Quality assurance, efficiency indicators and cost-utility of the evaluation workup for liver transplantation.

We report the results of a retrospective review of the outpatient pretransplantation workup for United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS) 3 patients adopted at a liver transplantation (LT) center and illustrate the efficiency indicators used for quality evaluation and cost-analysis. A single-center, pre-LT evaluation workup was performed on an outpatient basis at a cost per patient evaluation of 2,770 Euros (). Objective measures were: the number of patients admitted to and excluded from each phase of the algorithm; the rate of patients admitted to pre-LT evaluation out of the total of referred patients (the referral efficiency rate); the rate of waitlisted patients out of those admitted to pre-LT evaluation (the evaluation efficiency rate); the rate of waitlisted patients out of those referred for LT (the process efficiency rate); and the cost per waitlisted patient, as the ratio of the cost per patient evaluation to the evaluation efficiency rate. From January 1, 1996, to October 1, 2004, 1,837 patients were referred for LT on an outpatient basis. Based on preemptive evaluation of the available clinical data, 412 patients (22.4%) were excluded from pre-LT evaluation and 1,425 (77.6%) were admitted to preliminary consultation. Among these, 603 (42.3%) were excluded from and 822 (57.7%) were admitted to pre-LT evaluation with a referral efficiency rate of 44.7% (822 of 1,837). Out of the patients evaluated for LT, 484 were waitlisted with a cost-utility and evaluation efficiency rate of 58.8% each (484 of 822). Of the 1,837 patients originally addressed for LT 484 were waitlisted, yielding a process efficiency rate of 26.3% (484 of 1,837) and a cost per waitlisted patient of 4,710.8. In conclusion, the 3 indicators allowed monitoring of the efficiency of the pre-LT evaluation algorithm. The current process efficiency rate at our center is low (26.3%), but avoiding early referrals we might increase it to 31.6%, with a 12% net saving on costs per waitlisted patient (from 4,710.8 to 4,165.4).     

Preoperative pulmonary rehabilitation in patients undergoing lung resection for non-small cell lung cancer.

BACKGROUND: The impact of short-term preoperative pulmonary rehabilitation on exercise capacity of patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease undergoing lobectomy for non-small cell lung cancer is evaluated. METHODS: A prospective observational study was designed. Inclusion criteria consisted of an indication to lung resection because of a clinical stage I or II non-small cell lung cancer and a chronic obstructive disease on preoperative pulmonary function test. In such conditions, maximal oxygen consumption by a cardio-pulmonary exercise test was evaluated; when this resulted as being < or =15 ml/kg/min a pulmonary rehabilitation programme lasting 4 weeks was considered. Twelve patients fulfilled inclusion criteria, completed the preoperative rehabilitation programme and underwent a new functional evaluation prior to surgery. The postoperative record of these patients was collected. RESULTS: On completion of pulmonary rehabilitation, the resting pulmonary function test and diffuse lung capacity of patients was unchanged, whereas the exercise performance was found to have significantly improved; the mean increase in maximal oxygen consumption proved to be at 2.8 ml/kg/min (p<0.01). Eleven patients underwent lobectomy; no postoperative mortality was noted and mean hospital stay was 17 days. Postoperative pulmonary complication was recorded in 8 patients. CONCLUSIONS: Short-term preoperative pulmonary rehabilitation could improve the exercise capacity of patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease who are candidates for lung resection for non-small cell lung cancer.     

术中射频消融后病灶刮除治疗脊柱转移瘤

目的:探讨术中射频消融(RFA)后再行病灶刮除术治疗脊柱转移瘤的可行性及疗效.方法:2004年～2006年,对11例脊柱转移瘤患者术中实施RFA后再行病灶刮除术,将FRA前后病灶标本进行光镜和电镜病理检查,随访患者疼痛缓解情况及肿瘤复发情况.结果:术中未出现脊髓和神经根损伤,RFA后瘤组织固缩,刮除顺利,出血量350～3800ml,平均1024.5ml.全部病例得到6个月以上随访,平均9.8个月,全部患者生存期超过6个月,VAS评分术前平均5.8分,术后6个月时平均1.9分.1例出现局部肿瘤复发.RFA前的标本光、电镜检查均未见肿瘤组织坏死.RFA后光镜检查3例无明显坏死,9例肿瘤细胞完全坏死:电镜检查10例肿瘤细胞完全坏死,1例肿瘤细胞部分坏死,1例无明显坏死.结论:术中RFA后再行病灶刮除治疗脊柱转移瘤安全可行,有利于肿瘤的刮除,减少局部复发的风险.     

A new priority policy for patients with hepatocellular carcinoma awaiting liver transplantation within the model for end-stage liver disease system.

The best prioritization of patients with hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) waiting for liver transplantation under the model for end-stage liver disease (MELD) allocation system is still being debated. We analyzed the impact of a MELD adjustment for HCC, which consisted of the addition of an extra score (based on the HCC stage and waiting time) to the native MELD score. The outcome was analyzed for 301 patients with chronic liver disease listed for liver transplantation between March 1, 2001 and February 28, 2003 [United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS)-Child-Turcotte-Pugh (CTP) era, 163 patients, 28.8% with HCC] and between March 1, 2003 and February 28, 2004 (HCC-MELD era, 138 patients, 29.7% with HCC). In the HCC-MELD era, the cumulative dropout risk at 6 months was 17.6% for patients with HCC versus 22.3% for those patients without HCC (P = NS), similar to that in the UNOS-CTP era. The cumulative probability of transplantation at 6 months was 70.3% versus 39.0% (P = 0.005), being higher than that in the UNOS-CTP era for patients with HCC (P = 0.02). At the end of the HCC-MELD era, 12 patients with HCC (29.3%) versus 57 without HCC (58.8%) were still on the list (P = 0.001). Both native and adjusted MELD scores were higher (P < 0.05) and progressed more in patients with HCC who dropped out than in those who underwent transplantation or remained on the list (the initial-final native MELD scores were 17.3-23.1, 15.5-15.6, and 12.8-14.1, respectively). The patients without HCC remaining on the list showed stable MELD scores (initial-final: 15.1-15.4). In conclusion, the present data support the strategy of including the native MELD scores in the allocation system for HCC. This model allows the timely transplantation of patients with HCC without severely affecting the outcome of patients without HCC.     

Assessing postoperative discomfort after third molar surgery: a prospective study.

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to identify the risk factors for severe discomfort after mandibular third molar surgery and to assess the validity of the Postoperative Symptom Severity (PoSSe) scale. PATIENTS AND METHODS: In a 2-year prospective study, a total of 255 unilateral impacted mandibular third molar teeth were surgically removed under local anesthesia by 3 surgeons. Standardized surgical and analgesic protocols were followed. At the review appointment, 1 week after surgery, all patients returned a completed follow-up questionnaire (PoSSe scale) and were evaluated clinically for postoperative pain (number of painkillers taken) and trismus (differences in mouth opening). Sixteen predictive variables were evaluated using stepwise logistic regression analysis to identify the risk factors associated with severe discomfort. RESULTS: Severe postoperative discomfort was predicted by these independent variables: gender, tobacco use, ramus relationship/space available, and antibiotic prophylaxis. Oral contraceptive use and operation time were not identified as risk factors. The patients' perceptions of the severity of symptoms (PoSSe scale score) was strongly correlated with clinical assessment of trismus (r = 0.54) and pain (r = 0.42). CONCLUSION: The PoSSe scale resulted in a valid and responsive measure of the severity of symptoms after surgical extraction of lower third molars and reflected the clinical severity of the postoperative discomfort. From a patient's perspective, operative factors had little bearing on the quality of life after removal of mandibular third molars.     

One-shot percutaneous ethanol injection of liver tumors under general anesthesia: Preliminary data on efficacy and complications

Purpose: To verify the efficacy of ultrasound (US)-guided injection of large amounts of ethanol into large or multiple liver lesions, in a single session under general anesthesia (one-shot PEI) for percutaneous ablation of hepatic tumors. Methods: Twenty-nine patients (27 with 51 hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) nodules on cirrhosis, diameter range 1.0<+>–<+>9.0 cm; two patients with a single metastasis from the gastroenteric tract, 5.0 and 9.0 cm, respectively, in diameter) were treated with one-shot PEI. Results: The total volume of alcohol delivered per patient ranged from 16 to 210 ml. Mean ethanol volume in all patients was 49 ml. Dynamic computed tomography (CT) examination showed complete necrosis in 41 of 50 lesions. Two patients died of hypovolemic shock due to massive upper gastrointestinal bleeding, 3 and 7 days, respectively, after the interventional procedure. All the remaining patients are alive (follow-up 5<+>–<+>14 months) except one who died of liver failure 5 months after. New HCC nodules occurred in six patients within 6 months and one intralesional relapse was recorded. Conclusion: In this preliminary experience, one-shot PEI is as effective in inducing liver tumor necrosis as traditional PEI; its advantages are shorter treatment time and the capability of treating larger and multiple liver lesions.     

A comparision of brain biopsy and CSF-PCR in the diagnosis of CNS lesions in AIDS patients

Twenty patients with AIDS who had intracranial lesions underwent both brain biopsy and cerebro-spinal fluid (CSF) examination to compare histological diagnosis with the polymerase chain reaction (CSF-PCR) for the identification of infectious agents. CSF-PCR was performed for herpes simplex virus, varicella zoster virus, cytomegalovirus (CMV), JC virus (JCV), Epstein-Barr virus (EBV), Toxoplasma gondii and Mycobacterium tuberculosis. A definitive diagnosis was obtained by brain biopsy in 14 patients (2 with astrocytoma, 12 with brain infection). CSF-PCR was positive for EBV DNA in 3 of 3 cases of primary cerebral lymphoma, positive for JCV DNA in 6 of 7 biopsy-proven (and one autopsy-proven) cases of progressive multifocal leukoencephalopathy (PML). CSF-PCR was positive for CMV DNA in one biopsy-proven and one autopsy-proven case of CMV encephalitis (the former also had PML) and positive for M. tuberculosis DNA in one case of tuberculous encephalitis. None of the five toxoplasmic encephalitis cases (one definite, four presumptive) were T. gondii DNA positive. There was close correlation between histology and CSF-PCR for CMV encephalitis, PML and PCL. Antitoxoplasma therapy affected the sensitivity of both histological and CSF-PCR methods. Received: 8 November 1995 Received in revised form: 9 July 1996 Accepted: 19 July 1996     

The role of hyperthermic perfusion as a first step in the treatment of soft tissue sarcoma of the extremities

Eighty-six patients with locally advanced, high-grade soft tissue sarcomas of the extremities were studied prospectively in order to determine the efficacy of hyperthermic perfusion (HP) or hyperthermic antiblastic perfusion (HAP) as the first step of a combined multimodality therapy. The immediate response was evaluated in terms of tumor regression, and results confirmed the in vivo sensitivity of human sarcomas to the selective antineoplastic action of heat alone or combined with drugs (melphalan, actinomycin D, and cis-platinum). HAP has been shown to be simpler and safer than HP, and it is now currently routinely employed. As far as the long-term cure is concerned, all the patients have been evaluated for functional results, locoregional control, and survival, according to the different treatment schedules. The first clinical trials employed HP or HAP followed by delayed surgery alone. In 11 of 17 evaluable patients treated with HP, and in 17 of 29 treated with HAP, conservative surgery could be performed. A high incidence of locoregional relapse (24%) occurred, with low overall survival rates: 50.1% and 31.7% at 5 and 10 years after HP plus surgery, and 47.9% after HAP plus surgery at both 5 and 10 years. The protocol was, therefore, modified to include continuous intraarterial infusion of Adriamycin® (ADR) (17 patients) or radiotherapy (9 patients) before surgery. The results obtained thus far may be summarized as follows: (a) conservative surgery with functional limb-salvage was possible in all patients; (b) the percentage of locoregional failure decreased to approximately 12% after HAP + ADR infusion + excision, the 5- and 10-year overall survival rates both being 77.6 %, and the 5- and 10-year disease-free rates both being 57.8%; (c) no local recurrences occurred in the group treated with HAP + radiotherapy + excision with a 5-year overall survival rate of 71.5% and a 5-year disease-free rate of 50.4%. In conclusion, the combined multimodality approaches employed appear to have improved both functional results and long-term cure, even though these must be further confirmed on a larger series of patients.

---

Resumen Ochenta y seis pacientes con sarcomas de los tejidos blandos de las extremidades, de alto grado histológico, e invasión local avanzada fueron estudiados en forma prospectiva con el objeto de determinar la eficacia de la perfusión hipertérmica (PH) o la perfusión hipertérmica antiblástica (PHA) como primer paso dentro de una terapia combinada multimodal.La respuesta inmediata fue valorada en términos de la regresión tumoral, y los resultados confirmaron la sensibilidad in vivo de los sarcomas humanos a la acción antineoplásica selectiva del calor sólo o combinado con drogas (melfalán, actinomicina D, y cis-platino). La PHA ha demostrado ser más sencilla y más segura que la PH y actualmente es utilizada en forma rutinaria.En lo referente a curación a largo plazo, todos los pacientes han sido evaluados en cuanto a resultados funcionales, control locorregional, y supervivencia, de acuerdo a los diferentes programas terapéuticos.En los primeros ensayos clínicos se utilizó PH o PHA seguida de cirugía solamente. En 11 de 17 pacientes valorables tratados con PH y 17 con PHA, fue posible realizar cirugía conservadora. Se presentó una incidencia alta de relapso locorregional (24%), con tasas bajas de supervivencia global: 50.1% y 31.7% a 5 y 10 años con PH y cirugía, y 47.9% con PHA y cirugía tanto a 5 como a 10 años.El protocolo fue consecuentemente modificado para incluir una infusión intraarterial continua de Adriamicina® (ADR) (17 pacientes) o radioterapia (9 pacientes) antes de la cirugía.Los resultados logrados hasta el momento pueden ser resumidos así: (a) la cirugía conservadora con salvamento del miembro fue posible en la totalidad de los pacientes; (b) el porcentaje de falla locorregional disminuyó aproximadamente 12% después de PHA + infusión de ADR + resección, con supervivencias globales a 5 y 10 años de 77.6%, y tasas de estado libre de enfermedad a 5 y 10 años de 57.8%; (c) no se presentaron recurrencias locales en el grupo tratado con PHA + radioterapia + resección, con una tasa de supervivencia global a 5 años de 71.5% y una tasa de estado libre de enfermedad a 5 años de 50.4%.En conclusión, los aproches con terapia combinada multimodal empleados parecen haber mejorado tanto los resultados funcionales como las tasas de curación a largo plazo, aunque estos resultados aún deben ser reconfirmados en una serie mayor de pacientes.

---

Résumé Une étude prospective concernant 86 malades qui présentaient un sarcome des parties molles des membres de stade évolutif avancé a été entreprise pour déterminer l'efficacité de la perfusion hyperthermique ou de la perfusion hyperthermique antiblastique en tant que première étape d'un traitement à modalités multiples.La réponse immédiate a été appréciée en fonction de la régression tumorale. Les résultats ont confirmé la sensibilité in vivo des sarcomes humains à l'action antinéoplasique sélective de la chaleur employée isolemment ou combinée avec des drogues (melphalan, actinomycine D, et cis-platinum). La perfusion hyperthermique antiblastique s'est montrée plus simple et plus sûre que la perfusion hyperthermique, et de ce fait est devenue une méthode thérapeutique normalement employée.Pour apprécier l'action thérapeutique à long terme tous les malades ont été étudiés en tenant compte des résultats fonctionnels, du contrôle loco-régional, et de la survie obtenus selon les différentes thérapeutiques appliquées.Les premiers essais ont eu recours à l'hyperthermie thermique ou à l'hyperthermie thermique antiblastique suivie d'une intervention chirurgicale. Chez 11 des 17 malades traités par l'hyperthermie thermique, et chez 17 des 29 malades soumis à l'hyperthermie antiblastique le traitement chirurgical conservateur a pu être réalisé. Les résultats furent les suivants: fréquence importante des récidives loco-régionales (24%); taux global de survie bas: 50.1% et 31.7% à 5 ans et 10 ans après perfusion hyperthermique suivie de chirurgie, ce taux étant de 47.9% après perfusion hyperthermique antiblastique suivie de chirurgie à 5 ans et 10 ans.En fonction de ces résultats le protocole thérapeutique fut modifié en y ajoutant une transfusion intra-artérielle continue d'Adriamycine® (17 malades) ou de la radiothérapie (9 malades) avant l'intervention.Les résultats obtenus à ce jour peuvent se résumer ainsi: (a) la chirurgie conservatrice permettant de sauver un membre fonctionnel est toujours possible; (b) la poucentage d'échec régional décroit environ jusqu' à 12% après perfusion hyperthermique antiblastique associée à la perfusion d'Adriamycine® et l'excision, le taux global de survie à 5 ans et 10 ans étant de 77.6%, le taux d'absence de la maladie à 5 ans et 10 ans étant de 57.8%; (c) aucune récidive locale n'est survenue dans le groupe traité par perfusion hyperthermique antiblastique associé à la radiothérapie et à l'exérèse, le taux global de survie à 5 ans étant de 71.5% et le taux d'absence de la maladie à 5 ans étant de 50.4%.En conclusion le traitement qui a été employé associant plusieurs modalités thérapeutiques a entrainé une amélioration des résultats fonctionnels et de la cure à long terme encore que ce fait demande a été confirmé par une étude étendue à un plus grand mombre de malades.

---

---

Supported by Special Project Hyperthermia from the Italian Ministry of Health.