Eingeladener Kommentar zu: „Einmal- versus wiederverwendbare Instrumente in der laparoskopischen Cholezystektomie — Kostenkalkulation und Nutzwertbestimmung”

Schlu?folgerungen Unser Motto in der Chirurgie sollte hei?en: „An erster Stelle steht die Qualit?t, erst sekund?r kommen die Kosten.“ In diesem Sinne verstehen wir auch die vorgelegte Arbeit vonKriwanek et al. (1). Durch den Gebrauch von wiederverwendbaren Instrumenten (oder Kombinationen davon) konnten die Kosten der LC um 50 bis 70% reduziert werden. Die Qualit?t für den Chirurgen litt jedoch unter dem reinen Gebrauch von wiederverwendbaren Instrumenten. Deshalb erachten es die Autoren für sinnvoll, eine Kombination zwischen Wegwerfinstrumenten und wiederverwendbaren Instrumenten anzuwenden. Damit entsteht unter leichter Erh?hung der Kosten keine Qualit?tseinbu?e und demzufolge ein maximaler Nutzen für die Patienten (nicht jedoch für die Spital?konomen). Jede Kosten-Nutzen-Analyse unterliegt jedoch einem stetigen Flu? und ver?ndert sich demzufolge auch mit der Einführung neuer Produkte und Technologien von Seite der Industrie. Interessant für die gesamte Laparoskopie wird es jedoch dann, wenn solche Kosten-Nutzen-Analysen auf andere Gebiete wie z. B. die Therapie der Leistenhernie oder der Gallengangssteine übertragen werden. Diese Ergebnisse werden die weitere Zukunft der laparoskopischen Chirurgie wesentlich beeinflussen. Deshalb gilt es für uns Chirurgen, eine Sensibilit?t für ?konomische Aspekte zu entwickeln und Kosten-Nutzen-Analysen für das eigene Spital (wie hier gezeigt) zu erarbeiten.     

Comparison of indium-111 octreotide and thallium-201 scintigraphy in patients mammographically suspected of having breast cancer: Preliminary results

Indium-111 octreotide and thallium-201 scintigraphic studies were compared in 21 patients (16 with palpable and five with non-palpable lesions) suspected of having breast malignancies on the basis of mammography. Early (15 min) and late (3 h)²⁰¹Tl (111 MBq) and 4-h and 24-h¹¹¹In-octreotide (111–148 MBq) static planar anterior images (matrix 256×256) were obtained on separate days. Images were evaluated both visually and quantitatively. Biopsy was performed following the imaging studies. Histopathology revealed 17 breast carcinomas (15 cases of invasive ductal carcinoma, one mucinous adenocarcinoma and one intraductal carcinoma) and four benign breast lesions (two fibroadenomas, one abscess and one case of fat necrosis). The means histopathologcial tumour size (mean largest diameter) was 3.38±1.9 cm.¹¹¹In-octreotide detected 16 of the 17 breast cancers (94%) while²⁰¹Tl detected 13 of them (76%). Both¹¹¹In-octreotide and²⁰¹Tl missed one nonpalpable carcinoma showing only an isolated cluster of microcalcifications on mammography. The smallest tumour size detected by both agents 1.5×1.5 cm. Of the four benign lesions, only the breast abscess revealed both²⁰¹Tl and¹¹¹In-octreotide uptake.¹¹¹In-octreotide scan also showed tracer uptake in five of the six patients with histologically proven axillary metastases, while four of these six patients showed²⁰¹Tl uptake. The tumour/background (T/B) ratios of late¹¹¹In-octreotide and²⁰¹Tl images were 1.71±0.38 and 1.46±0.30 respectively (P=0.039). In this preliminary study,¹¹¹In-octreotide yielded more favourable results than²⁰¹Tl in the detection of breast carcinomas. However, the diagnostic efficacy of¹¹¹In-octreotide imaging needs to be investigated in larger patient series.     

Improved long-term bone-implant integration Experiments in transgenic mice overexpressing bovine growth hormone

Several recent studies have investigated the effects of growth hormone (GH) on the healing of fractures and bone ingrowth, but with conflicting results. The negative results may be due to antibody formation against injected GH or because some experimental models are able to prove only positive GH effects. In this study, we wanted to investigate the effect of GH on implant integration in bone. To avoid potential formation of antibodies against injected GH, we used a model with transgenic mice overexpressing bovine GH (bGH).

Titanium implants were inserted in the forehead of the mice. 4 months after insertion, the implants were cut out en bloc with the surrounding bone. The calcified specimens were cut and ground to a thickness of approximately 10m. Histomorphometry demonstrated significantly more direct bone-to-metal contact in the transgenic mice than in the nontransgenic littermates. Our findings indicate that systemic administration of GH in humans may improve implant integration in bone.     

A new monoclonal antibody against the GABA-protein conjugate shows immunoreactivity in sensory neurons of the rat.

A monoclonal antibody, 115AD5, was raised against GABA coupled to bovine serum albumin. The monoclonal antibody 115AD5 also reacted with other GABA-protein conjugates. The specificity of the monoclonal antibody was corroborated by enzyme-linked immunoassay, dot-immunobinding experiments and immunostaining of rat cerebellum sections. The monoclonal antibody 115AD5 could successfully be applied on Vibratome and cryostat sections using either indirect immunofluorescence or peroxidase techniques. In rat cerebellar cortex the monoclonal antibody 115AD5 gave an intense immunoreaction in stellate cells, in Golgi neurons, and in basket cells and their processes around Purkinje cell bodies. Purkinje cell dendrites showed GABA immunoreactivity while the cell bodies were non-reactive or only weakly reactive. There was labelling in some nuclei of Purkinje cells. GABA immunoreactivity was also found in dot-like structures in the granular layer. A large population of sensory neurons in rat thoracic and lumbar spinal dorsal root ganglia presented an intense immunoreactivity for the monoclonal antibody 115AD5. Nerve bundles immunoreactive for GABA were also seen in these ganglia. In the trigeminal ganglion, a major population of sensory neurons and some of their processes presented immunoreactivity for GABA. In the sensory nodose ganglion of the vagus nerve, many neuronal cell bodies and some fibres were immunoreactive for GABA. Ligation of the vagus nerve caudal to the ganglion resulted in an increased GABA immunoreactivity in neuronal somata of the ganglion, as well as in nerve fibres on the ganglionic side of the ligature. The present results suggest that in the rat, a population of sensory neurons in thoracic and lumbar spinal dorsal root ganglia, as well as in the trigeminal and nodose ganglia contain GABA. The presence of GABA immunoreactivity in these neurons raises the possibility of a neurotransmitter or modulator role.     

Activity of natural killer cells and granulocytes in peripheral blood and separated cells]

The natural killing of K 562 cells by whole blood from normal subjects was comparable with that shown by separated mononuclear cells. In order to establish the conditions for a reliable natural killer assay by using very small numbers of effector cells in whole blood, the isotope uptake of target cells was increased by a modified labelling method, which permitted the use of fewer target cells in the assay. The natural cytotoxicity of whole blood was augmented by interferon to the same extent as observed with separated mononuclear cells. The chemiluminescence of granulocytes in whole blood comparable with that of separated granulocytes. Taken together, these methods are considerably less tedious than the conventional methods, technique is also economical, and the results may reflect in vivo cytolytic processes much better.     

Retinal specificity in eye fragments: investigations on the retinotectal projections of different quarter-eyes in Xenopus laevis

According to Sperry's chemoaffinity hypothesis, the projection of a small eye fragment with a reduced amount of optic fibres should be restricted to that position in the optic tectum corresponding to its own specificity. However, previous investigations on different types of quarter-eyes in Xenopus laevis have revealed that their retinal projection was always restricted to the rostral part of the tectum, no matter what the origin of the remaining retinal quadrant. To get an indication of the state of specificity in such eye fragments, we investigated by electrophysiological and histological methods several features of the retinal projections of temporoventral (TV), naso-ventral (NV) and ventral (V) quarter-eyes which referred to their positional identity. Irrespective of their different origins, the projections were always located in the rostral part of the tectum, the size of the innervated tectal area depending for all fragment types on the size of the quarter-eyes, i.e. number of optic fibres. However, quantitative analyses revealed that with increasing eye size the various fragments expand their projections preferentially into those tectal areas that match their original specificity: TV projection is more concentrated in the rostral tectum, NV eyes expand their projections mainly to the caudal tectum, and V eyes enlarge their projections equally into the medial and caudal tectum. In addition, fibre-tracing experiments with cobaltic lysine showed that, according to the different origins of the quarter-eyes, retinal fibres follow the appropriate branch of the optic tract selectively: fibres of NV and V eyes pass mainly through the medial tract, and most fibres of TV eyes innervate the rostral tectum directly from a central position between the two side branches. All these findings suggest that the different types of quarter-eyes retain their original positional identity. Thus, their rostrally located retinotectal projections are not in register with their retinal specificity. We conclude that in X. laevis local positional markers in the tectum, if present at all, do not influence the development of the retinotectal projection. Instead we suggest a concept of self-sorting of the optic fibres, which can account for the partial innervation of the rostral tectum in different types of quarter-eyes.     

International round robin tests on the measurement of carbon in diesel exhaust particulates

Object: Diesel soot has been recognized as probably carcinogenic to humans. Elemental carbon (also called black carbon) in soot is considered at the moment as the most significant surrogate to be measured for assessing the exposure to this pollutant. Its analysis is done by combustion in an oven and determination of the CO₂ formed, after elimination of the organic fraction of the soot by heating and/or by solvent extraction. The analysis allows determination of both fractions of the soot: “elemental carbon” (EC) and organic carbon␣(OC). The sum of EC and OC is called TC (total carbon). Method: An informal European coordination group organized two round robin tests on filter samples collected from diluted diesel emissions. The first round (RRT1) was performed on 13 different samples analyzed by ten laboratories. The range of loading was 2.5 to 150 μg/cm² of EC. No evaluation of the precision within laboratories could be made since each laboratory gave only one result per sample. Therefore a second round (RRT2) was organized with two samples and a blank filter sent in several portions to 11 laboratories. It should be stressed that each laboratory used its own method and that no standardization was planned at this stage. Results: Results of RRT1 showed that the coefficient of variation between laboratories decreased with higher loading and was around 10% to 15% for EC above about 20 μg/cm². Dispersion of the results varied and it appeared that the way OC is removed from the soot is probably the most important factor of influence. The correlation between the laboratories was good as a whole but some systematic differences could be detected. Besides the different techniques to remove the organic carbon, the pretreatment of the filter by HCl (either as a vapor or as a solution) to remove the inorganic carbonates (potential interference sources), is probably also a significant factor of influence in the dispersion of the results between laboratories. It is not yet clear from these results whether the “environmental” laboratories give different results from the “occupational” laboratories, but it is clear that their objectives differ since for the “environmentalists”, EC is not a specific marker of diesel immissions, in contrast to the “occupationalists”. Conclusion: It can be concluded that, although significant differences exist between laboratories they can be attributed mainly to the narrow distribution of the results within a single laboratory, and that the overall agreement of the results for EC and TC is fairly good. These results obtained with pure diesel engine emissions, should be complemented by field samples, but they have already achieved relevant findings in the performance of the procedures used to assess exposure to diesel soot. Received: 30 December 1996 / Accepted: 21 February 1997