Evaluation of the percentage of sperm motility at 24 h and sperm survival ratio for prediction of in vitro fertilization

Summary. The present study was carried out to investigate the predictive value of the percentage of sperm motility after 24-h incubation and sperm survival ratio from semen and inseminated sperm suspension using grading of motility by WHO criteria with respect to the fertilization of oocytes in vitro. A total of 789 oocytes from 85 cases were inseminated and the mean fertilization rate obtained was 72.5%. There was no significant correlation between all of the sperm motility results with fertilization rate in vitro. All sperm motility results were not significantly different between the non-fertilizing group and the fertilizing group and also between the group of fertilization rate ≤ 25th percentile (fertilization rate ≤62.5%) and the group of fertilization rate >62.5%. However, the initial percentage of rapid progressive sperm motility and progressive motility in semen and inseminated sperm suspension at 24 h gave significant differences between the group of fertilization ≤ 50th percentile (fertilization rate ≤80%) and the group of fertilization rate >80%. Overall accuracy using these parameters for prediction of fertilization rate >80% was only about 60%. In conclusion, the percentage of sperm motility at 24 h and sperm survival ratio in both semen and inseminated sperm suspension have no practical value in predicting fertilization rate in vitro. Moreover, detailed motility grading cannot improve the predictivity of these sperm motility parameters.     

Sperm morphological assessment based on strict criteria and in-vitro fertilization outcome.

One-hundred-and-twenty-three in-vitro fertilization (IVF) cycles were analysed in order to clarify the influence of strictly normal morphology (SNM) of spermatozoa on IVF outcome. SNM was defined using strict criteria according to Kruger with our modifications. The IVF cycles studied were divided into three groups: %SNM less than 12% (13 cycles), 12 less than 40% (68 cycles), greater than or equal to 40% (42 cycles). The cleavage rates per oocyte were higher in the groups with 12-40% and greater than or equal to 40% of %SNM than in the group with %SNM less than 12%. The embryo transfer rate per cycle increased with increasing %SNM. The overall pregnancy rate per cycle increased with increasing %SNM (7.7% in %SNM less than 12%, 22.1% in 12-40% of %SNM, and 40.5% in %SNM greater than or equal to 40%). The ongoing pregnancy rate per cycle also increased with increasing %SNM (7.7% in %SNM less than 12%, 14.7% in 12-40% of %SNM, and 31.0% in %SNM greater than or equal to 40%). The miscarriage rate was lower in %SNM greater than or equal to 40% (23.5%) than in 12-40% of %SNM (33.3%). It was suggested that %SNM is a good predictor of IVF outcome.     

Periovulatory increase in temperature difference within the rabbit oviduct

BACKGROUND: Earlier studies demonstrated a small temperature difference between the sperm storage and fertilization sites within the oviducts of rabbits and pigs. Our aim was to reveal the time dependence of this temperature difference relative to ovulation, and to determine how this difference is generated-by temperature elevation at one of these sites or by temperature decrease at the other site. METHODS: The temperature at the sperm storage site (at the isthmus near the uterotubal junction) and at the fertilization site (the isthmic-ampullary junction) of rabbit oviducts were measured before, during, and after ovulation by two probes, connected to digital thermometers. Rectal temperature was constantly measured and served as a control for body temperature. RESULTS: The temperature difference between the fertilization site and the storage site was 0.8+/-0.2 degrees C before ovulation. This difference increased at ovulation, reaching 1.6+/-0.1 degrees C after ovulation (P<0.03). This increased difference was mainly due to temperature decrease in the sperm storage site. CONCLUSION: The temperature-difference increase within the rabbit oviduct is generated at ovulation by a reduced temperature at the sperm storage site. This temperature gradient may play a role in mammalian reproduction via sperm thermotaxis.     

Incidence of severe ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome after GnRH agonist/HMG superovulation for in-vitro fertilization

In 1673 treatment cycles stimulated with buserelin and HMG, for IVF, GIFT or ZIFT, the severe ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome (OHSS) occurred in 10 cycles (0.6%). Eight patients were hyperandrogenic and showed an increased ovarian response to HMG. After replacement of a maximum of three embryos or zygotes, seven women became pregnant. Three women had a multiple gestation. All patients recovered uneventfully with conservative treatment. Support with progesterone or continuation of the agonist during the luteal phase did not prevent OHSS, confirming that the ovulatory HCG dose is the most important factor in inducing this severe complication. Luteal supplementation with HCG and/or HCG production during implantation could exacerbate OHSS.     

Fertilization in vitro increases non-disjunction during early cleavage divisions in a mouse model system

BACKGROUND: We have been studying an unusual mouse-the BALB/cWt (Wt) male-in which the Y chromosome is susceptible to high rates of mitotic non-disjunction, particularly at the first two cleavage divisions. As these are the same divisions that human embryos generated through assisted reproductive technology must complete in an artificial setting, analysis of the Wt Y chromosome allows us to examine the effect of fertilization and culture in vitro on mammalian chromosome segregation. METHODS: We performed standard mouse IVF, cultured embryos in 5% CO2 in air or in a lowered oxygen atmosphere, and used fluorescence in-situ hybridization to examine the sex chromosome constitutions of 2-, 4-, 8- and 16-cell stage Wt Y-bearing embryos. RESULTS: We observed a significant increase in mosaic sex chromosome aneuploidy at each embryonic stage in embryos cultured in 5% CO2 in air, but under lowered oxygen conditions mosaicism returned to control (in-vivo) levels. CONCLUSIONS: Our results demonstrate that slight alterations in in-vitro conditions may have a considerable impact on the genetic quality of assisted reproductive technology-derived embryos and suggest that the genetic quality of embryos should be a fundamental concern in the development of new culture systems for clinical use.     

The acrosome index, radical buffer capacity and number of isolated progressively motile spermatozoa predict IVF results

BACKGROUND: The accuracy by which a number of newly described semen variables can predict either total fertilization failure (TFF) or pregnancy outcome in IVF, has not previously been investigated. The study aim was, therefore, to determine prospectively the predictive value of these variables. METHODS: The semen variables investigated were the post-wash total progressively motile sperm cell count (TPMC(post-wash)), the acrosome index (AI), 'cytoplasmic residues' and normal sperm morphology, evaluated according to the strict criteria ('strict criteria'), as well as the fast and slow total radical trapping antioxidant potential ('fast TRAP' and 'slow TRAP' respectively). RESULTS: The study group (n = 87) showed a mean (+/- SD) number of 10.2 +/- SD retrieved oocytes, 12.6% TFF, a mean fertilization rate of 59.7% and a pregnancy rate of 19.5% (17/87). TFF was significantly predicted by TPMC(post-wash), 'strict criteria', AI and 'cytoplasmic residues' (all P < 0.05). The outcome after embryo transfer was significantly predicted by AI and 'fast TRAP'. Semen samples with an AI <5% and a 'fast TRAP' <1.14 mmol/l in particular did not result in any pregnancies after IVF-embryo transfer. CONCLUSIONS: Of all the measured and calculated semen variables, TPMC(post-wash) was the best predictor of TFF, whilst AI and 'fast TRAP' were the best predictors of pregnancy after IVF.     

Maternal death associated with ovum donation twin pregnancy.

A case of maternal death due to sub-arachnoid haemorrhage in an ovum donation twin pregnancy complicated by hypertension is described. Attention is drawn to a forecasted increase in maternal morbidity and mortality in in-vitro fertilization (IVF) pregnancies, which occur in older women and are often multiple.     

Risk of thromboembolism in relation to an in-vitro fertilization programme: three case reports

Severe thrombotic events following ovarian stimulation for in-vitrofertilization (IVF) procedures in three women are reported.None of these patients presented any concomitant clinical signof ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome. Coagulation inhibitorswere in the normal range but cardiovascular risk factors werepresent. It is postulated that early thrombosis could be favouredby high endogenous plasma oestrogen concentrations subsequentto ovarian stimulation when associated with another risk factor.Our data are discussed in relation to previous publications.It is suggested that risk factors must be considered individuallybefore each IVF attempt. In patients at high risk, clinicalmanagement of the post-transfer period is recommended.     

A more realistic approach to the cumulative pregnancy rate after in-vitro fertilization

As most studies overestimate the cumulative pregnancy rate,a method is proposed to estimate a more realistic cumulativepregnancy rate by taking into account the reasons for an earlycessation of treatment with in-vitro fertilization (IVF). Threemethods for calculating cumulative pregnancy rates were compared.The first method assumed that those who stopped treatment hadno chance at all of pregnancy. The second method, the one usedmost often, assumed the same probability of pregnancy for thosewho stopped as for those who continued. The third method assumedthat only those who stopped treatment, because of a medicalindication, had no chance at all of pregnancy and that the otherswho stopped had the same probability of pregnancy as those whocontinued treatment Data were used from 616 women treated atthe University Hospital Nijmegen, Nijmegen, The Netherlands.The cumulative pregnancy rates after five initiated IVF cyclesfor the three calculation methods were in the ranges 37–51%for the positive pregnancy test result, 33–55% for a clinicalpregnancy and 30–56% for an ongoing pregnancy. As expected,the first method underestimated the cumulative pregnancy rateand the second overestimated it The third method produced themost realistic cumulative pregnancy rates.     

The influence of ovarian follicular activity on late proliferative phase serum IGFBP-1 in down-regulated assisted conception cycles

Serum insulin-like growth factor binding protein-1 (IGFBP-1)concentrations were measured at the end of the proliferativephase in infertility patients undergoing normal menstrual cyclefrozen embryo transfer, exogenous hormone-supported frozen embryotransfer and in-vitro fertilization (IVF) treatment cycles.These patients were divided into five groups according to theirovarian follicular activity. The exogenous hormone-supportedfrozen embryo transfer group, who had no ovarian follicles,and the IVF groups (number of follicles ranging from 4–38)showed statistically higher serum IGFBP-1 concentrations whencompared to the normal menstrual cycle group (P0.01). Therewas no significant difference in the serum IGFBP-1 concentrationsbetween the exogenous hormone support frozen embryo transfergroup and the poor or normal response IVF groups (number offollicles ranging from 4 to 16). An IVF group that displayedan excessive response to our standard human menopausal gonadotrophinstimulation (>>20 mature follicles or oestradiol >>10000 pmol/1) showed a significantly higher serum IGFBP-1 concentrationwhen compared with the other groups (P = 0.001). This subgroupwas subsequently given a modified (follicle-stimulating hormone)stimulation regime which resulted in a significant reductionin serum IGFBP-1 concentrations (P << 0.05). There wasno correlation between serum oestradiol and IGFBP-1 overallor within the patient groups. We conclude that serum IGFBP-1concentrations in our down-regulated assisted conception cyclesdid not increase in line with ovarian follicular activity, unlessan excessive response was displayed.