Evaluating clinical educators: an employer's perspective

An Australian school of nursing's attempt to introduce an evaluation process required by management for clinical educators involved in undergraduate preregistration education is discussed Reliance on student feedback and clinical agencies' perceptions of the quality of teaching were seen as inadequate mechanisms for evaluation The evaluation process adopted incorporated observation of the educators together with self-reflection on their performance We conclude that post-briefings were poorly used and generally not reflective Educators relied heavily on their clinical skills and used a limited range of teaching strategies Whilst evaluation of clinical educators was time consuming and therefore costly, it is argued that it is essential to the integrity of the course The evaluation process has provided direction for support and development of clinical educators within the context of the curriculum     

Measured visual field extent varies with peripheral stimulus flicker rate in very young children.

PURPOSE: The purpose of this article is to describe measured visual field extent in very young children in response to variation in peripheral stimulus flicker rate. METHODS: Binocular visual field extent was measured using a black, double-arc perimeter and an LED static perimetry procedure in 120 11-month-old, 120 17-month-old, and 120 30-month-old children and 40 adults. Each subject was tested with one of four flicker rates: 1 Hz, 10 Hz, 20 Hz, or 40 Hz. An interpolated estimate of the eccentricity at which 50% of subjects detected the peripheral stimulus and the mean of the farthest eccentricity at which subjects detected the peripheral stimulus were calculated for each flicker rate for each age group. RESULTS: In 11-, 17-, and 30-month-old children, but not in adults, measured visual field extent (eccentricity at which the stimulus was detected) varied significantly with rate of stimulus flicker. The largest measured visual field extent was produced by a 10-Hz stimulus and the smallest was produced by 1-Hz and 40-Hz stimuli. Measured visual field extent in children was similar to that of adults for 10-Hz flicker, but smaller than that of adults for 1-Hz, 20-Hz, and 40-Hz flicker. CONCLUSIONS: These results underscore the importance of standardizing stimulus parameters when developing tests for clinical assessment of visual fields in children. Furthermore, for longitudinal assessment of young patients, use of a 10-Hz flicker rate, in combination with the other parameters used in the present study, would help to avoid difficulties in interpretation that could arise from an interaction between age-related and disease-related changes that might occur if other stimulus flicker rates were used.     

The implications of Project 2000 and the formation of links with higher education for the professional and academic needs of nurse teachers in the United Kingdom

A national study was conducted between 1991 and 1994 to explore and describe the changing role of the nurse teacher following the introduction of Project 2000 pre-registration nursing courses. Multiple methods were used to collect data from a wide variety of respondents (nurse teachers, midwife teachers, clinical nurses, health service managers and higher education lecturers). This paper presents the findings relating to the impact of Project 2000 and the move into higher education on the continuing educational needs of nurse teachers. Views on college strategies for staff development, the changing nature of teachers'academic and professional development needs and the problems of the conflicting demands experienced are reported. The research highlights the need for clinical credibility to be clearly defined in relation to nurse teachers and for educational institutions to place more emphasis on teachers'clinical development if the rhetoric of policy is to become a reality.     

Is the diaphragm motion probability density function normally distributed?

During radiotherapy treatment planning, the margins given to the clinical target volume to form the planning target volume accounts for internal motion and set-up error. Most margin formulas assume that the underlying distributions are independent and normal. Clinical data suggests that the set-up error probability density function (pdf) can be considered to have an approximately normal distribution. However, there is evidence that internal motion does not have a normal distribution. Thus, in general, a convolution of the two pdfs should be performed to determine the total geometric error. The goals of this article were to (1) determine if the internal motion pdf due to respiration can be characterized using a normal distribution, and (2) if not, determine if the total geometric uncertainty for combining internal motion and set-up error can be characterized by a normal distribution. Sixty fluoroscopy diaphragm motion data sets were obtained using three breathing training types: free breathing, audio instruction, and visual feedback. Diaphragm motion was used as a surrogate for liver and lung cancer motion. The data were analyzed with normality tests in the following groups: (1) single motion measurements, (2) combined motion measurements for each patient, and (3) combined motion measurements for all patients. Following this analysis, the diaphragm motion pdfs were convolved with a set-up error pdf, and the standard deviation of the set-up error pdf at which the total geometric error pdf became normal was determined. At set-up error standard deviation values of at least 0.27 and 0.1 cm for free breathing, 0.57 and 0.42 cm for audio instruction, and 0.55 and 0 cm for visual feedback, for single motion measurements and combined motion measurements for each patient, respectively, total geometric error pdfs became approximately normal. When the motion measurements for all the patients were combined, diaphragm motion pdfs were approximately normal for all feedback types. Therefore, for treatment planning purposes in the absence of individual patient measurements, the diaphragm motion pdf can be considered an approximately normal distribution. However, care should be taken when determining a margin based on individual patients measurements as the total geometric error will, in general, not be normally distributed.     

Comparative evaluation of commonly used laboratory tests for post-mortem diagnosis of rabies

Animal brain samples received at WHO Collaborating Centre laboratory at National Institute of Communicable Diseases (NICD) during the years 1991-2002 were tested by Seller's stain, Fluorescent Antibody Test (FAT) and Mouse Innoculation Test (MIT) as methods of rabies diagnosis. Negri bodies on Seller's staining could be detected in 52.5% of MIT positive brains, the concordance of this test with MIT was found to be 77.8%. FAT was positive in 91.5% of MIT positive brains, though it showed concordance of 95.7% with MIT results in the total samples. 12.2% of the samples were found positive by FAT of which 1/3rd also showed the presence of Negri bodies when MIT was negative i.e. showing that the virus is present in inactivated form. Thus emphasizing the need for timely and proper collection and transportation of specimens for testing. Seller's stain and FAT give reliable diagnosis of rabies in the brain samples in majority of the cases. MIT being time-intensive test, is of academic value only in decision making as regards initiation of Post Exposure Treatment (PET), it is recommended that in cases where Seller's stain and FAT have yielded negative results the decision to initiate PET should give due consideration to the nature and circumstances of the animal bite and other epidemiological features.     

An unusual clinical presentation of bilateral schizencephaly

Summary We present a case with a characteristic magnetic resonance image (MRI) of bilateral open-lipped schizencephaly and atypical clinical presentation. The patient is still alive and in good health in her forties, she has never presented seizures, and although the motor dysfunction is well correlated with cerebral lobe involvement, neurobehavioral dysfunction is not proportional to the MR image of the cerebral malformation.

---

Un cas inhabituel de schizencéphalie bilatérale

Résumé Nous présentons un cas de schizencéphalie bilatérale ouverte caractérisé par une présentation clinique atypique et une imagerie par résonance magnétique nucléaire caractéristique. La patiente est encore vivante, en bonne santé, à plus de 40 ans, elle n'a jamais présenté de crise comitiale et, bien que les troubles moteurs soient bien corrélés aux altérations cérébrales, les troubles neuro-comportementaux ne sont pas proportionnels aux images IRM de cette malformation cérébrale.

     

The Clinical Health Economics System Simulation (CHESS): a teaching tool for systems- and practice-based learning.

Academic medical centers face barriers to training physicians in systems- and practice-based learning competencies needed to function in the changing health care environment. To address these problems, at the University of Virginia School of Medicine the authors developed the Clinical Health Economics System Simulation (CHESS), a computerized team-based quasi-competitive simulator to teach the principles and practical application of health economics. CHESS simulates treatment costs to patients and society as well as physician reimbursement. It is scenario based with residents grouped into three teams, each team playing CHESS using differing (fee-for-service or capitated) reimbursement models. Teams view scenarios and select from two or three treatment options that are medically justifiable yet have different potential cost implications. CHESS displays physician reimbursement and patient and societal costs for each scenario as well as costs and income summarized across all scenarios extrapolated to a physician's entire patient panel. The learners are asked to explain these findings and may change treatment options and other variables such as panel size and case mix to conduct sensitivity analyses in real time. Evaluations completed in 2003 by 68 (94%) CHESS resident and faculty participants at 19 U.S. residency programs preferred CHESS to a traditional lecture-and-discussion format to learn about medical decision making, physician reimbursement, patient costs, and societal costs. Ninety-eight percent reported increased knowledge of health economics after viewing the simulation. CHESS demonstrates the potential of computer simulation to teach health economics and other key elements of practice- and systems-based competencies.     

Microdissection genotyping of mixed glial and primitive neuroectodermal central nervous system neoplasm

A 22-year-old man with previous radiation treatment for childhood astrocytoma underwent resection of a right parietooccipital lesion. Histopathology revealed a malignant neoplasm with areas of astrocytic and primitive neuroectodermal components. To resolve the relationship and cellular origin, representative tissue was microdissected from several targets, obtaining a balanced mixture of each element. Nonneoplastic brain parenchyma was separately microdissected to determine polymorphic marker informativeness and to serve as an internal negative control. Despite the relatively small quantity of tissue removed for each microdissection target, sufficient material was available for reliable, balanced, polymerase chain reaction-format genotyping encompassing a panel of tumor suppressor genes and genetic loci associated with these forms of neoplasia. The findings revealed distinct discordant genotypic profiles for each of the neoplastic components. The efficacy of the approach used for molecular analysis of this complex neoplasm and the implication of the genotypic findings are discussed.     

Abrogation of DTH response and mitogenic lectin- and alloantigen-induced activation of lymphocytes by calcium inhibitors TMB-8 and BAPTA-AM

In vitro treatment of mouse lymphocytes with an intracellular calcium chelator BAPTA-AM significantly decreased lectin Concanavalin-A (Con-A)-induced and mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) mediated, alloantigen-induced lymphocyte activation as indicated by decreased percentage of lymphoblasts among the BAPTA-treated lymphocytes. In vivo treatment of mice with intracellular Ca(2+) antagonist TMB-8 was found to substantially impair delayed type hypersensitivity (DTH; cell mediated immune) response, as indicated by decreased footpad swelling on tuberculin challenge of mice sensitized with BCG, after a single treatment with a low dose of 0.01mg of TMB-8 per mouse. Interestingly, a second injection of a higher dose of TMB-8 (0.1mg per mouse) resulted in very significant (p=0.001) abrogation of DTH as indicated by complete absence of swelling of foot pad after PPD challenge in BCG-primed treated mice. All mice in this group showed fully impaired DTH response. Lymphocytes of allosensitized mice gave a significantly higher (p<0.05) MLR response than the na?ve mice. However, a single treatment of allosensitized mice with 0.1mg TMB-8 resulted into a lower MLR response, comparable in magnitude to that of untreated na?ve mice.     

Sequence diversity of the nucleoprotein gene of iris yellow spot virus (genus Tospovirus, family Bunyaviridae) isolates from the western region of the United States

Summary. Iris yellow spot virus (IYSV), a tentative virus species in the genus Tospovirus and family Bunyaviridae, is considered a rapidly emerging threat to onion production in the western United States (US). The present study was undertaken to determine the sequence diversity of IYSV isolates from infected onion plants grown in California, Colorado, Idaho, Oregon, Utah and Washington. Using primers derived from the small RNA of IYSV, the complete sequence of the nucleoprotein (NP) gene of each isolate was determined and the sequences compared. In addition, a shallot isolate of IYSV from Washington was included in the study. The US isolates of IYSV shared a high degree of sequence identity (95 to 99%) with one another and to previously reported isolates. Phylogenetic analyses showed that with the exception of one isolate from central Oregon and one isolate from California, all the onion and shallot isolates from the western US clustered together. This cluster also included onion and lisianthus isolates from Japan. A second distinct cluster consisted of isolates from Australia (onion), Brazil (onion), Israel (lisianthus), Japan (alstroemeria), the Netherlands (iris) and Slovenia (leek). The IYSV isolates evaluated in this study appear to represent two distinct groups, one of which largely represents isolates from the western US. Understanding of the population structure of IYSV would potentially provide insights into the molecular epidemiology of this virus.