Stress radiographs after ankle fracture: the effect of ankle position and deltoid ligament status on medial clear space measurements

OBJECTIVE: This study was designed to determine 1) how ankle position affects the medial clear space by using stress radiographs, 2) which medial clear space measurement, overall width or increase in width, better predicts deep deltoid ligament disruption after Weber type-B distal fibular fracture, and 3) what value of medial clear space is most predictive of deep deltoid ligament disruption after Weber type-B distal fibular fracture. DESIGN: Cadaveric fracture model. SETTING: Biomechanics laboratory. INTERVENTION: Fluoroscopic mortise views were taken of 6 fresh cadaveric ankles mounted in a fixture permitting both positioning in neutral flexion, dorsiflexion, and plantarflexion, and the application of internal and external rotational forces. After destabilizing the ankles according to the supination-external rotation mechanism of Lauge-Hansen, repeat radiographs were taken with the same combination of flexion and applied rotational stress. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Radiographic measurements of medial clear space width and changes in medial clear space were made. RESULTS: A medial clear space of > or =5 mm on radiographs taken in dorsiflexion with an external rotational stress was most predictive of deep deltoid ligament transection after distal fibular fracture. In dorsiflexion-external rotation, medial clear spaces of > or =4 mm yielded lower specificity and positive predictive value, whereas > or =6 mm yielded lower sensitivity and negative predictive value. All other stress conditions and increases in medial clear space of 2 or 3 mm were less predictive. CONCLUSIONS: Ankle stress radiographs taken in dorsiflexion-external rotation were most predictive of deep deltoid ligament disruption after distal fibular fracture. Under this stress condition, a medial clear space of > or =5 mm was the most reliable predictor of deep deltoid ligament status.     

Blisters associated with lower-extremity fracture: results of a prospective treatment protocol

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate patient outcomes after treatment of lower-extremity fractures associated with blister formation and to assess complications after soft-tissue treatment using a prospective protocol. DESIGN: Retrospective evaluation of prospectively collected data. SETTING: Level I trauma center. PATIENTS/PARTICIPANTS: Between September 1999 and September 2003, 47 patients who had sustained a closed lower-extremity fracture with early development of fracture blisters in the zone of injury were followed. Blisters were characterized as either avoidable or unavoidable with respect to surgical incisions, and characteristics such as number, size, blood filled or clear filled, and the presence of an intact roof were documented. INTERVENTION: All blisters were unroofed, and antibiotic cream (silver sulfadiazine, Silvadene, King Pharmaceuticals Inc.) was applied twice daily until the blister bed had re-epithelialized. MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS: Fracture union and the development of wound or skin complications. Patient satisfaction with the cosmetic outcome of the treatment regimen was assessed through telephone survey at 23-month minimum follow-up. RESULTS: Twenty-eight patients presented with a single blister, and 19 had multiple blisters. Blister size averaged 9.7 cm. Twenty-two patients had blood-filled blisters, 20 had clear-filled blisters, and five had a combination of the two. Fracture patterns included 17 ankle fractures (OTA 44), 13 tibial plateau fractures (OTA 41), five tibial-shaft fractures (OTA 42), eight calcaneus fractures (OTA 45), and four pilon fractures (OTA 43). Mean delay in definitive surgical care was 7.7 days (range 0 to 20 days). The average delay of surgery for ankle fractures was 6 days (range 0 to 18 days), which was significantly less than the delay for calcaneus fractures (12 days, range 4 to 19 days, P < 0.02) and tibial plateau fractures (11 days, range 0 to 20 days, P < 0.02). Thirty-seven of the 45 patients (82.3%) available for follow-up at a mean of 27 weeks (range 14 to 35) had an uncomplicated postoperative course, and fracture union was achieved in 43 of 45 cases (95.6%). The soft-tissue complication rate associated with the standardized treatment regimen was 13.3% (6/45 cases), with three cases of minor soft-tissue breakdown, one superficial infection, and two major complications directly related to the presence of fracture blisters. Both major complications involved full-thickness skin breakdown occurring directly at the base of fracture blisters in patients with diabetes. The skin breakdown required further surgery in both cases. Including the two patients who developed nonunion, the overall complication rate for the treatment cohort was 17.7% (8/45 cases). At a mean follow-up of 51.9 months (range 23 to 73), three patients in the cohort had expired. Of the 42 patients available for evaluation, 28 patients (67%) were reachable for a telephone survey to assess satisfaction with the outcome of the fracture and soft-tissue management. Patients rated their satisfaction with the cosmetic appearance of their lower extremities after the standardized treatment regimen on a scale of 1 to 10 (with 10 representing very satisfied), with a mean of 9.07 (range 5 to 10). Six patients reported scarring at the sites of previous fracture blisters, all of which occurred after blistering of the blood-filled subtype. The presence of scarring significantly decreased patient satisfaction with cosmesis and overall treatment (P < 0.0001 and P < 0.01, respectively). CONCLUSIONS: Treatment of fracture blisters with a silver sulfadiazine (Silvadene) regimen proved to be successful in minimizing soft-tissue complications by promoting re-epithelialization in all nondiabetic patients. At long-term follow-up, patients were generally satisfied with the cosmetic outcome of the treatment regimen. Postoperative scarring, which was more common with blood-filled blisters, significantly impacted patient satisfaction. We urge caution when planning to make a surgical incision around an area of both full-thickness (blood-filled) and partial-thickness (clear-filled) fracture blisters in diabetic patients because the zone of injury might extend beyond the borders of the fracture blister.     

Podium versus poster publication rates at the Orthopaedic Trauma Association

Original studies at orthopaedic meetings are presented on the podium and in poster format. Publication of those studies in peer-reviewed journals is the standard of communicating scientific data to colleagues. Investigators of previous studies have reported publication rates, but never differentiated between the modes of presentation. We evaluated the annual meeting of the Orthopaedic Trauma Association from 1994-1998 and found that studies presented on the podium were 1.3 times more likely to be published than those presented in a poster format (67% versus 52%). The mean time to publication was similar, 21.6 months for poster presentations and 24.8 months for podium presentations. Podium presentations were more likely to be published in the Journal of Orthopaedic Trauma, Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, and the Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery (American and British editions). Our findings suggest different rates and distribution of publication between podium and poster presentations at an international trauma meeting. These findings should be considered when evaluating studies of interest at the Orthopaedic Trauma Association meeting.     

Predictors of short-term functional outcome following ankle fracture surgery

BACKGROUND: Ankle fractures are among the most common injuries treated by orthopaedic surgeons. However, very few investigators have examined the functional recovery following ankle fracture surgery and, to our knowledge, none have analyzed factors that may predict functional recovery. In this study, we evaluated predictors of short-term functional outcome following surgical stabilization of ankle fractures. METHODS: Over three years, 232 patients who sustained a fracture of the ankle and were treated surgically were followed prospectively, for a minimum of one year. Trained interviewers recorded baseline characteristics, including patient demographics, medical comorbidities, and functional status according to the Short Musculoskeletal Function Assessment (SMFA). Laboratory findings, the American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) class, and operative findings were recorded from the chart during hospitalization. Follow-up information included the occurrence of complications or additional surgery, weight-bearing status, functional status according to the SMFA, and the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) ankle-hindfoot score. The data were analyzed to determine predictors of functional recovery at three months, six months, and one year postoperatively. RESULTS: Complete follow-up data were available for 198 patients (85%). At one year, 174 (88%) of the patients had either no or mild ankle pain and 178 (90%) had either no limitations or limitations only in recreational activities. According to the AOFAS ankle-hindfoot score, 178 (90%) of the patients had > or = 90% functional recovery. A patient age of less than forty years was a predictor of recovery, as measured with the SMFA subscores, at six months after the ankle fracture. At one year, however, age was no longer a predictor of recovery. Patients who were younger than forty were more likely to recover > or = 90% of function (p = 0.004), and men were more likely than women to recover function (p = 0.02). ASA Class 1 or 2 (p = 0.03) and an absence of diabetes (p = 0.02) were also predictors of better functional recovery at one year. SMFA subscores were below average at baseline, indicating a healthy population. At three and six months postoperatively, all SMFA subscores were significantly higher than the baseline subscores (p < 0.001); however, at one year, the SMFA subscores were almost back to the baseline, normal level. CONCLUSIONS: One year after ankle fracture surgery, patients are generally doing well, with most experiencing little or mild pain and few restrictions in functional activities. They have a significant improvement in function compared with six months after the surgery. Younger age, male sex, absence of diabetes, and a lower ASA class are predictive of functional recovery at one year following ankle fracture surgery. It is important to counsel patients and their families regarding the expected functional recovery after an ankle injury.     

Tourniquet cuff pressure: The gulf between science and practice

Tourniquet use is effective in producing a bloodless field. It is recommended that the least effective pressures be used to minimize tissue microstructure and biochemical damage from tourniquet application. When applied at the thigh, the minimum effective tourniquet pressure is 90 to 100 mm Hg above systolic BP, and in a normotensive, nonobese patient, pressure of 250 mm Hg is sufficient. Similarly, an arm tourniquet pressure of 200 mm Hg is recommended.The purpose of this survey was to assess the tourniquet pressures used by orthopaedic surgeons, both academic and community based, and their familiarity with associated literature. MATERIALS: A Website-based survey was distributed to a random sample of academic and community-based surgeons. Respondents were asked the upper and lower-extremity tourniquet pressures they routinely use. They were asked if they were able to cite or were aware of literature to support their answer. They were also asked to specify their practice setting and years in practice.Results were statistically analyzed utilizing Fisher's exact test and Mann-Whitney test. RESULTS: A total of 199 survey responses were collected. Out of these, 151 (76%) were complete for the lower extremity, and 141 (71%) were complete for upper extremity. The average years in practice were 12.6 years (range, 1-30).The median LE pressure was 300 mm (range, 150-400), and the median UE pressure was 250 mm (range, 150-300). Less than 20% of respondents routinely used pressures of 250 mm or less for the lower extremity. For upper extremity, only 11.3% used pressures at or below 200 mm.Surgeons in academic practice were more likely to use lower tourniquet pressures, and less likely to choose "don't know" as the option for literature support, but the difference was not statistically significant.Although 60% of respondents thought that they were aware of literature supporting their answers, only 25% of these for the lower extremity and 11% for the upper used the correct pressures. CONCLUSION: This survey demonstrates the existing gulf between tourniquet use and supporting literature.Tourniquet use is not benign and the correct pressure usage allows the least morbidity. We hope this survey will raise awareness of the correct tourniquet pressures and change practice patterns based on "that's how we have always done it".     

Sliding of two lag screw designs in a highly comminuted fracture model

A fracture construct, representing a worst-case model of a comminuted intertrochanteric fracture, was created in order to compare the fixation stability of two different cephalomedullary nails: one where the lag screw can telescope within itself to achieve displacement of the head-neck fragment, and the other where the solid lag screw slides only. After nail fixation, the models were loaded and then cycled, and positions of the head-neck fragment and lag screw were determined. Both nails similarly acted to limit motion of the head-neck fragment by the sliding of their lag screws, causing impingement of the fragment against the nail. Fragment movement was achieved with significantly less force with the telescoping lag screws, which also showed no final lateral projection from the nail. This was in contrast to the solid lag screws that demonstrated lateral projection in all cases.     

Does a positive ankle stress test indicate the need for operative treatment after lateral malleolus fracture? A preliminary report

OBJECTIVES: At our institution, a standardized protocol using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to evaluate ankle stability and need for surgery following a positive manual stress test for isolated lateral malleolus fractures has been used. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the results using this standardized protocol. DESIGN: Retrospective review. SETTING: University teaching hospital. PATIENTS:: Twenty-one patients who had a positive ankle stress test (>or=5 mm clear space widening) after isolated Weber B lateral malleolus fracture were further evaluated by MRI to determine the status of the deep deltoid ligament. INTERVENTION: If the MRI showed the deltoid ligament was completely disrupted, the patient was advised to have operative ankle repair. However, if the MRI demonstrated that the deep deltoid was intact or only partially disrupted, the patient was treated nonoperatively in a walking boot with weightbearing as tolerated ambulation. MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENT: Patients were followed until fracture union and contacted at 12-month minimum follow-up to determine outcomes by radiographic evaluation, health related quality of life (HRQOL) based on Short Form (SF)-36 results and functional outcomes based on the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle (AOFAS) and patient report of treatment satisfaction. RESULTS: Twenty-one patients had an MRI after a positive ankle stress test and comprised the study group. There were 12 men and 9 women with an average age of 27 years (range, 16-62 years). Absolute medial clear space measurement on stress testing ranged from 5 to 8 mm. In all, 19 of 21 patients (90%) had evidence of partially torn deep deltoid ligament on MRI and were treated nonoperatively, whereas two patients had MRI findings of a complete deep deltoid injury and underwent surgical treatment. There were no statistically significant correlations between the medial clear space measurements and MRI documentation of complete deltoid ligament rupture. All fractures united without evidence of residual medial clear space widening or posttraumatic joint space narrowing. Of the 15 patients who were available for 1 year minimum follow-up and agreed to come back for clinical and radiographic evaluation, 14 had an AOFAS score of 100, with the remaining patient having a score of 85. HRQOL based on SF-36 results indicated all patients were above or at normal levels, and all patients reported that they were satisfied with their treatment; 93% (14/15) indicated that they would make the same treatment decision again. CONCLUSIONS: Using our protocol, we were able to identify and provide effective nonoperative care to 19 patients who otherwise might have underwent operative treatment after an isolated lateral malleolus fracture. Further work is needed to identify the subset of patients who could be treated nonoperatively without a need for MRI scanning.