Nurses’ stories from Beirut: The 2020 explosive disaster on top of a pandemic and economic crises

The World Health Organization designated last year as the International Year of the Nurse and the Midwife. And as we know worldwide, 2020 became an unforgettable year as nurses and midwives everywhere confronted the COVID‐19 pandemic. To be a nurse in 2020 was challenging and heroic, but being a nurse in 2020 in Beirut, Lebanon was so extraordinarily charged with adversity. The country witnessed in a one‐year series of tragedies of epic dimensions – laying a heavy toll on front‐line nurses. We present our stories as eight Lebanese nurses, giving voice to our incredible experiences and our ongoing resilience in the face of these adversities. We served in the emergency department of a Beirut city hospital after a catastrophic explosion occurred in the capital on the 4th of August 2020. We reported for duty during a disaster of immense magnitude and are now coping with the aftermath of trauma. As nurses, we have faced many traumas in our country that has experienced through war and terrorism for decades. Arising from this disaster and challenges of the pandemic, we give policy recommendations that deserve urgent attention in Lebanon and underscore the need for disaster preparation, funding, education and importantly mental health care for nurses and other health professionals with help and support of the international community.     

The effects of coping style,social support,and behavioral problems on the well-being of mothers of children with Autism Spectrum Disorders in Lebanon

The present study examined the effects of coping styles, social support, and child's behavioral symptoms on the well-being of 65 mothers of children with Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASD) in Lebanon. Comparisons to the well-being of 98 mothers of typically developing children were also drawn. Regression analyses showed that disengagement and distraction coping predicted poor well-being, whereas cognitive reframing showed a correlation with better well-being levels. A significant correlation was found between child's behavioral problems and maternal well-being. T-test analyses revealed that mothers of children with ASD differed in terms of coping styles used. Additionally, mothers of children with ASD showed lower levels of perceived social support. Well-being was significantly better for mothers of typically developing children. Study limitations and implications are discussed.     

Attitudes towards domestic violence in Lebanon: a qualitative study of primary care practitioners

Background

Domestic violence (DV) is highly prevalent in the developing and developed world. Healthcare systems internationally are still not adequately addressing the needs of patients experiencing violence.

Aim

To explore physicians’ attitudes about responding to DV, their perception of the physician’s role, and the factors that influence their response.

Design and setting

Qualitative study using individual interviews among primary care practitioners working in Lebanon.

Method

Primary care clinicians practising for >5 years and with >100 patient consultations a week were interviewed. Physicians were asked about their practice when encountering women disclosing abuse, their opinion about the engagement of the health services with DV, their potential role, and the anticipated reaction of patients and society to this extended role.

Results

Physicians felt that they were well positioned to play a pivotal role in addressing DV; yet they had concerns related to personal safety, worry about losing patients, and opposing the norms of a largely conservative society. Several physicians justified DV or blamed the survivor rather than the perpetrator for triggering the violent behaviour. Moreover, religion was perceived as sanctioning DV.

Conclusion

Perceived cultural norms and religious beliefs seem to be major barriers to physicians responding to DV in Lebanon, and possibly in the Arab world more generally. Financial concerns also need to be addressed to encourage physicians to address DV.     

Hypertension prevalence and control among community‐dwelling lebanese older adults

There is a high prevalence of hypertension among Lebanese adults, but no evidence is available on its prevalence and control exclusively among older adults (65 + years). This study provides the first evidence on a representative sample of 502 community elderly and presents the basis for future research and policy implications. Results show an overall prevalence of 52% with a significantly higher female‐to‐male ratio. Factors independently associated with hypertension were older age, body mass index, and dementia. More than a third of those with a positive history of hypertension had uncontrolled blood levels. Uncontrolled hypertension was higher among women. Increasing awareness about medication adherence and controlling multi‐morbidities constitute promising measures to lowering the burden of hypertension among Lebanese older adults, especially women.     

Adolescents' self‐perceived and actual weight: Which plays a dominant role in weight loss behaviour in Lebanon?

Background

The decision to lose weight among adolescents is complex and is guided by a number of body‐related factors. This study examined the extent of agreement between actual weight, measured as body mass index, and self‐perceived weight and assessed their relative importance in weight loss behaviour among Lebanese adolescents.

Methods

Data on 278 adolescents aged 13–17 years were drawn from the nationwide Nutrition and Non‐Communicable Disease Risk Factor Survey (Lebanon, 2009). Binary multivariable logistic regressions were conducted to test associations with “effort to lose weight” as the outcome variable, controlling for a number of potential confounders.

Results

Close to 36% reported trying to lose weight. Around 21% and 13% were overweight and obese, respectively, and 40% and 10% perceived their weight as slightly high and very high, respectively. Inaccurate perceivers, those underestimating or overestimating their weight, constituted 39%, with overall percent agreement between actual and self‐perceived weight being 60.8% (kappa statistic = 0.319, 95% CI [0.242, 0.396]). About a third of the overweight adolescents (30.5%) and more than half of the obese (56.8%) underestimated their weight. In the multivariable analysis, self‐perceived weight was statistically significant and a stronger predictor of weight loss effort than body mass index (adjusted odds ratios = 14.42 and 6.42 for slightly high and very high perceived weight, respectively, compared to odds ratios = 1.47 and 2.31 for overweight and obese adolescents, respectively).

Conclusion

Health professionals need to consider self‐perceived weight in conjunction with actual weight in their pursuit of weight management goals and in planning prevention programmes that guide weight loss behaviours for adolescents.     

Prevalence,correlates and management of type 2 diabetes mellitus in Lebanon: Findings from a national population-based study

Aims

This study aims to examine the prevalence, associated risk factors and complications of diabetes, as well management and preventive care in Lebanon, a small, middle-income country of the Mediterranean region.

Methods

Using a comprehensive multi-dimensional questionnaire, a cross-sectional national survey of 2195 Lebanese adults aged ≥25 years was conducted based on the WHO STEPwise guidelines. The outcome variable, diabetes, was self-reported. Measures for diabetes management included frequency of blood glucose testing and regular eye and foot exams. Macrovascular and microvascular complications were also recorded.

Results

The prevalence of type 2 diabetes was 8.5% (95%CI = 7.3–9.7). Factors associated with an increased risk of having diabetes were: being divorced or widowed (OR = 2.56; 95%CI = 1.07–5.42) compared to single, being obese (OR = 1.50, 95%CI = 1.00–2.57), and having a family history of diabetes (OR = 3.40;95%CI = 2.48–5.19). Vigorous physical activity significantly decreased the odds of diabetes (OR = 0.42; 95%CI = 0.24–0.72). Diabetes management and self-care goals were as follows: 82% were not measuring their blood sugar via dextro on a daily basis, 64.2% did not have a foot exam within the past year, and 52.4% did not obtain the recommended yearly eye exam. The most common complications included heart disease (27.8%) and retinopathy (16.6%).

Conclusions

Prevalence of diabetes in Lebanon was comparable to that found in the West, yet remained lower than estimates in other resource-rich neighboring countries. Adherence to management and self-care measures was sub-optimal resulting in high complication rates. Contextual factors play a role in increasing diabetes risk. Population-based interventions to enhance and promote self-management behaviors are essential to improve complication rates.     

Legal and Policy Considerations in Lebanon Related to Proposals for Paraphilic Disorders in World Health Organization's International Classification of Diseases Manual, 11th Version

IntroductionThe World Health Organization's general assembly, in its last meeting of May 2019, has approved the suggested changes to the International Classification of Diseases manual, 11th version (ICD-11). Some of the proposed recommendations include the revision of “Disorders of Sexual Preference”, now called Paraphilic Disorders, currently listed under the International Classification of Diseases-10 Mental and Behavioural Disorders.AimThis article presents findings on the analysis of the existing laws and policies that are relevant to paraphilic disorders in Lebanon.MethodsA literature review of all official and unofficial documents, reports, and articles published on laws and health policies relevant to paraphilic disorders in Lebanon was conducted, including a thorough review on Lebanese laws on that matter. Moreover, interviews with government representatives, including the Ministry of Public Health, the Ministry of Justice, the Ministry of Social Affairs, representatives of Non-Governmental Organizations working in child protection, and mental health professionals from the private and public sector, were conducted.Main Outcome MeasureCovered are (i) the health system in Lebanon including policies and laws related to mental health care provision and relevance to paraphilic disorders, (ii) the legal framework and the mental health evaluation and treatment in the Lebanese criminal justice system: the case of paraphilic disorders, (iii) adjudication of sex offenders in Lebanon, (iv) criminal responsibility relevant to paraphilic disorders, and (v) the relationship between legal and clinical issues for non–forensic health professionals.ResultsThe treatment of paraphilic disorders would follow the treatment of all mental health conditions in Lebanon as no specific services for paraphilic disorders are available within these health-care systems. Legally, sexual crimes in Lebanon are not judged according to the individual's urges, fantasies, or state of mind, rather are assessed according to the acts committed by the individual. Therefore, an individual diagnosed with a paraphilic disorder is not culpable of any crime should he not act on this disorder by committing acts that fall under the scope of the penal code. An analysis of sexual acts that qualify as crimes reveals that the element of consent is rarely taken into consideration as most sexual crimes are defined as such with reference to violation of social norms, primarily “morals and public morality.” Therefore, a change in the diagnostic classification of mental and behavioral disorders (ICD or Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders) should not be a factor in their definition. Furthermore, in the course of enforcing criminal sanctions on individuals diagnosed with a mental disorder, the determining factor will be the individual's state of awareness at the time of the act. Psychiatric expertise initiated in that context lacks standardized criteria for diagnosis and is not bound by law to rely on international classifications; it is usually based on nonstructured interviews. Should it be assessed that the individual was fully aware of the consequences of his or her act, the paraphilic disorder diagnosis should not play any role in the sentencing.Clinical implicationsClinicians in Lebanon can now be aware of the legal sanctions that patients with paraphilic disorders may fall under, should criminal acts be committed. Clinicians can also be familiar with the role of mental health disorders in the legal system, specifically with relevance to “awareness” at the time of the criminal act. Moreover, clinicians can freely use the updated diagnoses of paraphilic disorders in the ICD-11, as they form no legal detriments in Lebanon.Strength & LimitationsThe interviewing technique used in this study ensured that participants spoke about issues pertinent to their experience and expertise and helped achieve data saturation. Nonetheless, although this is a review, a quality and bias screening tool was not used because of the search mostly pertaining to legal laws and cases instead of research articles. furthermore, no software was used to analyze the qualitative data from the interviews. In addition, some of the documents reviewed were in Arabic, and therefore, some nuances, while translating the essential findings to English, might have been lost in translation.ConclusionCompared with the ICD-10, the categories and definitions in ICD-11 should not create any additional obstacles nor offer any direct positive consideration, as the diagnostic classifications of mental disorders (ICD or Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders) are not relevant to the definition of criminal sexual acts in Lebanon.Makhlouf Y, Kerbage H, Khauli N, et al. Legal and Policy Considerations in Lebanon Related to Proposals for Paraphilic Disorders in World Health Organization's International Classification of Diseases Manual, 11th Version. J Sex Med 2020;17:491–504.