaesthesia factor was different for both patients. For the prone position simulation with anaesthesia patient 1 corrected from 62 degrees to 47 degrees and 43 degrees to 31 degrees. Patient 2 corrected from 70 degrees to 55 degrees and 40 degrees to 32 degrees for the thoracic and lumbar curves respectively. INTERPRETATION: Positioning of the patient, as well as anaesthesia, provide significant correction of the spinal deformity even before surgical instrumentation is fixed to the vertebra. The biomechanical effect of positioning should be taken into consideration by surgeons and possibly modify the support cushions accordingly to maximise 3D curve correction. The positioning is an important step that should not be overlooked by when simulating surgical correction and biomechanical models could be used to help determine optimal cushion placement.     

Comparison of the biomechanical 3D efficiency of different brace designs for the treatment of scoliosis using a finite element model

The biomechanical influence of thoraco-lumbo-sacral bracing, a commonly employed treatment in scoliosis, is still not fully understood. The aim of this study was to compare the immediate corrections generated by different virtual braces using a patient-specific finite element model (FEM) and to analyze the most influential design factors. The 3D geometry of three patients presenting different types of curves was acquired with a multi-view X-ray technique and surface topography. A personalized FEM of the patients’ trunk and a parametric model of a virtual custom-fit brace were then created. The installation of the braces on the patients was simulated. The influence of 15 design factors on the 3D correction generated by the brace was evaluated following a design of experiments simulation protocol allowing computing the main and two-way interaction effects of the design factors. A total of 12,288 different braces were tested. Results showed a great variability of the braces effectiveness. Of the 15 design factors investigated, according to the 2 modalities chosen for each one, the 5 most influential design factors were the position of the brace opening (posterior vs. anterior), the strap tension, the trochanter extension side, the lordosis design and the rigid shell shape. The position of the brace opening modified the correction mechanism. The trochanter extension position influenced the efficiency of the thoracic and lumbar pads by modifying their lever arm. Increasing the strap tension improved corrections of coronal curves. The lordosis design had an influence in the sagittal plane but not in the coronal plane. This study could help to better understand the brace biomechanics and to rationalize and optimize their design.     

The impact of intra-operative sternum vertical displacement on the sagittal curves of the spine

Patient positioning is an important step in spinal surgeries. Many surgical frames allow for lumbar lordosis modulation due to lower limb displacement, however, they do not include a feature which can modulate thoracic kyphosis. A sternum vertical displacer (SVD) prototype has been developed which can increase a subject’s thoracic kyphosis relative to the neutral prone position on a surgical frame. The kyphosis increase is obtained by lifting the subject’s torso off the thoracic cushions with a dedicated sternum cushion that can be displaced vertically. The objective of this study was to evaluate the impact of SVD utilization on the sagittal curves of the spine. Experimental testing was performed on six healthy volunteers. Lateral radiographs were taken in the neutral and sternum raised positions and then analyzed in order to compare the values of sagittal curves. The displacement of volunteers and surgical frame components between positions was recorded using an optoelectronic device. Finally, interface pressures between the volunteers and surgical frame cushions were recorded using a force sensing array. Average results show that passing from the neutral to sternum raised positions caused an increase of 53% in thoracic kyphosis and 24% in lumbar lordosis; both statistically significant. Sensors showed that the sternum was raised a total of 8 cm and that interface pressures were considerably higher in the raised position. The SVD provides a novel way of increasing a patient’s thoracic kyphosis intra-operatively which can be used to improve access to posterior vertebral elements and improve sagittal balance. It is recommended that its use should be limited in time due to the increase in interface pressures observed.     

3D rod shape changes in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis instrumentation: how much does it impact correction?

Purpose

Flattening of rods is known to reduce the correction capability of the instrumentation, but has not been studied in 3D. The aim is to evaluate the rods shape 3D changes during and immediately after instrumentation, and its effect on 3D correction.

Methods

The 5.5 mm CoCr rods of 35 right thoracic adolescent idiopathic scoliosis patients were measured from rod tracings prior to insertion, and reconstructed in 3D from bi-planar radiographs taken intra-operatively after the correction maneuvers and 1 week post-operatively. The rod bending curvature, maximal deflection and orientation of the rod’s plane of maximum curvature (RPMC) were computed at each stage. The relation between rod contour, kyphosis and apical vertebral rotation (AVR) was assessed.

Results

Main thoracic Cobb angle was corrected from 58° ± 10° to 15° ± 8°. Prior to insertion, rods were more bent on the concave side (curvature/deflection: 39° ± 8°/25 ± 6 mm) than the convex side (26° ± 5°/17 ± 3 mm). Only the concave rod shape changed after the correction maneuvers execution (flattening of 21° ± 9°/13 ± 7 mm; p < 0.001) and stayed unchanged post-operatively. After instrumentation, the RPMC was deviated from the sagittal plane (concave side: 27° ± 19°/convex side: 15° ± 12°). There was a significant association between kyphosis change and the relative concave rod to spine contour (rod curvature—pre-operative kyphosis) (R ² = 0.58) and between AVR correction and initial differential concave/convex rods deflection (R ² = 0.28).

Conclusions

Correction maneuvers induce a significant change of the concave rod profile. Both rods end in a plane deviated from the sagittal plane which is representative of the spinal curvature 3D orientation. Differential rod contouring technique has a significant impact on the resulting thoracic kyphosis and transverse plane correction.