The health care resource allocation debate. Defining our terms

The problem of health care distribution in the United States demands immediate action. Many different solutions have been proposed to slow rising health care costs and to improve access to care for the poor and uninsured. Debate among proponents of these various proposals might be advanced if a common language were adopted with regard to certain key terms instead of the various meanings currently assigned to these terms. For this reason, we propose and defend the following three definitions: (1) rationing is the societal toleration of inequitable access to health services acknowledged to be necessary by reference to necessary-care guidelines; (2) health care needs are desires for services that have been reasonably well demonstrated to provide significant net benefit for patients with specified clinical conditions; and (3) basic benefit plans are insurance packages that provide for all and only acknowledged health care needs, again by reference to appropriate clinical guidelines.     

The effect of diaper type and overclothing on fecal contamination in day-care centers

Fecal coliform contamination of environmental surfaces and hands in the day-care center is common. This study evaluated the effect of two diaper types on fecal contamination. Ten rooms in four day-care centers containing 141 children were studied in a prospective, randomized, crossover study. A total of 2946 samples were cultured during the 9-week study. Fecal coliforms were isolated from 307 inanimate objects (15%), 73 toy balls (46%), and 131 hands (17%). The number of contaminated inanimate objects was significantly less in rooms where paper diapers were worn when compared with that in rooms where double cloth diapers with plastic overpants were worn and in rooms where clothes were worn over diapers. Inanimate object cultures had more contamination in rooms in which diarrhea had occurred. Containment of feces by overclothes and diaper type may be important in decreasing transmission of enteric pathogens in day-care environments.     

Effect of educational programs, rigid sharps containers, and universal precautions on reported needlestick injuries in healthcare workers

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the effect of infection control programs on reported needlestick injuries in a general hospital. DESIGN: Surveillance of all reported needlestick injuries at the University of Cincinnati Hospital was maintained by the infection control department for five years, from 1985 through 1989. Data on individual workers were collected, tabulated on a monthly basis, and reviewed continually to monitor trends in injuries. During this time, the effects of each of three new infection control programs on reported injuries were evaluated sequentially. SETTING: A 700-bed general hospital that serves as the main teaching hospital of the University of Cincinnati. PARTICIPANTS: All employees of University Hospital who reported to personnel health for management of needlestick injuries. INTERVENTIONS: In 1986, an educational program to prevent injuries was initiated and continued throughout the surveillance period. In 1987, rigid sharps disposal containers were placed in all hospital rooms. In 1988, universal precautions were introduced with an intensive inservice. RESULTS: Surveillance identified 1,602 needlestick injuries (320/year) or 104/1,000/year. After the educational program began, reported injuries increased rather than decreased, and this was attributed to increased reporting. Subsequently, after installation of the new disposal containers, reported injuries returned to the levels seen prior to the educational program, but recapping injuries showed a significant decrease from 63/year to 30, or 20/1,000/year to 10. This decrease was observed in nurses but not in other healthcare workers. After universal precautions were instituted, total injuries increased slightly, but recapping injuries remained at 50% of the levels reported prior to the use of rigid sharps disposal containers. CONCLUSIONS: The three infection control programs failed to produce a major reduction in reported needlestick injuries, except for a decrease in recapping injuries associated with the placement of rigid sharps disposal containers in all patient rooms. These observations indicate that new approaches are needed to reduce needlestick injuries.     

Influence of subacute starvation on cardiac response to isoproterenol in rats.

Several studies have reported that the heart is severely affected by chronic malnutrition. However, the influence of these alterations on cardiac function remains unclear. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of subacute starvation on the heart chronotropic response to a beta-adrenergic agonist (isoproterenol). Twelve rats were fed rat chow ad libitum or a 50%-restricted diet for 17 days. The rats were killed, the right atrium was isolated and incubated, and in vitro spontaneous cardiac contractions and frequency were registered. Cumulative doses of isoproterenol were added to the solution until maximal cardiac frequency was achieved. A deficit of 25% in the weight gain was observed in study rats compared with controls (92.6 +/- 10.2 vs. 113.8 +/- 19.2 g, p less than 0.05). Mean daily food intake was 4.8 +/- 0.1 and 9.8 +/- 0.5 g/day for semistarved and control rats, respectively. The in vitro cardiac frequency of the semistarved rats was similar to that of controls (290 +/- 15 and 305 +/- 23 beats/min, respectively, NS). However, when isoproterenol was added to the solution, maximal cardiac frequency of the semistarved rats (435 +/- 51 beats/min) was lower than that of control rats (508 +/- 34 beats/min, p less than 0.005). These findings suggest that subacute starvation may alter the cardiac response to beta-adrenergic agonists.     

The effect of plasma solutes on total-body-water measurements via NMR.

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy has been reported as an alternative method for quantitating deuterium oxide concentrations in the evaluation of total-body-water in humans. However, the presence of dissolved plasma proteins results in an underestimation of deuterium NMR (2H-NMR) intensity ratios, thereby causing an overestimation (5-6%) of total-body-water (TBW) values determined from nonsublimed patient plasma samples. We demonstrate that plasma samples must be corrected for the volume percentage of water in plasma. Correction of initial 2H-NMR intensity ratios with a factor of 0.93 results in intensity ratios comparable to those determined from plasma samples subjected to vacuum sublimation to remove all plasma solutes.     

Rotavirus serology and breast-feeding in young children in rural Guinea-Bissau

One hundred and forty-four children aged 9-20 months living in 14 villages in a rural area of Guinea-Bissau were examined for circulating rotavirus antibodies twice in a 15-month period. An immunofluorescence technique was used. About 3/4 of the children seroconverted, independent of age on entering the study. The age-specific proportion of seropositivity increased from 4/40 (10%) at 9-11 months to 26/29 (90%) at 33-35 months of age. All the initially seropositive children retained detectable antibodies to rotavirus. The relative risk of seroconversion was 1.4 times (95% confidence interval 1.0-2.0) more common among children living in villages by the mainroad as compared to those living off the road. Contact rate is probably dependent on population density and mobility but not on age. Breast-feeding, decreasing sharply through the age interval covered by the follow-up (9-35 months), had no apparent influence on seroconversion at the ages concerned.