Should sperm donors be paid? A survey of the attitudes of the general public

Gamete donation in assisted reproduction is an accepted treatment option for certain infertile couples. Traditionally, men donating spermatozoa have been paid a nominal fee, whilst women donating oocytes have not. The issue of payment for sperm donors has recently attracted attention following the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority's (HFEA) suggestion that such payment may be withdrawn. Prior to the final meeting of the HFEA working party which is examining this issue, here we report the results of a survey designed to solicit opinion on whether sperm donors should be paid, to identify social or other factors which influence this opinion, and to examine the influence of financial incentive on potential donors. We surveyed 717 individuals in three distinct groups: the general public, students (potential donors), and infertility patients (potential recipients). The majority of the potential donor group (students) was in favour of paying sperm donors, as were infertility patients. In contrast the general public was not. The opinion of the general public on this issue was influenced by their prior knowledge of whether donors were paid: those of the general public favouring the payment of sperm donors had a prior awareness that such payments were made. Although not in favour of paying sperm donors, the general public overwhelmingly approved of the use of donated spermatozoa for the treatment of infertile couples, and thought that ways should be sought to increase the availability of donor spermatozoa for the treatment of infertility and for research purposes. Within the potential donor group (students), the majority indicated that financial reward was an important factor which would influence their decision to donate spermatozoa. As the majority of both the potential recipients and potential donors feels that sperm donors should be paid, perhaps the views of these groups should carry significant weight when the decision whether or not to withdraw payment is taken. This is especially the case in view of the fact that the majority of the general public is in favour of the use of donated spermatozoa for the treatment of infertile couples.      

Continuous antihistamine treatment controls allergic inflammation and reduces respiratory morbidity in children with mite allergy

BACKGROUND: Allergic reaction is characterized by a complex inflammatory process. Some of the new antihistamines have antiallergic effects and can affect the inflammatory cell recruitment via adhesion molecule downregulation. We aimed to assess in a 12-month study whether continuous treatment with an antihistamine (terfenadine) can reduce respiratory symptoms and local inflammation in children with mite allergy. METHODS: The study was double-blind and placebo-controlled: it involved two parallel groups of children suffering from rhinoconjunctivitis and/or mild intermittent asthma due to mite allergy. They received either terfenadine (1 mg/kg per body weight per day) or placebo for 1 year. Nasal, conjunctival, and bronchial symptoms were recorded by diary cards; at each of the programmed control visits, a nasal scraping for inflammatory cells and ICAM-1 was performed. Some additional clinical parameters were also recorded: days of school absence, extra visits for acute respiratory symptoms, and days of hospital admission. RESULTS: Only children treated with terfenadine achieved significant control of symptoms (P<0.05 in 8 out of 12 months) and allergic inflammation, as shown by inflammatory cell infiltrate and ICAM-1 expression at nasal level (P<0.001), and had significantly fewer extra visits and school absences than the placebo group (P<0.03). No side-effects were reported in either group. CONCLUSIONS: The present study demonstrates that continuous terfenadine treatment (1 mg/kg body weight per day) could decrease respiratory symptoms and allergic inflammation, and it had an additional antiallergic effect in reducing ICAM-1 expression on nasal epithelial cells. Therefore, the present results confirm the efficacy of a long-term therapeutic strategy in controlling allergic inflammation.     

Dopamine autoreceptor agonists: resolution and pharmacological activity of 2,6-diaminotetrahydrobenzothiazole and an aminothiazole analogue of apomorphine

The enantiomers of the aminothiazole analogues of the known dopaminergic agonists apomorphine (1) and 2-aminohydroxytetralin (2) have been prepared. The absolute configurations of the enantiomers of 2,6-diaminotetrahydrobenzothiazole have been established by X-ray crystallographic analysis. Dopamine (DA) autoreceptor agonist activities of the compounds were evaluated. Testing revealed (-)-5, the S enantiomer, to be the most active compound tested (inhibition of GBL accelerated dopamine synthesis and inhibition of alpha-methyltyrosine-induced decline of DA). In addition (-)-5 does not exhibit stereotyped behavior, suggesting a pronounced selectivity for DA autoreceptors.     

Academic uroradiology: the future

Radiologic education, research, and the practice of radiology will be of the highest quality in the future if academic departments stress organ-system subspecialization while continuing to integrate and interface with technique-based specialists. Planning should begin now to effect an orderly progression to an organ-system-based subspecialty structure for radiology training in general and for uroradiology specifically. Uroradiologists should remain as central consultants to their clinical counterparts, working collaboratively with urologists in clinical endeavors of mutual relevance. More fellowships in uroradiology should be offered that attempt to incorporate all imaging methods and procedures into the curriculum. These issues are addressed in the context of patient care, service, education, and cost containment.     

Measuring philosophy: a philosophy index

Chiropractic philosophy which has been debated since the founding of chiropractic in 1895 has taken on new vigour over the past ten years. Despite a growing body of literature examining chiropractic philosophy, the chiropractic profession continues to be divided over this issue. To date, there has been little research examining the meaning of chiropractic philosophy to rank-and-file practitioners.The purpose of this paper is to present a philosophy index, based on thirteen items, which measures Canadian chiropractors'' attitudes toward chiropractic philosophy. The internal consistency alpha reliability coefficient was .7700. Trends in practice philosophy were compared between males and females, among eight geopolitical regions, between those who attended the Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College and those who attended other colleges, between those who graduated before 1983 and those who graduated after 1983, and income. The data indicate that distinct, identifable groups (empiricists, rationalists and moderates) exist within the profession, and that the profession is divided with respect to chiropractic epistemology, the role of science, chiropractic''s status as an alternative form of healing and the etiology of disease. In addition, the data reveal statistically significant differences in attitudes toward philosophy across the country and college attended. The authors argue that more research needs to be done in order to understand more fully the meaning of chiropractic, its impact on practice and professional identity.     

The dopamine agonist pramipexole scavenges hydroxyl free radicals induced by striatal application of 6-hydroxydopamine in rats: an in vivo microdialysis study

Hydroxyl free radical production seems to play an important role in the pathogenesis of Parkinson's disease. In the present study, we investigated the dopamine agonists pramipexole and pergolide as well as the nitrone compound S-PBN (N-tert-butyl-alpha-(2-sulfophenyl)nitrone) to reduce hydroxyl radical formation. Microdialysis experiments were carried out in non-anaesthetized Wistar rats. Salicylate was incorporated into the perfusion fluid to measure indirectly hydroxyl radicals indicated by 2,3-dihydroxybenzoic acid (2,3-DHBA). Local perfusion with 0.2 or 2 nmol/2 microl/min 6-hydroxydopamine (6-OHDA) via the microdialysis probe significantly increased 2,3-DHBA levels 14-fold and 47-fold, respectively. Systemic application of either pergolide (0.05 mg/kg) or pramipexole (1 mg/kg) failed to significantly reduce 6-OHDA-induced hydroxyl radical production. In contrast, a 40 min pretreatment with pramipexole (2 and 10 nmol/2 microl/min via the probe) before onset of 6-OHDA perfusion, significantly attenuated 2, 3-DHBA levels compared with vehicle controls. S-PBN pretreatment (2 nmol/2 microl/min) was not effective to reduce 2,3-DHBA levels. In conclusion, pramipexole was able to reduce hydroxyl radical levels induced by 6-OHDA in vivo after local application. This property of pramipexole may be beneficial under conditions of enhanced hydroxyl radical formation in parkinsonian brains and may add to its well known dopamine D(2)-like receptor agonistic effects.