Medical Necessity in Canadian Health Policy: Four Meanings and . . . a Funeral?

Four meanings of medical necessity have emerged, evolved, and dominated past and current health policy debates about the appropriate level of service coverage under Canada's health insurance program. To explore the shift in definition, provincial government and national health care association position papers responding to federal legislative and policy reviews of Canada's health insurance program from 1957 to 1984 were examined, as were more current reports on medical necessity. Four meanings of medical necessity predominated: "what doctors and hospitals do"; "the maximum we can afford"; "what is scientifically justified"; and "what is consistently funded across all provinces." These meanings changed with time as different stakeholder associations and governments redefined the concept of medical necessity to achieve different policy objectives for health service coverage under Canada's health insurance program.     

Memory outcome at 5 years post-childhood traumatic brain injury

Primary objective: This study seeks to extend previous findings by documenting memory performance in a sample of 70 children at 5 years post-injury. It was anticipated that increasing injury severity would be associated with decreased performance on working and complex memory tasks. It was also expected that injury severity would significantly predict memory, but that the time from insult to subsequent testing would be associated with an increased relationship to non-injury factors.

Research design: Participants were assessed at 5 years post-injury, aged between 6-14 years, using measures of immediate, working and complex memory.

Methods and procedures: The sample comprised 18 children who had sustained a severe TBI, 24 with a moderate TBI, 11 with a mild TBI and 17 healthy controls, matched for age, gender and socio-economic-status.

Results: Results indicated that severe TBI was associated with decreased complex auditory-verbal memory performance, although children with TBI did not display impairment on immediate, working or complex visual-spatial memory. While injury severity significantly predicted complex memory outcome, non-injury factors failed to significantly predict either working or complex memory performance.

Conclusions: Future research should be engineered towards further clarifying what influences recovery from childhood TBI in the elongated post-injury period.     

Controlled clinical comparison of plastic versus glass bottles of BacT/ALERT PF medium for culturing blood from children

The plastic pediatric BacT/ALERT (bioMérieux, Durham, N.C.) PF (PPF) is a new nonvented aerobic culture medium in a clear plastic bottle designed to prevent breakage. We compared the performance of the new PPF bottle to that of the present glass BacT/ALERT PF bottle for the recovery of microorganisms as well as for the time to detection of growth in samples of blood obtained for culture from children. We found that the PPF and PF bottles were comparable for recovery of microorganisms and that the safety advantage of plastic bottles can be achieved without compromising performance.     

Induction of protein oxidation by cobalt and chromium ions in human U937 macrophages

Metal particles and ions from hip prostheses have the potential to induce the production of reactive oxygen species (ROS), making them prime suspects for disturbing the cellular balance of oxidants/antioxidants (redox state of the cell). To better understand the cellular effect of metal ions from metal-on-metal prostheses, the aim of this study was to examine the effect of cobalt (Co2+) and chromium (Cr3+) ions on protein oxidation in human U937 macrophages. Protein oxidation was measured by Western blot using antibodies directed against dinitrophenylhydrazine (DNP)-derivatized protein carbonyls, the most commonly measured products of protein oxidation in biological samples. Three DNP-derived proteins were detected. The first has a molecular weight of 16 kDa and is expressed at a very low level. The second has a molecular weight of 48 kDa and its level is not regulated by metal ions. The third is a 69 kDa protein and its level is regulated by Co2+ and Cr3+ ions. Therefore, the last band served as a marker of protein oxidation in the present study. Results showed that Co2+ and Cr3+ ions induced a time- and dose-dependent protein oxidation reaching 6.5 and 2.9 times the control after 72 h, respectively, which were inhibited by the antioxidant glutathione monoethyl-ester. Finally, results showed that the oxidized proteins are mainly found in the cytoplasmic fraction of the cells and are absent from the nucleus. In conclusion, our results suggest that metal ions from metal-on-metal prostheses have the potential to modify the redox state of cells both locally (periprosthetic environment) or systematically (circulating cells). The long term effect of these ions on protein oxidation in vivo remains to be investigated.     

Improving HIV surveillance in Victoria: the role of the "detuned" enzyme immunoassay

Between 1999 and 2000, new diagnoses of HIV in Victoria (Australia) rose by 41%, from 140 to 197. In this time period, sera from new HIV diagnoses were tested using the Organon Teknika "detuned" enzyme immunoassay (EIA). We compared the results of the detuned EIA with incident infections defined by surveillance (on the basis of a previous negative or indeterminate HIV test and/or a seroconversion illness within the 12 months preceding HIV diagnosis). Of 317 specimens, 97 (31%) incident infections and 114 (36%) recent infections were detected using surveillance and detuned EIA, respectively. The detuned assay misclassified 11 cases with AIDS and 2 cases with CD4 counts < or = 200 micro3 (probable long-standing infections) as recent infections and was unable to identify 31 (32%) of 97 cases previously classified as incident cases by surveillance. The assay detected an extra 35 recent infections that were previously classified as nonincident by surveillance. By combining the detuned assay and surveillance, 132 (42%) incident infections were identified from 317 specimens, 36% more than surveillance alone. We recommend that a detuned assay or similar test become part of the routine strategy to identify incident infections in Victoria. Incident infections provide important information for targeting prevention strategies and the opportunity to interrupt ongoing viral transmission.     

Sequence variation in the 3'-untranslated region of the dopamine transporter gene and attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).

The dopamine transporter gene (DAT1) has been reported to be associated with attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in a number of studies [Cook et al. (1995): Am J Human Genet 56(4):9993-998; Gill et al. (1997): Mol Psychiatry 2(4):311-313; Waldman et al. (1998): Am J Human Genet 63(6):1767-1776; Barr et al. (2001): Biol Psychiatry 49(4):333-339; Curran et al. (2001): Mol Psychiatry 6(4):425-428; Chen et al. (2003): Mol Psychiatry 8(4):393-396]. Specifically, the 10-repeat allele of the 40-bp variable number of tandem repeats (VNTR) polymorphism located in the 3' untranslated region (UTR) of the gene has been found to be associated with ADHD. There is evidence from in vitro studies indicating that variability in the repeat number, and sequence variation in the 3'-UTR of the DAT1 gene may influence the level of the dopamine transporter protein [Fuke et al. (2001): Pharmacogenomics J 1(2):152-156; Miller and Madras (2002): Mol Psychiatry 7(1):44-55]. In this study, we investigated whether DNA variation in the DAT1 3'UTR contributed to ADHD by genotyping DNA variants around the VNTR region in a sample of 178 ADHD families. These included a MspI polymorphism (rs27072), a DraI DNA change (T/C) reported to influence DAT1 expression levels, and a BstUI polymorphism (rs3863145) in addition to the VNTR. We also screened the VNTR region by direct resequencing to determine if there was sequence variation within the repeat units that could account for the association. Our results indicate that DAT1 is associated with ADHD in our sample but not with alleles of the VNTR polymorphism. We did not find any variation in the sequence for either the 10- or 9-repeat alleles in the probands screened nor did we observe the reported DraI (T/C) variation. Our results therefore refute the possibility of the reported DraI variation or alleles of the VNTR as the functional variants contributing to the disorder.     

Identification of a gene from Xp21 with similarity to the tctex-1 gene of the murine t complex

Long range physical mapping within the p21 region of the X chromosomeIdentified a CpG rich Island approximately 180 kb centromericto the chronic granulomatous disease (CGD) locus. The segmentsadjacent to the CpG Island hybridized to discrete bands In DNAsof several species and when used to screen retinal cDNA librariesled to the Identification of cDNAs that detected a mRNA of 2.1kb in many tissues. Molecular characterization of correspondinggenomic clones of this novel human gene confirmed the originof the cDNA clones and Indicated a genomic structure with fiveexons spanning a total of 9 kb. The complete cDNA sequence revealedthat this gene contained a putative open reading frame of 116amino acids with a 3' untranslated region of 1.74 kb. The aminoacid sequence shows a high degree of similarity to the predictedproduct of the tctex-1 gene of the mouse t complex. As linkagestudies and patients with deletions have Implicated the Xp21region as containing the retInltls plgmentosa defect (RP3),the gene was assessed as a candidate disease gene In RP3 families.A single base pair polymorphism was Identified within the codingregion but no disease associated changes were found by singlestrand conformational polymorphism and sequencing analysis ofamplified exons of 20 RP patients. Analysis of a dinucleotiderepeat polymorphism within this gene In families affected withRP3 suggested refinement of the RP3 region.     

Characterization of FMR1 proteins isolated from different tissues

FMR1 protein expression was studied in different tissues. Inhuman, monkey and murine tissues, high molecular mass FMR1 proteins(67–80 kDa) are found, as shown in lymphobiastoid celiiines. The identity of these proteins was confirmed by theirabsence in tissues from patients with the fragile X syndromeand a FMR1 knock-out mouse. An IIe367Asn substitution in theFMR1 protein did not aiter the transiation, processing and localizationof FMR1 proteins in lymphoblastoid cells from a patient carryingthis mutation. All the high molecular mass FMR1 proteins isolatedfrom normal lymphoblastoid cells and cells from the patientwith the IIe367Asn substitution were able to bind RNA. However,the FMR1 proteins of the patient had reduced affinity for RNAbinding at high salt concentrations. In some human, monkey andmurine tissues low molecular mass FMR1 proteins (39–41kDa) were found, which had the same N terminus as the 67–90kDa isoforms, but differ in their C terminus and are thereforemost likely the result of carboxy-terminal proteolytic cleavage.These low molecular mass FMR1 proteins did not bind RNA, incontrast with the high molecular mass FMR1 proteins. The significanceof these low molecular mass proteins remains to be studied.     

Recovery of cryopreserved 96-well plates from −80° C

Summary A simple method is described for the effective recovery of cells cryopreserved in 96-well plates.