Mutations within codon 306 of the
Mycobacterium tuberculosis embB gene modestly increase ethambutol (EMB) MICs. To identify other causes of EMB resistance and to identify causes of high-level resistance, we generated EMB-resistant
M. tuberculosis isolates in vitro and performed allelic exchange studies of
embB codon 406 (
embB406) and
embB497 mutations. In vitro selection produced mutations already identified clinically in
embB306,
embB397,
embB497,
embB1024, and
embC13, which result in EMB MICs of 8 or 14 μg/ml, 5 μg/ml, 12 μg/ml, 3 μg/ml, and 4 μg/ml, respectively, and mutations at
embB320,
embB324, and
embB445, which have not been identified in clinical
M. tuberculosis isolates and which result in EMB MICs of 8 μg/ml, 8 μg/ml, and 2 to 8 μg/ml, respectively. To definitively identify the effect of the common clinical
embB497 and
embB406 mutations on EMB susceptibility, we created a series of isogenic mutants, exchanging the wild-type
embB497 CAG codon in EMB-susceptible
M. tuberculosis strain 210 for the
embB497 CGG codon and the wild-type
embB406 GGC codon for either the
embB406 GCC,
embB406 TGC,
embB406 TCC, or
embB406 GAC codon. These new mutants showed 6-fold and 3- to 3.5-fold increases in the EMB MICs, respectively. In contrast to the
embB306 mutants, the isogenic
embB497 and
embB406 mutants did not have preferential growth in the presence of isoniazid or rifampin (rifampicin) at their MICs. These results demonstrate that individual
embCAB mutations confer low to moderate increases in EMB MICs. Discrepancies between the EMB MICs of laboratory mutants and clinical
M. tuberculosis strains with identical mutations suggest that clinical EMB resistance is multigenic and that high-level EMB resistance requires mutations in currently unknown loci.Ethambutol (EMB) is a first-line antituberculosis drug that is often used in combination with other drugs to treat tuberculosis and to prevent the emergence of drug resistance. EMB also has a place in the treatment of drug-resistant and multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (
2). The recent global increase in the incidence of drug-resistant tuberculosis has produced many strains that are resistant to EMB. Therefore, it is prudent to test isolates from all tuberculosis patients for their EMB susceptibility, especially when EMB is used to treat multidrug-resistant tuberculosis. Unfortunately, conventional culture-based EMB susceptibility test methods have poor intertest and interlaboratory reproducibilities (
8,
21). This has made it difficult to firmly rule out the presence of EMB resistance by the use of conventional assays. Culture-based
Mycobacterium tuberculosis drug susceptibility tests are also quite slow (
12,
20).Genetic tests for EMB resistance are potentially more rapid and more accurate than conventional culture-based resistance testing. Genetic assays identify resistance by detecting mutations that encode EMB resistance on the
M. tuberculosis chromosome, principally within the
embB gene (
5,
17,
25). The results of genetic assays can be available within hours; they have high interassay reproducibilities and have the potential to have high sensitivities (
5,
25). However, genetic testing for EMB resistance has been hindered by a persistent uncertainty concerning the role of specific mutations in EMB resistance. Initially, the role of mutations within codon 306 of the
embB gene (
embB306) was questioned. Although
embB306 mutations were present in 30 to 68% of EMB-resistant clinical isolates (
1,
13,
22), some studies had noted a widespread presence of
embB306 mutations in EMB-susceptible isolates (
1,
7,
9). The role of
embB306 mutations was firmly established to be a cause of low- and moderate-level (two to seven times the MIC for the wild type) EMB resistance in a recent allelic exchange study (
19). However, that study also demonstrated that
embB306 mutations do not in themselves cause high-level (MICs > 20 μg/ml) EMB resistance. Furthermore, the cause of EMB resistance in the 32 to 70% of clinical EMB-resistant
M. tuberculosis isolates that did not have
embB306 mutations remained an open question.Several clinical studies have suggested that other mutations in the
embCAB operon are responsible for at least some of the remaining EMB-resistant tuberculosis cases. The most commonly occurring
embCAB mutations other than
embB306 have been found in
embB406 and
embB497. Importantly, these two mutations have been detected in clinical isolates with high-level EMB resistance (
11,
14). However, other studies identified
embB406 mutations in EMB-susceptible clinical isolates (
7,
15,
23). Other mutations in the
embB and
embC genes have also been identified in EMB-resistant clinical
M. tuberculosis isolates (
6,
22,
23), but at low frequencies, making it difficult to firmly establish associations with EMB resistance. Thus, the actual role of non-
embB306 mutations in EMB resistance has not been proven.In the study described here, we examined the role of
embB mutations outside of the
embB306 codon in EMB resistance. Using in vitro-selected mutants and allelic exchange techniques, our results demonstrate that non-
embB306 mutations in the
embCAB operon play an important role in EMB resistance, but like mutations in
embB306, these mutations confer only a low to a moderate increase in EMB MICs. Our study strongly suggests that unrecognized mycobacterial gene targets for EMB resistance and high-level resistance remain to be discovered.
相似文献