Instruments measuring interprofessional collaboration in healthcare – a scoping review

ABSTRACT

Worldwide there is growing understanding of the importance of interprofessional collaboration in providing well-functioning healthcare. However, little is known about how interprofessional collaboration can be measured between different health-care professionals. In this review, we aim to fill this gap, by identifying and analyzing the existing instruments measuring interprofessional collaboration in healthcare. A scoping review design was applied. A systematic literature search of two electronic databases, Medline (PubMed) and CINAHL, was conducted in 03/2018. The search yielded 1020 studies, of which 35 were selected for the review. The data were analyzed by content analysis. In total, 29 instruments measuring interprofessional collaboration were found. Interprofessional collaboration was measured predominantly between nurses and physicians with different instruments in various health-care settings. Psychometric testing was unsystematic, focusing predominantly on construct and content validity and internal consistency, thus further validation studies with comprehensive testing are suggested. The results of this review can be used to select instruments measuring interprofessional collaboration in practice or research. Future research is needed to strengthen the evidence of reliability and validity of these instruments.     

Experiences of physical and sexual abuse and their implications for current health

OBJECTIVE: To estimate the prevalence of a history of physical and sexual abuse in adulthood among gynecological patients and the association with general and reproductive health. METHODS: A cross-sectional questionnaire study on abusive experiences of gynecologic outpatients in a tertiary hospital. The total sample size was 691. RESULTS: Of all women, 42.4% had experienced moderate or severe physical or sexual abuse as an adult. One hundred forty-seven (21.6%) women reported physical abuse, 84 (12.3%) sexual abuse, and 58 (8.5%) both. The abused and nonabused women did not differ in mean age, education, or parity. Sexually abused women and those who were both sexually and physically abused reported poor general health significantly more often (P=.005 and P=.001, respectively) than the nonabused. They also rated their sex life as significantly worse than the nonabused women (P=.002 and P=.012, respectively). Over half of abused women had experienced common physical complaints during the previous 12 months compared with one third of the nonabused (P<.001). Two thirds of both the abused and the nonabused women preferred that their gynecologist not ask directly about abuse. CONCLUSION: Abusive experiences were common in gynecologic outpatients. Women with abusive experiences had ill health and poor sexual life more often than the controls. In contrast to the results of previous studies, most of the women did not want to be asked about abuse by their gynecologist.     

gamma-Glutamyl transferase and mean cell volume reveal maternal alcohol abuse and fetal alcohol effects

Serial measurements of gamma-glutamyl transferase and mean cell volume were done in 85 pregnant alcohol abusers (320 samples). These included 26 moderate drinkers, 30 heavy drinkers, and 29 alcoholic women. Studies of 28 pregnant women who denied the use of alcohol (138 samples) showed that pregnancy itself had no effect on gamma-glutamyl transferase and mean cell volume. However, gamma-glutamyl transferase was increased in 14.9%, 31.7% and 59.1% of the samples collected from moderate drinkers, heavy drinkers, and alcoholic women, respectively, and likewise mean cell volume was elevated in 10.8%, 17.2%, and 40.2%, respectively. Either gamma-glutamyl transferase or mean cell volume was high or both were high in 27.1% of the moderate drinkers, in 38.3% of the heavy drinkers, and in 76.3% of the alcoholic women. Fetal alcohol effects developed in 42 cases. Increased gamma-glutamyl transferase predicted fetal alcohol effects in 61.5%, with a relative risk of 2.51. Elevated mean cell volume predicted fetal alcohol effects in 40.9%, with a relative risk of 2.40. These results suggest that the assay of gamma-glutamyl transferase and mean cell volume can be valuable in monitoring pregnant women with recognized or suspected alcohol abuse.     

Mean cell volume and gamma-glutamyl transferase are superior to carbohydrate-deficient transferrin and hemoglobin-acetaldehyde adducts in the follow-up of pregnant women with alcohol abuse

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: To compare the usefulness of carbohydrate-deficient transferrin (CDT), the ratio of CDT to total transferrin, and hemoglobin-acetaldehyde adducts with mean cell volume (MCV) and gamma-glutamyl transferase (GGT) in the follow-up of alcohol abuse during pregnancy. METHODS: Forty-four pregnant drug and alcohol abusing female patients attending a special outpatient clinic were followed from the 8th to 24th gestational week onwards. A population of sixty-two healthy pregnant women was recruited to assess the effect of gestation on the markers. RESULTS: Eight of thirteen heavy drinking (> or =8 drinks/week) patients delivered infants with fetal alcohol effects (FAE). MCV and GGT were higher among heavy drinking patients than in moderately drinking (<8 drinks/week) patients (92+/-4 vs 90+/-3 fl and 31+/-34 vs 16+/-10 U/ L, respectively), and in patients delivering infants with FAE compared with patients delivering healthy infants (95+/-3 vs 90+/-3 fl and 34+/-26 vs 15+/-10 U/L, respectively). Hemoglobin-acetaldehyde adducts, CDT, and the ratio of CDT to total transferrin were neither associated with the reported level of alcohol consumption nor with the occurrence of FAE. In the receiver operating characteristics analysis MCV was found to be superior to CDT and the adducts, and GGT superior to the adducts, in identifying heavy drinking and in predicting FAE. In the control population, both CDT and total transferrin were found to rise during pregnancy, whereas the ratio of CDT to total transferrin was found to decline. The upper reference range of 33 U/L for CDT was considerably higher than that of non-pregnant women (26 U/L). CONCLUSION: MCV and GGT appear to be the most efficient laboratory markers for detecting excessive alcohol consumption and the adverse effects of alcohol on the fetus.     

Fear of childbirth: a neglected dilemma

Severe fear of childbirth complicates 6% to 10% of parturients and is manifested as nightmares, physical complaints and difficulties in concentrating on work or on family activities. Very often fear of childbirth leads to request for an elective cesarean section (CS). In Finland, Sweden, and the United Kingdom, fear of childbirth or maternal request is the reason for about 7-22% of CS births. Fear of childbirth is as common in nulliparous as in parous women. Fear of labor pain is strongly associated with the fear of pain in general, and a previous complicated childbirth or inadequate pain relief are the most common reasons for requesting a CS among parous women. Previous psychological morbidity and a great number of daily stressors expose a woman to a great risk of fear of childbirth. Fear of childbirth is not an isolated problem but associated with the woman's personal characteristics, mainly general anxiety, low self-esteem, and depression, and dissatisfaction with their partnership, and lack of support. Also the partners of women with fear have a certain pattern of low psychological well-being, resulting in low life-satisfaction, dissatisfaction with partnerships, and depression. A vivid debate about the woman's right to choose the mode of delivery is going on in obstetric literature, but discussion on the reasons for women to request a CS, or on the possibilities to help them overcome the fear of vaginal childbirth is scanty. Preliminary Swedish and Finnish reports demonstrated the results of treatment during pregnancy, when more than half of the women withdrew their request after being able to discuss their anxiety and fear, and vaginal deliveries after treatment were successful.     

Invasive group B streptococcal infections in Finland: a population-based study

We analyzed surveillance data on group B streptococcus (GBS) infection in Finland from 1995 to 2000 and reviewed neonatal cases of early-onset GBS infection in selected hospitals in 1999 to 2000. From 1995 to 2000, 853 cases were reported (annual incidence 2.2-3.0/100,000 population). We found 32-38 neonatal cases of early-onset GBS disease per year (annual incidence 0.6-0.7/1,000 live births). In five hospitals, 35% of 26 neonatal cases of early-onset GBS infection had at least one risk factor: prolonged rupture of membranes, preterm delivery, or intrapartum fever. Five of eight mothers screened for GBS were colonized. In one case, disease developed despite intrapartum chemoprophylaxis. Although the incidence of early-onset GBS disease in Finland is relatively low, some geographic variation exists, and current prevention practices are suboptimal. Establishing national guidelines to prevent perinatal GBS is likely to reduce the incidence of the disease.     

Psychosocial predictors of disappointment with delivery and puerperal depression. A longitudinal study

BACKGROUND: To examine the extent to which personality characteristics, depression, fear and anxiety about pregnancy and delivery, and socio-economic background, predict disappointment with delivery and the risk of puerperal depression. METHODS: Two hundred and eleven women filled in questionnaires measuring personality traits, socio-economic factors, and marital satisfaction once before and once after the 30th week of pregnancy, and 2 3 months after delivery, when obstetric data about pregnancy and delivery was also collected. RESULTS: The women who were disappointed with their delivery or suffered from puerperal depression had been more depressed already in early pregnancy. Regression analysis showed that the strongest predictors of disappointment with delivery were labor pain (increase in R2 = 0.14, p<0.001) and emergency Cesarean (increase in R2 = 0.18, p<0.001). Puerperal depression was predicted by depression (increase in R2 = 0.16, p<0.001), and by personal traits such as general anxiety, vulnerability and neuroticism (increase in R2 = 0.32, p<0.001), both before 30 weeks of pregnancy and prior to the delivery (for depression increase in R2 = 0.05, p<0.001, and for anxiety and vulnerability increase in R2 = 0.04, p<0.01). The strongest predictors were depression at both time points before delivery (beta = 0.51, p<0.001, and beta = 0.39, p<0.001). Pregnancy- and delivery-related anxiety prior to the delivery also predicted puerperal depression, but complications of the pregnancy and delivery did not. CONCLUSIONS: Depression in early pregnancy predicts disappointment with the delivery and is a strong predictor of puerperal depression.     

The effect of maternal ethanol intoxication on fetal cardiotocography: a report of four cases

Fetal cardiotocography revealed no or poor variability and no reactivity to fetal movements and or external stimuli in four drunken women. This was taken as a sign of fetal hypoxia in one patient and led to emergency caesarean section although, the infant was not hypoxic. In the other three patients, cardiotocography normalized within 11-14 h when the mothers became sober.