Review article: Detaining patients against their will: Can duty of care be used to justify detention and restraint in emergency departments?

Every day in EDs, clinicians are faced with situations where they need to decide whether to detain a patient for assessment and treatment. For patients who meet the relevant criteria, provisions of mental health legislation can be used. For other patients, clinicians often rely on so-called ‘duty of care’. This article briefly explores this complex area of law, including the relevant legislation, common law principles and grey areas. It also proposes an approach to decision-making in this area.     

Melanoma diagnosis at a specialist dermatology practice without the use of photographic surveillance

Background/Objective

Photographic aides are increasingly used in melanoma surveillance. We report melanoma characteristics detected using traditional surveillance without photographic technologies.

Methods

Retrospective study of melanomas diagnosed by three dermatologists at a private dermatology practice over 7 years. Patients underwent full skin examinations with dermoscopy and suspect lesions were excised or biopsied. Total body photography (TBP) and serial digital dermoscopic imaging (SDDI) were not used. Patient demographics, melanoma subtype and thickness, location, biopsy technique and keratinocyte cancers diagnosed at the same visit were recorded. Ratio of in situ to invasive melanomas was calculated. Melanoma risk factors were recorded for 69 randomly-selected patients.

Results

492 patients were diagnosed with 615 melanomas during 579 visits. 505 (82%) were in situ (in situ to invasive ratio of 4.6:1). Of the invasive melanomas, 85.5% had a Breslow thickness <0.8 mm, 10 (9.1%) 0.8–1 mm and 6 (5.5%) >1 mm. 43.3% of in situ melanomas were lentiginous or lentigo maligna and 41.6% were superficial spreading melanomas (SSM). Of invasive melanomas, 24.3% were lentigo maligna melanoma and 59.5% were SSM. 48.4% of melanomas were diagnosed by shave procedures. Where risk factors were known, 25% were very-high-risk and 43% had a history of melanoma. Keratinocyte carcinoma was diagnosed by biopsy at 26.1% of visits. Studies using TBP and/or SDDI report in situ to invasive ratios of 0.59:1 to 2.17:1.

Conclusion

Tradiational melanoma surveillance with immediate biopsy of suspect lesions results in high in situ to invasive ratios. Studies using photographic surveillance show lower ratios of in situ to invasive disease.     

Long‐term efalizumab therapy for patients with moderate‐to‐severe,chronic plaque psoriasis: results from an Australian expanded access program

Background Psoriasis is a chronic skin disease that can impact heavily on a patient’s well‐being. Efalizumab, a unique, targeted, biological therapy, has demonstrated efficacy in treating moderate‐to‐severe, chronic plaque psoriasis with ≤36 months of continuous therapy. The objective of this Extended Access Program (EAP) was to evaluate further the benefit of efalizumab as long‐term therapy in a real‐world clinical setting. Methods After an initial conditioning dose of efalizumab (0.7 mg/kg subcutaneously), a weekly dose of efalizumab (1.0 mg/kg) was administered for ≤21 months. Patients with reduced Psoriasis Area and Severity Index (PASI) scores (≥50%, or a score ≤8) at month 3 entered the long‐term maintenance treatment period. Results In total, 101 patients (>18 years) with severe plaque psoriasis enrolled on the EAP, of these 93 (92.1%) met all the inclusion criteria. After 3 months of treatment, 84/101 (83.2%) patients had evaluable data and entered the maintenance period. After 3 months, 57/84 (67.9%) patients had achieved PASI‐50. Using an intent‐to‐treat analysis, after 21 months of treatment, PASI‐75 and PASI‐50 were achieved by 43/101 (42.6%) and 69/101 (68.3%) of patients, respectively. Efalizumab was generally well tolerated during the 21 months of continuous therapy. Conclusion Efalizumab, 1.0 mg/kg/week, is effective and well tolerated in a ‘real world’ clinical setting, providing enduring reduction of psoriasis symptoms for up to 21 months.     

Randomized Controlled Trial of a Computer Strategy to Increase General Practitioner Preventive Care

Background. Previous interventions targeting primary care practitioners with the aim of increasing preventive care delivery have demonstrated limited effectiveness. The primary aim of this study was to assess the effectiveness of a computerized continuing medical education program to increase rates of three screening behaviors (cholesterol, blood pressure, and cervical screening) and to identify three risk behaviors (smoking, alcohol consumption, benzodiazepine use) in general practice.Methods. Nineteen general practitioners were randomly allocated to intervention or control conditions. Those given the intervention received a computerized feedback system. The intervention was delivered using a touchscreen computer located in the surgery waiting area. The preventive behaviors of interest were patient smoking, alcohol use, benzodiazepine use, and blood pressure, cholesterol and cervical screening using the Papanicolou test. Differences in performance by group in each of the outcomes was measured at baseline and 3-month follow-up. Logistic regression analyses with generalized estimating equations were conducted as the main analyses.Result. At 3-month follow-up, statistically significant differences were evident in the following outcome measures: accurate classification of benzodiazepine users (z = 2.8540, P < 0.05); accurate classification of non-benzodiazepine users (z = 2.7339, P < 0.05); accurate classification of hazardous or harmful alcohol drinkers (z = 2.3079, P < 0.02); blood pressure screening (z = 3.4136, P < 0.001); and cholesterol screening (z = 6.6313, P < 0.001).Conclusion. A computerized system of performance-specific feedback was effective at increasing some preventive care services in general practice.     

Gastroesophageal Reflux in Obesity: The Effect of Lap-Band Placement

Background: Gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) is a common condition which is often aggravated by morbid obesity. Lap-Band surgery provides effective weight loss in the morbidly obese. There have been several reports that gastric banding causes or aggravates reflux. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of Lap-Band placement on GERD. Methods: All patients with a significant history of GERD who had a Lap-Band inserted over a 2-year period were evaluated postoperatively to assess any change in impact on reflux. Resolution required absence of reflux symptoms and no anti-reflux drug therapy. Results: There were 48 (16%) of 274 consecutive patients with a significant history of reflux esophagitis requiring regular therapy preoperatively. The median age was 39 (range 23-58) and M:F ratio was 5:43. We confirm a high prevalence of GERD in patients with morbid obesity: 17% with symptoms requiring regular therapy (Community Norm 7%). Total resolution of all reflux symptoms occurred in 36 (76%) patients, improvement in 7 (14%), no change in 3 (6%), and aggravation of symptoms in 2 (4%). Patients with severe and moderate symptoms had similar improvement. Resolution or improvement was reported soon after surgery. Conclusion: Rapid and major improvement in symptoms of GERD occurs after Lap-Band placement. The placement of the band probably acts directly to reduce reflux. This result contrasts with reports which have found gastric banding causes or aggravates GERD.