Cost-effectiveness Analysis for Technology Acquisition

Background

In a developing country with limited resources, it is important to utilize the total cost visibility approach over the entire life-cycle of the technology and then analyse alternative options for acquiring technology.

Methods

The present study analysed cost-effectiveness of an “In-house” magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan facility of a large service hospital against outsourcing possibilities. Cost per unit scan was calculated by operating costing method and break-even volume was calculated. Then life-cycle cost analysis was performed to enable total cost visibility of the MRI scan in both “In-house” and “outsourcing of facility” configuration. Finally, cost-effectiveness analysis was performed to identify the more acceptable decision option.

Result

Total cost for performing unit MRI scan was found to be Rs 3,875 for scans without contrast and Rs 4,129 with contrast. On life-cycle cost analysis, net present value (NPV) of the “In-house” configuration was found to be Rs-(4,09,06,265) while that of “outsourcing of facility” configuration was Rs-(5,70,23,315). Subsequently, cost-effectiveness analysis across eight Figures of Merit showed the “In-house” facility to be the more acceptable option for the system.

Conclusion

Every decision for acquiring high-end technology must be subjected to life-cycle cost analysis.Key Words: Technology assessment, Cost benefit analysis, Cost-effectiveness analysis     

Cost-effectiveness analysis for technology acquisition

Background: In a developing country with limited resources, it is important to utilize the total cost visibility approach over the entire life-cycle of the technology and then analyse alternative options for acquiring technology.     

Total anomalous pulmonary venous connection: surgical experience in Indians

BACKGROUND: We report a retrospective analysis of the demographic. morphological and clinical profiles of patients along with results of operative repair for total anomalous pulmonary venous connection. METHODS AND RESULTS: In the last 15 years, 248 patients (168 boys, 80 girls) underwent repair for total anomalous pulmonary venous connection. Their ages ranged from I day to 24 years (median 8 months) and 145 of them were < or = 1 year of age. The patients' weight ranged from 2 to 52 kg (median 5 kg). About 70% of patients (n = 174) were less than the 50th percentile of predicted weight for age and sex. The anomalous connection was supracardiac in 134 (54%), cardiac in 80 (32.2%), infracardiac in 9 (3.6%) and mixed in 25 (10.1%) patients. Fifty (20.2%) patients had obstructed drainage and 76 patients (30.2%) had moderate or severe pulmonary arterial hypertension. Forty-five patients (18.1%) had to be operated upon on an emergency basis. All the patients were operated upon using moderately hypothermic cardiopulmonary bypass. In 114 patients, circulatory arrest was used. There were 45 (19.1%) in-hospital deaths. The major causes of early death were pulmonary arterial hypertensive crisis in 19 (7.7%) and low cardiac output syndrome in 17 (6.9%) patients. Age < or = 1 year (odds ratio 2.16; 95% confidence interval: 1.22-3.82, p=0.008), severe pulmonary arterial hypertension (odds ratio 5.86; 95% confidence interval: 2-17, p=0.001), and need for emergency surgery (odds ratio 3.65; 95% confidence interval: 1.59-8.38, p=0.002) were independent risk factors for early death. Follow-up ranged from 1 to 180 months (median 48 months). There were 4 lake deaths. Actuarial survival at 12 years was 92.6% +/- 2.8%. CONCLUSIONS: In Indian circumstances, mortality continues to be high in infants with total anomalous pulmonary venous connection. Severe pulmonary arterial hypertension appears to be the most important predictor of operative mortality. Severe malnutrition, delayed diagnosis and late referrals possibly contribute to the high mortality.     

Teratogenic effects of insulin: An experimental study on developing chick embryo

Objective:The objective was to observe the effect of insulin on chick embryos with reference to their growth and developmental defects.Results:No major malformations were observed. Decrease in weight and CRLs was lower in the experimental group as compared to their control counterparts. Values for volume of the embryo were similar in two groups.Conclusion:No obvious teratogenic effects are observed with insulin in the dose use for the study.KEY WORDS: Chick embryo, insulin, teratogen     

Hormone dependency of rat mammary carcinoma--a comparison of two assay systems.

Succinic dehydrogenase activity of the DMBA induced tumor explants cultured with or without hormones was assessed histochemically while receptors for estrogen (ER) and progesterone (PgR) were estimated from the cytosol fraction of the tumor tissue. Tumor regression following ovariectomy (OVX) was kept as the end point for determining hormone dependency. By in vitro method positive correlation was observed in 5 of 6 responsive or hormone dependent tumors, and 13 out of 14 independent tumors. Presence of receptors (ER + PgR, PgR) correlated with responsiveness in 4 of 6 tumors while their absence in the non-responsive group correlated in 6 of 14 tumors. Prolactin responsive tumors did not regress following OVX even if ER + PgR or ER/PgR were present. Using the same tumor tissue the results of hormone dependency by the two methods were identical in only 9 of 20 tumors.     

Cincinnati Prehospital Stroke Scale: reproducibility and validity

STUDY OBJECTIVE: The Cincinnati Prehospital Stroke Scale (CPSS) is a 3-item scale based on a simplification of the National Institutes of Health (NIH) Stroke Scale. When performed by a physician, it has a high sensitivity and specificity in identifying patients with stroke who are candidates for thrombolysis. The objective of this study was to validate and verify the reproducibility of the CPSS when used by prehospital providers. METHODS: The CPSS was performed and scored by a physician certified in the use of the NIH Stroke Scale (gold standard). Simultaneously, a group of 4 paramedics and EMTs scored the same patient. RESULTS: A total of 860 scales were completed on a convenience sample of 171 patients from the emergency department and neurology inpatient service. Of these patients, 49 had a diagnosis of stroke or transient ischemic attack. High reproducibility was observed among prehospital providers for total score (intraclass correlation coefficient [rI],.89; 95% confidence interval [CI],.87 to.92) and for each scale item: arm weakness, speech, and facial droop (.91,.84, and.75, respectively). There was excellent intraclass correlation between the physician and the prehospital providers for total score (rI,.92; 95% CI,.89 to.93) and for the specific items of the scale (.91,.87, and.78, respectively). Observation by the physician of an abnormality in any 1 of the 3 stroke scale items had a sensitivity of 66% and specificity of 87% in identifying a stroke patient. The sensitivity was 88% for identification of patients with anterior circulation strokes. CONCLUSION: The CPSS has excellent reproducibility among prehospital personnel and physicians. It has good validity in identifying patients with stroke who are candidates for thrombolytic therapy, especially those with anterior circulation stroke.