Ethics and Economics in Search of a Common Language

Book reviewed in this article: The Needs of Strangers . By Michael Ignatieff. The Health Economy . By Victor Fuchs. Just Health Care . By Norman Daniels     

Impact of smoking on cancer stage at diagnosis.

BACKGROUND: Studies evaluating the relationship between smoking and cancer spread are limited. METHODS: We studied the relationship between cancer stage at diagnosis (local, regional, or metastatic) and smoking history (current, previous, or nonsmoker). For lung cancer, patterns of spread were also studied. RESULTS: In a tumor registry for eastern North Dakota, northwestern Minnesota, and northern South Dakota, 11,716 cases were identified from 1986 to 2001. Current smokers (relative risk [RR], 2.11; 95% confidence interval, 1.93 to 2.32; P <.001) and previous smokers (RR, 1.56; 95% confidence interval, 1.42 to 1.72; P <.001) had an increased risk of metastatic disease at diagnosis. Current smokers (RR, 1.39; 95% confidence interval, 1.29 to 1.51; P <.001), but not previous smokers, also had an increased risk of regional disease. An increase in metastatic disease was most evident for prostate cancer (RR, 1.53; P =.003). An increase in regional disease was most evident for head and neck (RR, 3.53; P <.001), prostate (RR, 1.83; P =.030), and breast cancer (RR, 1.22; P =.005). Compared with previous smokers, current smokers with metastatic lung cancer were more likely to have involvement of the brain (33.6% v 23.0%; P =.004), bone marrow, adrenal gland, and pericardium (24.7% v 15.9%; P =.004). CONCLUSION: Previous or current smoking is a risk factor for increased cancer stage in a wide range of malignancies. Further study is required to determine whether this association is causal.     

Complications of microlaparoscopy and awake laparoscopy.

Complications of laparoscopy are categorized into trocar insertion complications, complications resulting from image quality, and complications resulting from instrumentation. Microlaparoscopy also has similar complications and additional complications when being performed in the awake patient. Each of these complications is reviewed as they apply to microlaparoscopy. The results reveal that the seriousness of the complication is directly dependent on the size of the perforation. Therefore, surgeons' reluctance to downsize the instruments used is increasing the laparoscopy complication rate. Using smaller-diameter trocars and instruments reduces laparoscopic complication rates.     

Associated occurrence of persistent truncus arteriosus and asplenia

Summary An infant with persistent truncus arteriosus associated with splenic agenesis and the asplenia syndrome is reported, including clinical, echocardiographic and autopsy findings. To the authors' knowledge this association has not been previously reported.     

cDNA Sequencing of the 5′ Noncoding Region (5′ NCR) to Determine Hepatitis C Genotypes in Patients with Chronic Hepatitis C

Reports suggest that response tointerferon-alpha therapy is influenced by both hepatitisC viral genotype and titer. Our aim was to determine ifdirect, automated, cycle sequencing of the PCR productfrom an HCV RNA detection assay could be used toreliably determine HCV genotype. In addition, theapproach was used to determine the HCV genotypedistribution in our patient population and to learn ifthere was a correlation between HCV genotype and RNAtiter that could be used to predict response totreatment. In all 143 consecutive patients were testedfor both HCV RNA titer and genotype. Automated, cycle sequencing of PCR product was highly effectiveand failed to yield a genotype in only 3 (2%) patients.The distribution of HCV genotypes was: 1a (40%), 1b(39%), 2a (2%), 2b (6%), 3a (4%). There were significant differences in the median HCV RNA titersbetween genotypes 1, 2, and 3. 6 High HCV RNA titers>4.4 × 10⁶ copies/ml were only seenin genotype 1. However, the HCV RNA level should not beused as a surrogate marker of genotype because of a significantoverlap of titers within the genotypes.     

The syndrome of senile gait

Summary Infrared computed stroboscopic photometry was used to quantify the kinematic profiles of walking in 10 elderly patients with symmetrical neurological disturbances of gait and in 19 age-matched neurologically healthy people. Clinical examination of the patients revealed similar profiles of walking even though their diagnoses were vascular dementia (2), normal pressure hydrocephalus (2), Alzheimer dementia with possible normal pressure hydrocephalus (2), mixed Alzheimer and vascular dementia (1), peripheral neuropathy (1), Alzheimer dementia with parkinsonian features (1), and un determined (1). Quantitatively, the patients' gait kinematics deviated greatly from control values, but these deviations were statistically attributable to reductions in stride. We suggest that many gait disturbances in elderly people are similar, regardless of etiology, because the characteristics of these gait disturbances are heavily veiled by nonspecific stride-dependent changes that comprise the syndrome of senile gait.     

Antiviral immune responses modulate the nature of central nervous system (CNS) disease in a murine model of multiple sclerosis

Summary: In animals and in humans, T-cell therapy can cure advanced disseminated leukemia that would otherwise be fatal. The therapeutic effect of immune T cells is quantitative. As the dose of effector T cells is increased, survival is proportionately increased. Therefore, effective T-cell therapy is predicated on the ability to procure large numbers of immune effector T cells. By using cultured T cells, the number of immune T cells can be increased in vivo substantially above che level achievable by vaccination. The survival of cultured T ceils in vivo is dependent upon both the culture conditions used and the therapeutic regimens employed. Under appropriate conditions, cultured T ceils can proliferate in vivo in response to stimulation by antigen, distribute widely and survive long term to provide effector function and immunologic memory. Given that T cells recognize peptides. the need for immunization with tumor can be circumvented by immunization with peptide. Peptide-specific T cells and the progeny of single T-cell clones can provide the necessary cellular functions to eradicate disseminated murine leukemia. The ability of cloned T cells to similarly provide substantial measurable immunity in humans has been validated in clinical trials. By priming with peptides and by using established culture conditions, T-cell therapy can now be directed against virtually any antigen within the host T-cell repertoire. The major remaining question to be answered is which proteins and which peptides are the most suitable targets for T-cell therapy trials.     

Methylmercury poisoning: Long-term clinical,radiological, toxicological,and pathological studies of an affected family

For 3 months in 1969 a family in the United States that included a pregnant mother consumed pork containing methylmercury. Children, aged 20, 13, and 8 years and a neonate, developed severe neurological signs. Twenty-two years later, the 2 oldest had cortical blindness or constricted visual fields, diminished hand proprioception, choreoathetosis, and atentional deficits. Magnetic resonance images showed tissue loss in the calcarine and parietal cortices and cerebellar folia. The youngest had quadriplegia, blindness, and severe mental retradation until their deaths. The brain of the 8-year-old who died at age 30 showed cortical atrophy, neuronal loss, and gliosis, most pronounced in the paracentral and parietooccipital regions. The total mercury level in formalin-fixed, left occipital cortex was 1,974 ng/gm as measured by atomic absorption. Regional brain mercury levels correlated with extent of brain damage. A control patient had 38.5 ng of mercury/gm in the occipital cortex. Systemic organs in the patient and a control subject had comparable mercury levels. In mercury-intoxicated rats, we found that only 5 to 10% of total brain mercury was lost by formalin fixation. Brain inorganic mercury in the patient ranged from 82 to 100%. Since inorganic mercury crosses the blood-brain barrier poorly, biotransformation of methyl to inorganic mercury may have occurred after methylmercury crossed the blood-brain barrier, accounting for its persistence in brain and causing part of the brain damage.