Acute vascular rejection is associated with systemic complement activation in a pig-to-primate kidney xenograft model

The introduction of h-DAF transgenic porcine organs into pre-clinical pig-to-primate discordant xenotransplantation has led to complete and reliable abrogation of hyperacute xenograft rejection (HAR). Despite additional heavy immunosuppression however, most xenografts are still lost due to acute vascular rejection (AVR), with current treatment protocols being of only limited value. In a life-supporting model of pig-to-primate kidney transplantation, unmodified (n=8) or h-DAF-transgenic (n=9) porcine kidneys were transplanted into cynomolgus monkeys under cyclophosphamide (CyP), cyclosporine and low-dose steroid immunosuppression. Longest recipient survival was 11 days in the control group and 68 days in the h-DAF transgenic group. Stable initial graft function with recipient survival >4 days was generated in eight animals (two controls and six transgenics). In these animals, plasma complement levels were analyzed during ongoing AVR. Compared with baseline levels, a two-fold increase in C3a levels and a four-fold increase in sC5b-9 levels were measured. In parallel to systemic complement activation, increased deposition of C3 and C5b-9 along with massive staining for recipient IgM immunoglobulins was detected in the xenografts on immunohistochemistry. We conclude that acute vascular xenograft rejection of porcine kidneys in cynomolgus monkeys is associated with classical pathway complement activation following binding of induced recipient anti-porcine antibodies. This complement activation can be observed despite membrane bound expression of human complement regulators in the porcine xenografts. Therefore, additional short-term fluid phase complement inhibition seems necessary for the future development of protocols designed for treatment of AVR in the pig-to-primate combination.     

Plasma perfusion by apheresis through a Gal immunoaffinity column successfully depletes anti-Gal antibody: experience with 320 aphereses in baboons

Abstract: Background: Anti‐Galα1–3Gal (Gal) antibodies (Gal Ab) contribute to the rejection of porcine organs transplanted into primates. Extracorporeal immunoadsorption (EIA) has been developed to eliminate Gal Ab from the circulation. Methods: Between 1995 and 1999 we performed 320 EIAs in baboons using a COBE‐Spectra apheresis unit incorporating a synthetic Gal immunoaffinity column. Three plasma volumes were immunoadsorbed on each occasion. The 221 consecutive EIAs performed in 41 immuno‐suppressed baboons between January 1997 and April 1999 form the basis of this review. Of these 41 baboons, 29 underwent a series of three or four EIAs at daily intervals, seven had multiple series of three EIAs, and the remainder underwent single or double EIAs. Serum Gal Ab levels were monitored by ELISA before and at intervals after the course of EIA. Results: There were two fatal complications, one from a respiratory mishap (unrelated to the EIA) and one from persistent hypotension unresponsive to therapeutic interventions. Seven procedures (3%) were terminated early owing to technical difficulties and/or persistent hypo‐tension. Mean pre‐EIA Gal Ab levels in naïve baboons were 33.1 µg/ml (IgM) and 14.5 µg/ml (IgG). Immediately after three consecutive EIAs, IgM was depleted by a mean of 97.3% and IgG by 99.4%. By 18 to 24 h later, Gal Ab was returning but depletion remained at 80.1% (IgM) and 84.7% (IgG). The subsequent rate of return of Gal Ab depended on the immunomodulatory protocol used. Conclusions: (1) With appropriate monitoring, EIA is an acceptably safe procedure, even in small (< 10 kg) baboons. (2) Three consecutive EIAs are effective in removing > 97% of Gal Ab. (3) In the majority of cases, return of Gal Ab begins within 24 h, irrespective of the immuno‐modulatory protocol.     

Islet transplantation

Recently, significant advances have been made in the number and purity of islets that can be retrieved from the human pancreas, thus enabling several centers to initiate or resume clinical trials of islet transplantation in type I diabetic patients. Although the success rate of islet transplantation is lower than that of pancreas transplantation in terms of achievement of insulin-independence, islet transplantation has significant potential advantages over vascularized pancreas transplantation: it is a simple and safe procedure; it has the potential to be performed on an outpatient basis; it offers access to cell banking after cryopreservation; it offers the potential advantages of pre-transplant reduction of im-munogenecity; and it even offers the future feasibility of xenotransplantation. In this article, the current status of clinical trials and future perspectives of islet transplantation, including immunomodulation, immunotolerance, immunoisolation, and xenotransplantation, are reviewed. Received for publication on Feb. 24, 1999; accepted on March 28, 1999     

Adoptive transfer: The role of perforin in mouse cytotoxic T lymphocyte rejection of human tumor xenografts in vivo

ABSTRACT: The popliteal lymph node cells of immunocompetent mice generated a strong in vitro cytotoxic response to footpad injection of several human tumor cell lines and the resulting mouse effector cells predominantly used a perforin-mediated cytotoxic mechanism. A relatively minor FasL-dependent cytotoxic response to CEM-CCRF and Jurkat leukemias, but not colon carcinoma COLO 205 cells, was also detected in immunized perforin-deficient mice. In vitro depletion of CD3⁺ CD8⁺ T cells, but not CD4⁺ T or NK1.1⁺ cells, completely inhibited lysis of human tumor cells, suggesting that CD3⁺ CD8⁺ T cells were effectors of perforin-mediated xenospecific cytotoxicity. Xenospecific cytotoxic T cells from wild-type mice were extremely efficient at rejecting tumor when adoptively transferred into scid mice bearing established COLO 205, CEM-CCRF, or Jurkat tumor xenografts. By contrast, cytotoxic T lymphocytes of perforin-deficient mice had no effect on the growth of established tumor xenografts. These data indicate that perforin, and hence direct cytotoxicity, plays a key role in the ability of adoptively transferred CD8⁺ cytotoxic T lymphocytes to eradicate established xenografts.     

Human tonsil implants xenotransplanted in SCID mice display broad lymphocytic diversity and cellular activation profile similar to those in the original lymphoid organ

BACKGROUND: Models consisting of human immune cells in suspension transferred to severe combined immune deficient (SCID) mice have been invaluable for studying immune response, autoimmunity, and lymphomagenesis. The dissemination of human cells within the mouse body hampers immune functionality with time and favorites the development of human graft vs. mouse host (GvH) disease. To circumvent these limitations we surgically implanted tonsil pieces subcutaneously in SCID animals (hu-ton-SCID mice). Recall humoral responses was elicited and animals did not suffer from signs of GvH disease. A detailed cell subset and cell activation analysis of implants has not yet been reported. METHODS: Implants from 86 hu-ton-SCID mice were evaluated by immunohistochemistry and flow cytometry analyses to assess human lymphoid cell subpopulation surviving with time after implantation, and to evaluate status of human cell activation. Results: B cells persist over 3 months in implants. The proportion of class and type-specific Ig+ cells varied between implants, but as a whole IgG+ cells were more abundant than IgA+, and IgM+ cells, and kappa+ cells predominated over lambda+ cells. The mean proportions of these cells resemble those in the original tonsil. Fine analysis of CD19+ B cells demonstrated no expansion of activated (CD5+, CD23+, CD69+) B cells in implants compared with tonsils, and a decrease of CD19+CD77+ B cells corresponding to a centroblastic phenotype, which is consistent with the disappearance of follicular structure in implants. Double positive CD20+CD27+ memory B cells were detected in implants by immunohistochemistry. T cell CD4+CD8-/CD4-CD8+ ratios were about 4 in implants, that is similar to those in tonsils, and there was no expansion of CD3+CD4+CD8+ and of CD3+CD4-CD8- T-cell subpopulations. T cells activation markers (CD25, CD69) were similarly expressed in implants and tonsils, and implants contained cells with a memory T cell phenotype (CD45RO). Finally cells within implants depicted a low rate of proliferation when assessed by Ki-67 expression levels. Conclusions: Compared with original tonsils, tonsil implants in hu-ton-SCID mice lose the germinal center architecture, which is correlated with the decrease of CD77+ B cells, but conserve T and B cell subpopulation diversity, notably memory cells. In addition, implant T and B cells are not differently activated when compared with those in original tonsils and do not proliferate extensively. These observations indicate indirectly absence of GvH reaction at the cellular level in this model. Collectively, the detailed implant cellular characterization in the hu-ton-SCID model provides a strong rationale for the use of this model in the study of human recall antibody response.     

Porcine complement regulators protect aortic smooth muscle cells poorly against human complement-induced lysis and proliferation: consequences for xenotransplantation

BACKGROUND: Accelerated atherosclerosis after transplantation has been observed and is characterized by smooth muscle cell proliferation in the graft. Porcine cells are frequently used in models of atherosclerosis and porcine organs are considered for use in transplantation. Complement (C) activation is known to play a major role in rejection of xenografts and is also considered to play a role in the development of atherosclerosis. The aim of this study was to investigate the expression and function of membrane bound regulators of complement (CReg) on porcine aortic smooth muscle cells (PASMC). METHODS: The PASMC were assessed for expression of CReg and susceptibility to lysis by human C by flow-cytometry. The effect of various cytokines on CReg expression and C-susceptibility was investigated. The ability of human C to induce cell proliferation was assessed using the Alamar blue assay. RESULTS: The PASMC only express the CReg membrane cofactor protein (MCP) and CD59 on their cell surface. MCP expression was increased by interleukin (IL)-4. In contrast to porcine aortic endothelial cells (PAEC), PASMC were found to be surprisingly sensitive to C-mediated lysis, mainly due to a low level of expression of CD59. Human C-induced proliferation of PASMC, which was dependent on complete membrane attack complex (MAC) formation. CONCLUSIONS: Endogenously expressed CReg on PASMC poorly protect these cells to human C. Human C can induce proliferation of PASMC. In order to prevent accelerated atherosclerosis in porcine xenografts, increased levels of CReg not only have to be obtained on the endothelial cells but also on the smooth muscle cells.     

From ABO-incompatible human kidney transplantation to xenotransplantation

The development (in 1981) of a protocol for successful renal allotransplantation across ABO barriers is outlined. From this experience, the concept of "adaptation", subsequently termed "accommodation", was defined. It was then hypothesized that a similar approach might allow pig-to-human organ xenotransplantation. This hypothesis was explored in the pig-to-baboon renal transplantation model, with graft survival for a maximum of 23 days. Rejection episodes were temporarily reversed, providing encouragement that discordant xenotransplantation would one day prove successful. Finally, the preparation of the thymokidney, developed as a means of inducing xenotolerance, is briefly reviewed.