Impact of adjustment for quality on results of metaanalyses of diagnostic accuracy

BACKGROUND: We examined whether and to what extent different strategies of defining and incorporating quality of included studies affect the results of metaanalyses of diagnostic accuracy. METHODS: We evaluated the methodological quality of 487 diagnostic-accuracy studies in 30 systematic reviews with the QUADAS (Quality Assessment of Diagnostic-Accuracy Studies) checklist. We applied 3 strategies that varied both in the definition of quality and in the statistical approach to incorporate the quality-assessment results into metaanalyses. We compared magnitudes of diagnostic odds ratios, widths of their confidence intervals, and changes in a hypothetical clinical decision between strategies. RESULTS: Following 2 definitions of quality, we concluded that only 70 or 72 of 487 studies were of "high quality". This small number was partly due to poor reporting of quality items. None of the strategies for accounting for differences in quality led systematically to accuracy estimates that were less optimistic than ignoring quality in metaanalyses. Limiting the review to high-quality studies considerably reduced the number of studies in all reviews, with wider confidence intervals as a result. In 18 reviews, the quality adjustment would have resulted in a different decision about the usefulness of the test. CONCLUSIONS: Although reporting the results of quality assessment of individual studies is necessary in systematic reviews, reader wariness is warranted regarding claims that differences in methodological quality have been accounted for. Obstacles for adjusting for quality in metaanalyses are poor reporting of design features and patient characteristics and the relatively low number of studies in most diagnostic reviews.     

Anaphylaxis: an update for dental practitioners

Anaphylaxis is an acutely presenting life‐threatening medical emergency. Surveys indicate that dentists feel inadequately able to recognize and treat anaphylaxis. This paper reviews the terminology and pathophysiology of anaphylaxis, and describes the recognition and initial management of anaphylaxis for dentists. Dentists should be able to administer intramuscular adrenaline during anaphylaxis at the appropriate dose. The role of further medical care is also explained. Six cases of anaphylaxis arising from dental oral maxillofacial surgery practice are discussed.     

Is there an association between anxiety/depression and temporomandibular disorders in college students?

Objective

Considering the high incidence of Temporomandibular Disorders (TMD) in the population aged 15-30 years and the fact that students are exposed to stressful psychosocial factors, the purposes of this study were: to verify clinical symptoms and jaw functionality in college students with TMD according to the anxiety/depression (A/D) level and to evaluate the correlation between A/D and functionality, maximum mouth opening (MMO) and pain and muscle activity.

Material and Methods

Nineteen students with TMD diagnosed according to the Research Diagnostic Criteria for Temporomandibular Disorders underwent two assessments during an academic semester. The evaluations were based on questionnaires (MFIQ - Mandibular Function Impairment Questionnaire; HADS - Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale), clinical measurements (MMO without pain, MMO and assisted MMO; palpation of joint and masticatory muscles), and electromyography. The HADS scores obtained in the two assessments were used to classify all data as either "high" or "low" A/D. Data normality, differences and correlations were tested with the Shapiro-Wilk test, Student''s t-test (or the Wilcoxon test), and Spearman test, respectively. The alpha level was set at 0.05.

Results

None of the clinical variables were significantly different when comparing low and high A/D data. In low A/D there was a significant correlation between HADS score and: MFIQ (P=0.005, r=0.61), and MMO without pain (P=0.01, r=-0.55).

Conclusions

Variation in A/D level did not change clinical symptoms or jaw functionality in college students with TMD. Apparently, there is a correlation between TMJ functionality and A/D level, which should be further investigated, taking into account the source of the TMD and including subjects with greater functional limitation.     

Automated Network Assembly of Mechanistic Literature for Informed Evidence Identification to Support Cancer Risk Assessment

Background: Mechanistic data is increasingly used in hazard identification of chemicals. However, the volume of data is large, challenging the efficient identification and clustering of relevant data.Objectives: We investigated whether evidence identification for hazard assessment can become more efficient and informed through an automated approach that combines machine reading of publications with network visualization tools.Methods: We chose 13 chemicals that were evaluated by the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) Monographs program incorporating the key characteristics of carcinogens (KCCs) approach. Using established literature search terms for KCCs, we retrieved and analyzed literature using Integrated Network and Dynamical Reasoning Assembler (INDRA). INDRA combines large-scale literature processing with pathway databases and extracts relationships between biomolecules, bioprocesses, and chemicals into statements (e.g., “benzene activates DNA damage”). These statements were subsequently assembled into networks and compared with the KCC evaluation by the IARC, to evaluate the informativeness of our approach.Results: We found, in general, larger networks for those chemicals which the IARC has evaluated the evidence to be strong for KCC induction. Larger networks were not directly linked to publication count, given that we retrieved small networks for several chemicals with little support for KCC activation according to the IARC, despite the significant volume of literature for these specific chemicals. In addition, interpreting networks for genotoxicity and DNA repair showed concordance with the IARC KCC evaluation.Discussion: Our method is an automated approach to condense mechanistic literature into searchable and interpretable networks based on an a priori ontology. The approach is no replacement of expert evaluation but, instead, provides an informed structure for experts to quickly identify which statements are made in which papers and how these could connect. We focused on the KCCs because these are supported by well-described search terms. The method needs to be tested in other frameworks as well to demonstrate its generalizability. https://doi.org/10.1289/EHP9112     

培养心肌细胞牵张刺激装置的建立及应用

1　方法　牵张刺激装置的制作如模式图 1.制作实验模型采用材料为有机玻璃板、2 4孔培养板、硅胶膜 (厚度 0 .2 2 μｍ) .硅胶膜从平面圆形变为球形时 ,面积扩大的百分比 =(Ｓ球 -Ｓ园 ) /Ｓ园 ,其中Ｓ球 =ＡＤ2 ,Ｓ园 =ｒ2 ,而ＡＤ2 =ｈ2 +ｒ2 ,其中ｒ为孔的半径 ,ｈ为膜升高的高度图 2 .通过控制ｈ的大小 ,可控制膜被牵拉的强度 .本实验采用使膜面积扩大 2 0 %的强度 ,故ｈ =4ｍｍ[1] .参照Ｋａｓｓｉｒｉ等[2 ,3 ] 方法进行心肌细胞的分离培养 .生长有贴壁心肌细胞的 2 4孔板被固定于牵张装置 ,缓慢充气使硅胶膜向上凸起 4ｍｍ ,分别维持…     

The photobiology of the human circadian clock

In modern society, the widespread use of artificial light at night disrupts the suprachiasmatic nucleus (SCN), which serves as our central circadian clock. Existing models describe excitatory responses of the SCN to primarily blue light, but direct measures in humans are absent. The combination of state-of-the-art neuroimaging techniques and custom-made MRI compatible light-emitting diode devices allowed to directly measure the light response of the SCN. In contrast to the general expectation, we found that blood oxygen level–dependent (BOLD) functional MRI signals in the SCN were suppressed by light. The suppressions were observed not only in response to narrowband blue light (λ_max: 470 nm) but remarkably, also in response to green (λ_max: 515 nm) and orange (λ_max: 590 nm), but not to violet light (λ_max: 405 nm). The broadband sensitivity of the SCN implies that strategies on light exposure should be revised: enhancement of light levels during daytime is possible with wavelengths other than blue, while during nighttime, all colors are potentially disruptive.

Due to the Earth’s rotation around its axis, many organisms developed an internal clock to anticipate the predictable changes in the environment that occur every 24 h, including the daily light–dark cycle. In mammals, this clock is located in the suprachiasmatic nucleus (SCN), located in the hypothalamus directly above the optic chiasm (1, 2). The SCN receives information from the retina regarding ambient light levels via intrinsically photosensitive retinal ganglion cells (ipRGCs), thus synchronizing its internal clock to the external light–dark cycle. ipRGCs contain the photopigment melanopsin, which is maximally sensitive to blue light, with a peak response to 480-nm light (3, 4). In addition, ipRGCs also receive input from rod cells and cone cells (5–7). The three cone cell subtypes in the human retina respond maximally to 420-nm, 534-nm, and 563-nm light, while rod cells respond maximally to 498-nm light (8). In rodents, input from cone cells renders the SCN sensitive to a broad spectrum of wavelengths (9), while rod cells mediate the SCN’s sensitivity to low-intensity light (10, 11). Recently, these findings in rodents were proposed to translate to humans (12), suggesting that the human clock is not only sensitive to blue light, but may also be sensitive to other colors.In humans, circadian responses to light are generally measured indirectly (e.g., by measuring melatonin levels or 24-h behavioral rhythms). These indirect measures revealed that circadian responses to light in humans are most sensitive to blue light (13–16); however, green light has also been found to contribute to circadian phase shifting and changes in melatonin to a larger extent than would have been predicted based solely on the melanopsin response, suggesting that rods and/or cones may also provide functional input to the circadian system in humans (17). Despite this indirect evidence suggesting that several colors can affect the human circadian clock, this has never been measured directly due to technical limitations. Thus, current guidelines regarding the use of artificial light are based solely on the clock’s sensitivity to blue light. For example, blue light is usually filtered out in electronic screens during the night (18, 19), and blue-enriched light is used by night shift workers to optimize their body rhythm for achieving maximum performance (20–22).The ability to directly image the human SCN in vivo has been severely limited due to its small size and the relatively low spatial resolution provided by medical imaging devices. Previous functional MRI (fMRI) studies using 3-Tesla (3T) scanners were restricted to recording the “suprachiasmatic area,” which encompasses a large part of the hypothalamus and thus includes many other potentially light-sensitive nuclei (23–25). To overcome this limitation, we used a 7T MRI scanner, which can provide images with sufficiently high spatial resolution to image small brain nuclei (26) such as the SCN. Here, we applied colored light stimuli to healthy volunteers using a custom-designed MRI-compatible light-emitting diode (LED) device designed to stimulate specific photoreceptors while measuring SCN activity using fMRI. Using analytical approaches, we then identified the SCN’s response, the smallest brain nucleus that has so far been imaged. We found that the human SCN responds to a broad range of wavelengths (i.e., blue, green and orange light). Surprisingly, we also found that the blood oxygen level–dependent (BOLD) fMRI signal at the SCN is actually suppressed—not activated—by light.