An audit of consent refusals in clinical research at a tertiary care center in India

Background and Rationale:

Ensuring research participants’ autonomy is one of the core ethical obligations of researchers. This fundamental principle confers on every participant the right to refuse to take part in clinical research, and the measure of the number of consent refusals could be an important metric to evaluate the quality of the informed consent process. This audit examined consent refusals among Indian participants in clinical studies done at our center.

Materials and Methods:

The number of consent refusals and their reasons in 10 studies done at our center over a 5-year period were assessed. The studies were classified by the authors according to the type of participant (healthy vs patients), type of sponsor (investigator-initiated vs pharmaceutical industry), type of study (observational vs interventional), level of risk [based on the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) “Ethical Guidelines for Biomedical Research on Human Participants”], available knowledge of the intervention being studied, and each patient''s disease condition.

Results:

The overall consent refusal rate was 21%. This rate was higher among patient participants [23.8% vs. healthy people (14.9%); P = 0.002], in interventional studies [33.6% vs observational studies (7.5%); P < 0.0001], in pharmaceutical industry-sponsored studies [34.7% vs investigator-initiated studies (7.2%); P < 0.0001], and in studies with greater risk (P < 0.0001). The most common reasons for consent refusals were multiple blood collections (28%), inability to comply with the study protocol (20%), and the risks involved (20%).

Conclusion:

Our audit suggests the adequacy and reasonable quality of the informed consent process using consent refusals as a metric.KEY WORDS: Autonomy, consent, India, reason, refusal, risk     

Enhancement of erythrocyte superoxide dismutase activity: effects on cellular oxidant defense

To delineate further the role of superoxide dismutase (SOD) in red blood cell (RBC) oxidant defense, normal human erythrocytes were osmotically lysed and resealed in the presence of varying concentrations of exogenous SOD. This resulted in a dose-dependent increase in SOD activity in the resealed erythrocytes while maintaining nearly normal RBC hemoglobin concentration (less than 10% decrease from the control value), cell volume, and cellular deformability. Surprisingly, a five- or ninefold increase in SOD activity yielded no additional protection against superoxide-generating drugs (phenazine methosulfate or menadione sodium bisulfite). No significant differences were observed between the control and SOD-loaded RBCs in O2-driven methemoglobin formation or generation of thiobarbituric acid-reactive substances. In contrast, RBCs with elevated SOD activity pretreated with sodium azide (to block catalase activity) or 1-chloro-2,4- dinitrobenzene (to deplete reduced glutathione, GSH) showed significantly enhanced methemoglobin generation in response to superoxide generating drugs. No differential response was noted between the control, control-resealed, and SOD-loaded RBCs to oxidants other than superoxide. Based on our results and other data, we conclude that elevated SOD activity may imbalance cellular oxidant defense, resulting in enhanced oxidation due to the accelerated generation of H2O2, the product of O2- dismutation. This effect is significantly exacerbated under conditions in which H2O2 catabolism is altered.     

Adoptive immunotherapy evaluating escalating doses of donor leukocytes for relapse of chronic myeloid leukemia after bone marrow transplantation: separation of graft-versus-leukemia responses from graft-versus-host disease

Infusions of large numbers (> 10(8)/kg) of donor leukocytes can induce remissions in patients with chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) who relapse after marrow transplantation. We wanted to determine if substantially lower numbers of donor leukocytes could induce remissions and, if so, whether this would reduce the 90% incidence of graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) associated with this therapy. Twenty-two patients with relapsed CML were studied: 2 in molecular relapse, 6 in cytogenetic relapse, 10 in chronic phase, and 4 in accelerated phase. Each patient received escalating doses of donor leukocytes at 4- to 33-week intervals. Leukocyte doses were calculated as T cells per kilogram of recipient weight. There were 8 dose levels between 1 x 10(5) and 5 x 10(8). Lineage-specific chimerism and residual leukemia detection were assessed using sensitive polymerase chain reaction (PCR) methodologies. Nineteen of the 22 patients achieved remission. Remissions were achieved at the following T-cell doses: 1 x 10(7) (n = 8), 5 x 10(7) (n = 4), 1 x 10(8) (n = 3), and 5 x 10(8) (n = 4). To date, 15 of the 17 evaluable patients have become BCR-ABL negative by PCR. The incidence of GVHD was correlated with the dose of T cells administered. Only 1 of the 8 patients who achieved remission at a T-cell dose of 1 x 10(7)/kg developed GVHD, whereas this complication developed in 8 of the 11 responders who received a T-cell dose of > or = 5 x 10(7)/kg. Three patients died in remission, 1 secondary to marrow aplasia, 1 of respiratory failure and 1 of complications of chronic GVHD. Sixteen patients who were mixed T-cell chimeras before treatment became full donor T-cell chimeras at the time of remission. Donor leukocytes with a T-cell content as low as 1 x 10(7)/kg can result in complete donor chimerism together with a potent graft-versus-leukemia (GVL) effect. The dose of donor leukocytes or T cells used may be important in determining both the GVL response and the incidence of GVHD. In many patients, this potent GVL effect can occur in the absence of clinical GVHD.     

Plasma P-selectin is increased in thrombotic consumptive platelet disorders

P-selectin is a 140-kD protein found in the alpha-granules of platelets and the Weibel-Palade bodies of endothelial cells that on cell activation is expressed on the cell surface and also secreted into the plasma. The secreted form of P-selectin, like plasma P-selectin, differed from platelet membrane P-selectin in that its molecular mass was approximately 3 kD lower under reducing conditions. Both the secreted and plasma forms of P-selectin contained cytoplasmic sequence as determined by Western blot analysis with an affinity-purified rabbit anti-P-selectin cytoplasmic peptide antibody. We have measured plasma P- selectin and beta-thromboglobulin (beta TG) concurrently in (1) patients with consumptive thrombotic disorders, including disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC), heparin-induced thrombocytopenia (HIT), and thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura (TTP)/haemolytic uremic syndrome (HUS); (2) patients with idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura (ITP); and (3) healthy controls. Patients with DIC, HIT, and TTP/HUS, but not ITP, had significantly elevated plasma P-selectin and beta TG levels when compared with their age-matched healthy controls. The increased plasma P-selectin and beta TG in patients with thrombotic disorders were likely to be the result of in vivo platelet and endothelial cell damage or activation. We also found that avoidance of veno-occlusion and other tedious measures customarily taken during blood collection and sample preparation to prevent in vitro platelet activation did not affect plasma P-selectin assay results. In addition, plasma P-selectin levels were not influenced by the presence of renal failure or heparin administration. These results indicate that plasma P- selectin may be a useful new marker for thrombotic diseases.     

Influence of clinical status on the association between plasma total and unbound bilirubin and death or adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes in extremely low birth weight infants

Objectives: To assess the influence of clinical status on the association between total plasma bilirubin and unbound bilirubin on death or adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes at 18–22 months corrected age in extremely low birth weight infants. Method: Total plasma bilirubin and unbound bilirubin were measured in 1101 extremely low birth weight infants at 5 ± 1 days of age. Clinical criteria were used to classify infants as clinically stable or unstable. Survivors were examined at 18–22 months corrected age by certified examiners. Outcome variables were death or neurodevelopmental impairment, death or cerebral palsy, death or hearing loss, and death prior to follow‐up. For all outcomes, the interaction between bilirubin variables and clinical status was assessed in logistic regression analyses adjusted for multiple risk factors. Results: Regardless of clinical status, an increasing level of unbound bilirubin was associated with higher rates of death or neurodevelopmental impairment, death or cerebral palsy, death or hearing loss and death before follow‐up. Total plasma bilirubin values were directly associated with death or neurodevelopmental impairment, death or cerebral palsy, death or hearing loss, and death before follow‐up in unstable infants, but not in stable infants. An inverse association between total plasma bilirubin and death or cerebral palsy was found in stable infants. Conclusions: In extremely low birth weight infants, clinical status at 5 days of age affects the association between total plasma bilirubin and death or adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes at 18–22 months of corrected age. An increasing level of UB is associated a higher risk of death or adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes regardless of clinical status. Increasing levels of total plasma bilirubin are directly associated with increasing risk of death or adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes in unstable, but not in stable infants.     

Regulation of diabetes and late complications in the ambulatory treatment of patients with Type II diabetes mellitus]

In order to obtain more information on the quality of metabolic control and presence of secondary complications in type 2 diabetic patients treated in a hospital outpatient-clinic, we studied 124 of our diabetic patients (56 males, 68 females, age 65 (SD 11) years, duration of diabetes 9, range 1-32 years). HbA1c levels were 7.9% in patients on oral hypoglycaemic agents (n = 56), and 8.2% in insulin-treated patients (n = 59). Cholesterol and triglyceride levels tended to be lower in the insulin-treated patients. The prevalence of vascular abnormalities was high: in comparison with a population of general practice patients more patients had hypertension (56% vs 38%), coronary artery disease (48% vs 40%), and cerebrovascular disease (15% vs 6%). In addition, 35% of our diabetics had signs of peripheral artery disease. Retinopathy was present in 35 patients, microalbuminuria was found in 31 patients, proteinuria in 18 patients. The presence of microalbuminuria and proteinuria was a strong indicator for cardiovascular disease, polyneuropathy and retinopathy. The use of cardiovascular medication was high: 57 patients used antihypertensive therapy, 37 used diuretics, and 26 long-acting nitrates. Only 25 patients took no medication apart from to their diabetes therapy.     

Carcinoid crisis after injection of 6-18F-fluorodihydroxyphenylalanine in a patient with metastatic carcinoid.

A carcinoid crisis is a severe complication of the carcinoid syndrome that can arise in patients with advanced metastatic neuroendocrine tumors. It can be initiated by stress, catecholamines, and tumor manipulation. In this article, we report a case in which an injection with the catecholamine tracer 6-18F-fluorodihydroxyphenylalanine, used for PET, induced a carcinoid crisis. Octreotide can be used for treatment and should be available. Tracer injection should be slow.     

Human papillomavirus type 16 (HPV 16) E7 and major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I and II expression in human keratinocytes in culture

Archives of Virology - The low expression of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I antigens on human papillomavirus (HPV)-infected cervical carcinoma cells may be responsible for an...