Hip surgery and its evidence base: progress over a decade?

Background

The burden of traumatic and elective hip surgery is set to grow. With an increasing number of techniques and implants against the background of an aging population, the emphasis on evidence-based treatment has never been greater. The purpose of this study was to assess changes in the levels of evidence in the hip literature over a decade.

Materials and methods

Articles pertaining to hip surgery from the years 2000 and 2010 in Hip International, Journal of Arthroplasty, Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery and The Bone and Joint Journal were analysed. Articles were ranked by a five-point level of evidence scale and by type of study, according to guidelines from the Centre for Evidence-based Medicine.

Results

531 articles were analysed from 48 countries. The kappa value for the inter-observer reliability showed excellent agreement between the reviewers for study type (κ = 0.956, P < 0.01) and for levels of evidence (κ = 0.772, P < 0.01). Between 2000 and 2010, the overall percentage of high-level evidence (levels I and II) studies more than doubled (12 to 31 %, P < 0.001). The most frequent study type was therapeutic; the USA and UK were the largest producers of published work in these journals, with contributions from other countries increasing markedly over the decade.

Conclusions

There has been a significant increase in high levels of evidence in hip surgery over a decade (P < 0.001). We recommend that all orthopaedic journals consider implementing compulsory declaration by authors of the level of evidence to help enhance quality of evidence.

Level of evidence

Level 2: economic and decision analysis.

     

Nonlinear Protein Binding: Not What You Think

Nonlinear protein binding is traditionally thought of as an increasing fraction unbound with increasing total drug concentration. In the past several years, research into the protein binding of several tetracyclines has shown that an unexpected and counterintuitive phenomenon has been observed, specifically that of decreasing unbound drug fraction with increasing total concentrations of drug over certain concentration ranges. Although several studies of tigecycline have shown the importance calcium and its chelation may play in the protein-drug interaction, the potential clinical implications and relevance have not been explored. Here, we define typical and atypical nonlinear protein binding, overview protein binding theory, and discuss theoretical implications on pharmacokinetics. Using tigecycline as an example, in silico simulations and calculations show how when atypical nonlinear protein binding is not accounted for free drug exposure, and drug tissue penetration may be overestimated. It is important to revisit the impacts of nonlinearity in protein binding on clinical pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics, and ultimately, clinical efficacy. Although this phenomenon could potentially warrant clinical dose adjustment for certain compounds, it also presents a potential opportunity to exploit underlying mechanisms to develop new therapies and better understand molecular interactions of xenobiotics within the physiological system.     

Water Activity and Its Significance in Topical Dosage Forms

Unique properties of thermodynamic activity of solvents in topical semisolids and its effects on in vitro product performance have not been fully understood. Mechanistic investigation was undertaken to demonstrate the significance of thermodynamic potential of solvents [water activity (a_w) or solvent activity (a_s)] on in vitro performance of model topical formulations. Drug transport across synthetic membranes was found to decrease with decreasing water activity of formulations. Similarly, in vitro permeation of model permeant (caffeine) across porcine epidermis was found to decrease with decreasing water activity of formulations. Notably, relatively low water activity formulations (a_w, 0.78) induced dehydration in porcine skin associated with significant structural changes like detachment of individual stratum corneum layers. Inclusion of hydrating agents (propylene glycol) in low water activity (a_w, 0.78) formulations restored hydration levels and structural integrity of porcine skin. Most importantly, incremental inclusion of propylene glycol in low water activity formulations (a_w, 0.78) enhanced in vitro permeation of model permeant (fluorescein sodium). Further investigation revealed that variability in processing conditions (high shear mixing during emulsification step) could modulate water activity in semisolid formulations despite their compositional sameness. In retrospect, water activity was found to be a critical quality attribute of topical semisolid products which impacts overall product performance and drug delivery.     

Enhanced in vitro activity of tigecycline in the presence of chelating agents

The lack of availability of novel antibiotic agents and the rise of resistance to existing therapies has led clinicians to utilise combination therapy to adequately treat bacterial infections. Here we examined how chelators may impact the in vitro activity of tigecycline (TIG) against Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Escherichia coli and Klebsiella pneumoniae. Minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs) were determined by broth dilution with and without various combinations of chelators (EDTA and other tetracyclines) and metal ions (i.e. calcium, magnesium). Trimethoprim (TMP) was used as a non-chelating control. Addition of metal ions led to increases in MICs, whilst addition of EDTA led to decreases in MICs. The chelating effects of EDTA were reversed by addition of magnesium and most profoundly calcium. Similar effects of EDTA and calcium were observed for tetracycline (TET) and TMP. When other tetracyclines (TET, oxytetracycline (OXY) and chlortetracycline (CHL)) were used as chelators at concentrations below their MICs, TIG MICs decreased for P. aeruginosa but not for E. coli. Some decreases in TIG MICs were observed for K. pneumoniae when TET and CHL were added. A dose-dependent decrease in TIG MIC was observed for TET and was reversed by the addition of calcium. The presence of effects of EDTA and calcium on TMP MICs indicates that mechanisms outside of TIG chelation likely play a role in enhanced activity. Full characterisation of an unexpected interaction such as TIG–TET with different microorganisms could provide valuable insights into the underlying mechanisms and design of physiologically viable chelators as candidates for future combinations regimens.     

Finger pulp reconstruction with thenar flap: Aesthetic and functional outcome

Purpose: Fingertip injuries are common in industrial production activities as well as in domestic work. Loss of pulp hampers daily life activities. Functional and aesthetic aspects are important in fingertip reconstruction. The bone is usually exposed along with soft tissue loss. Therefore to reconstruct the pulp flap with adequate bulk is required. Methods: We reported a case series of 12 patients with the injury over the volar aspect of distal phalanx of the index or middle finger. In all cases, laterally based thenar flap was chosen. The flap donor site was closed primarily in most of cases, while 4 patients required skin graft. The flap was detached between 2-3 weeks. Functional assessment was done using static and dynamic 2-point discrimination and range of motion at each joint. The aesthetic outcome was assessed through questionnaire. The results were analyzed using the unpaired t-test (SPSS version 21). Results: Partial necrosis occurred in 2 cases while rest of flaps survived successfully. Static 2-point discrimination ranged from 6e10 mm, mean 8.6 mm; and dynamic 2-point discrimination ranged from 8-10 mm, mean 8.9 mm. The mean satisfaction score was (4.0 ± 0.55). Conclusion: Thenar flap is a good choice for reconstruction of the finger pulp as it provides the bulk with good functional and aesthetic outcome.     

Development of a Method That Eliminates False-Positive Results due to Nerve Growth Factor Interference in the Assessment of Fulranumab Immunogenicity

Fulranumab, a human IgG2 monoclonal antibody that neutralizes nerve growth factor (NGF), is currently in development for the treatment of pain. Our initial immunogenicity test method was found to be prone to NGF interference, leading to a high apparent incidence of anti-drug antibody (ADA) in phase 1 studies. The ADA immunoassay comprised a homogeneous bridging electrochemiluminescence (ECL) format with biotin and ruthenium-labeled fulranumab bound together (“bridged”) by ADA in test samples for detection. In this assay, NGF produced a false-positive signal due to its ability to bridge fulranumab molecules. Thus, we developed a specificity assay to eliminate the NGF false-positive results. We encountered the challenge of eliminating drug interference as well as drug target interference, and discovered that the acid-dissociation-based pretreatment of samples used for mitigating drug interference dramatically increased drug target interference. Several strategies were investigated to eliminate the NGF interference; yet only one strategy specifically removed NGF and produced true fulranumab-specific ADA results by using competitive inhibition with fulranumab and utilizing an alternative NGF binding antibody to eliminate NGF interference. Using this new method, we confirmed that the high apparent anti-fulranumab antibody incidence (>60%) in clinical study samples was in fact due to fulranumab-bound NGF released during the acid-dissociation step of the ADA testing method. We conclude that our revised method accurately identifies anti-fulranumab antibodies by incorporating steps to eliminate fulranumab and NGF interference. We advise that acid-dissociation pretreatment must not be universally applied to improve ADA assays without investigating its bioanalytical risks versus benefits.