Adult learning,objectivity and other self-evident untruths

Editorial Introduction

Adult Learning, Objectivity and other Self-Evident Untruths     

Does sympathetic nerve discharge affect the firing of myelinated cutaneous afferents in humans?

In clinical practise, the notion that some complex regional pain syndromes (CRPS) are associated with sympathetic facilitation of nociceptive transmission is widespread. However, physiological increases in cutaneous sympathetic nerve activity have not been found to influence the firing properties of cutaneous polymodal nociceptive (high-threshold mechano-heat sensitive) fibers in human subjects. Whether the same applies to low-threshold cutaneous mechanoreceptors is not known. Such an effect could be relevant for sympathetic facilitation of nociception, given that tactile afferents are implicated in the allodynia associated with CRPS. This issue was addressed by recording the responses of single cutaneous mechanoreceptors in the glabrous skin of the finger pads to constant mechanical stimuli, at rest and during physiological increases in cutaneous sympathetic activity produced by arousal stimuli. Unitary recordings were made from 17 rapidly adapting (15 FAI and 2 FAII) and 20 slowly adapting (9 SAI and 11 SAII) afferents located in the finger pads via tungsten microelectrodes inserted percutaneously into the median nerve at the wrist in nine subjects. A servomotor applied 1 s constant-displacement ramp-and-hold indentations to the receptor-bearing digit every 3 s. Displacement and compression force were recorded. Blood flow in the finger pad and sweating in the palm were measured contralaterally. Increases in cutaneous sympathetic outflow caused only modest changes in the spontaneous and compression-evoked firing of tactile afferents. These changes were usually (for 26/37 afferents) related to the associated decreases in skin blood flow. The latency from the start of the ramp stimulus to the onset of firing was inversely correlated to flow (i.e. unit response was delayed during vasoconstriction) for 11/31 units (7/15 FAI, 1/2 FAII, 2/9 SAI, 1/5 SAII), whereas no units showed a positive correlation. Compression-evoked firing rates were positively correlated to flow (i.e. vasoconstriction reduced firing rates) for 14/31 units (2/15 FAI, 1/2 FAII, 7/9 SAI, 4/5 SAII), whereas no units showed a negative correlation. 10/11 SAII afferents exhibited spontaneous background firing, which increased for 4 and decreased for 4 in response to arousal stimuli, presumably reflecting their sensitivity to changes in skin stretch associated with sympathetically mediated reductions in blood volume in the finger pad. Two afferents showed no change, but nor was there significant vasoconstriction in these recordings. Thus, arousal stimuli reduced rather than augmented tactile afferent firing. The close relation to blood flow for all types of afferents, and the different responses among SAII afferents, suggest that sympathetically mediated changes in afferent firing properties are indirect, i.e. secondary to changes in the mechanoreceptors' tissue environment rather than to a direct sympathetic effect on the endings.     

Emergency medicine and environmental activism

Clearfell, burn and sow silviculture is promoted as being the most scientific method of harvesting wet sclerophyll forests in Tasmania. However, it fails to take into account wider social and global environmental issues such as climate change and the carbon cycle. This paper describes an emergency physician's role in the continuing debate surrounding the management of Tasmania's old-growth forests. Like evidence-based medicine, the use of science in this context has its limitations, and such comparisons are discussed.     

Low molecular weight heparin (tinzaparin) therapy for moderate risk thromboprophylaxis during pregnancy. A pharmacokinetic study

Low molecular weight heparin (LMWH) is used increasingly for prophylaxis and treatment of venous thromboembolism during pregnancy. However, the prophylactic dose for patients at moderate risk varies between centers, and the recommended LMWH dose for the non pregnant patient is frequently used in pregnant women. The aim of this study was to investigate the effects of pregnancy on the pharmacokinetics of anti-Xa levels during moderate risk thromboprophylaxis with the LMWH, tinzaparin. In 24 pregnant women, one of three doses of tinzaparin (50, 75 or 100 IU/kg) were given according to the treating physician's assessment of their risk profile. Four-hour peak anti-Xa levels were measured throughout pregnancy and 24-hour profiles were measured at 28 and 36 weeks gestation. Doses were adjusted when peak anti-Xa levels fell below 0.1 IU/ml and, in some cases, when levels at 10 and 18 hours post injection were undetectable (<0.05 IU/ml). Our results showed that women receiving tinzaparin (50 IU/kg) frequently had peak (4 hour) anti-Xa levels below 0.1IU/ml and that 46% of these patients required dose adjustment. Similarly anti-Xa levels were also found to be low over the 24-hour period. A starting dose of 75 IU/kg, once daily, gave greater anti-Xa cover over the 24-hour period and may avoid the need for dose adjustment. The results suggest that the pharmacokinetics of tinzaparin are affected by pregnancy. Larger studies are required to determine whether an increased tinzaparin dose (75 IU/kg) would be more effective in the prevention of thrombosis during pregnancy than 50 IU/kg.