Selecting the best and brightest: A comparison of residency match processes in the United States and Canada

BACKGROUND:

Selecting candidates for plastic surgery residency training remains a challenge. In the United States, academic measures (United States Medical Licensing Exam Step I scores, medical school class rank and publications) are used as primary criteria for candidate selection for residency. In contrast, Canadian medical education de-emphasizes academic measures by using a pass-fail grading system. As a result, choosing residents from many qualified applicants may pose a challenge for Canadian programs without objective measures of academic success.

METHODS:

A 25-question online survey was distributed to program directors of Canadian plastic surgery residency-training programs. Program directors commented on number of yearly residents and applicants; application sections (ranked in importance using a Likert scale); interview invitation and rank-order list determination; and their satisfaction with the selection process.

RESULTS:

Ten Canadian plastic surgery program directors responded (90.9% response rate). The most important application components determining invitation to interview were letters of reference from a plastic surgeon (mean importance of 5.0 on the Likert scale), clinical electives in plastic surgery (mean 4.6) and electives with their program (mean 4.5). Applicants invited for interview were assessed on the quality of their responses to questions, maturity and personality. The majority of program directors agreed that a clinical elective with their program was important for consideration on their rank-order list. Program directors were neutral on their satisfaction with the selection process.

CONCLUSION:

Canadian plastic surgery residency programs emphasize clinical electives with their program and letters of reference from colleagues when selecting applicants for interviews. In contrast to their American counterparts, Canadian program directors rely on clinical interactions with prospective residents in the absence of objective academic measures.     

Malaria morbidity,treatment-seeking behaviour,and mortality in a cohort of young children in rural Burkina Faso

OBJECTIVE: To describe the pattern of fever-associated morbidity, treatment-seeking behaviour for fever episodes, and cause-specific mortality in young children of a malaria-holoendemic area in rural Burkina Faso. METHODS: In a longitudinal community-based intervention study, 709 representative children aged 6-31 months were followed daily over 6 months (including the main malaria transmission period) through village-based field staff. RESULTS: Of 1848 disease episodes, 1640 (89%) were fever episodes, and of those, 894 (55%) were attributed to malaria (fever + > or =5000 parasites/microl). Eighty-five percent of fever episodes were treated, mainly with chloroquine and paracetamol, 69% of treatments took place in households, 16% in local health centres, 13% in villages, and 1% in hospitals. Treatment-seeking in a health centre or hospital was associated with accessibility and disease severity. Cerebral malaria and malnutrition-associated diarrhoea were the most frequently diagnosed causes of death. While most children with a post-mortem diagnosis of diarrhoea had not received any treatment, children who died of malaria had often received insufficient treatment. In particular, there was a lack of an appropriate second-line treatment at formal health services after chloroquine treatment had failed to resolve symptoms. CONCLUSIONS: These findings call for more effective prevention and treatment of malaria, malnutrition and diarrhoea in rural African communities, as well as for better supervision of existing malaria treatment guidelines in formal health services.     

Childhood diabetic neuropathy: a clinical and electrophysiological study

Clinical diabetic neuropathy in childhood is rare, but electrophysiological involvement of the peripheral nerve is more frequent. We assessed clinically and electrophysiologically the peripheral nervous system of 69 children and adolescents suffering from diabetes mellitus (DM). The mean age of the patients was 12.8 years and the mean age at onset of DM was 6.8 years with a mean disease duration of 6.3 years. Seven patients (10%) had clinical neuropathy of which ankle jerk reflex abolition was the most frequent sign. Twenty patients (29%) had a neurophysiological neuropathy prevalently affecting the lower limbs. Peripheral neuropathy was correlated with patient age, older age at onset, duration of DM, height and poor glycaemic control.     

Progesterone receptor gene polymorphism is associated with decreased risk for breast cancer by age 50

In a population-based case-control study for breast cancer before the age of 51 years, 554 cases and 559 age-matched controls were genotyped for the polymorphic progesterone receptor allele PROGINS. Breast cancer risk was decreased in women carrying the PROGINS allele. The odds ratio adjusted for age and study region was 0.76 [95% confidence interval (CI), 0.58-1.00]. Compared with wild-type A1/A1 homozygotes, the odds ratio for A1/A2 heterozygotes and A2/A2 homozygotes was 0.82 (95% CI, 0.62-1.08) and 0.27 (95% CI, 0.10-0.74), respectively, suggesting a gene dosage effect of the A2 allele. There was suggestive evidence for a differential effect by menopausal status (P = 0.07) and by family history of breast cancer (P = 0.15).     

Emphysema in the renal allograft

Two diabetic patients in whom emphysematous pyelonephritis developed after renal transplantation are described. Clinical recognition of this unusual and serious infection is masked by the effects of immunosuppression. Abdominal radiographic, ultrasound, and computed tomography findings are discussed. The clinical presentation includes urinary tract infection, sepsis, and acute tubular malfunction of the allograft in insulin-dependent diabetics.